Sign in

You're signed outSign in or to get full access.

AI

Alto Ingredients, Inc. (ALTO)·Q4 2024 Earnings Summary

Executive Summary

  • Q4 2024 was operationally challenged: revenue fell to $236.3M with a gross loss of $1.4M and adjusted EBITDA of -$7.7M, driven by lower selling prices, derivative losses, and asset impairments tied to cost actions; EPS was -$0.57 .
  • Management executed restructuring: cold-idled Magic Valley, cut headcount by 16%, and integrated Eagle Alcohol—actions that reset the base (over $30M in impairments/acq. expenses in Q4) and are expected to drive approximately $8M annualized cost savings beginning Q2 2025 .
  • Strategic repositioning: acquired an adjacent beverage-grade liquid CO2 processor at Columbia, immediately accretive with ~2-year payback and capacity >70k tons; initiated ISCC-certified ethanol exports to the EU; exploring asset sales, a merger, or other strategic alternatives .
  • Consensus estimates from S&P Global for Q4 2024 were unavailable; framing catalysts include strategic review, early 2025 portfolio actions, and cost savings converting to P&L from Q2 2025 onward (subject to margin environment) [functions.GetEstimates error].

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

  • What Went Well

    • “Immediately accretive” acquisition of a beverage-grade liquid CO2 processor at Columbia with a “compelling payback of approximately two years,” supporting Columbia economics and offering capacity to >70k tons annually .
    • Pekin operational improvements: production utilization at nameplate 100M gallons post-outage; Q4 Pekin production up 3.8M gallons YoY (+7%), with an additional ~8M gallons targeted in 2025; ISCC certifications enabled EU exports starting in Q4 .
    • Liquidity preserved: YE cash $35.5M and total borrowing availability $88.1M (incl. $65M term facility, subject to conditions) .

  • What Went Wrong

    • Macro margin pressure: average sales price/gal fell to $1.88 (vs $2.24 LY), reducing net sales by $38M YoY in Q4; crush margin decline (~$0.18/gal) adversely impacted gross profit by ~$8.7M .
    • Western operations profitability: Magic Valley’s economics impaired by high delivered corn basis and weaker protein/corn oil returns tied to broader soy crush/renewable diesel dynamics—resulting in cold-idle and $21.4M impairment .
    • Non-GAAP headwinds: realized derivative losses increased to $3.5M (vs $2.3M LY), driving adjusted EBITDA to -$7.7M (vs +$3.5M LY); Q4 net loss attributable to common stockholders was -$42.0M, or -$0.57 .

Financial Results

MetricQ4 2023Q3 2024Q4 2024
Net Sales ($M)$273.6 $251.8 $236.3
Gross Profit (Loss) ($M)$(2.5) $6.0 $(1.4)
Adjusted EBITDA ($M)$3.5 $12.2 $(7.7)
Net Loss Attributable to Common ($M)$(19.3) $(2.8) $(42.0)
EPS (Basic & Diluted)$(0.26) $(0.04) $(0.57)
Street Estimates (Revenue / EPS)UnavailableUnavailableUnavailable
  • Drivers: lower average sales price/gal ($1.88 vs $2.24 LY) and market crush margin down ~$0.18/gal; realized derivative losses were $3.5M in Q4 2024; non-cash impairments and acquisition-related expenses >$30M reset the baseline .

Segment net sales (Q4 2024):

SegmentQ4 2024 Net Sales ($M)
Pekin Campus$142.5
Marketing & Distribution$40.1
Western Production$54.1
Corporate & Other$2.8
Intersegment Eliminations$(3.1)
Net Sales as Reported$236.3

Key KPIs

KPIQ4 2023Q3 2024Q4 2024
Total Gallons Sold (MM)92.5 96.8 95.1
Specialty Alcohol Gallons (MM)20.1 22.5 21.7
Sales Price per Gallon – Total ($/gal)$2.24 $2.06 $1.88
Corn Cost per Bushel – Total ($/bu)$5.46 $4.68 $4.63
PLATTS Ethanol Price ($/gal)$1.96 $1.81 $1.60

Balance sheet and liquidity (YE 2024): Cash $35.5M; borrowing availability $88.1M (operating line $23.1M; term loan $65.0M, subject to conditions) .

Guidance Changes

MetricPeriodPrevious GuidanceCurrent Guidance / StatusChange
Annualized cost savings (headcount -16%)From Q2 2025None disclosedApproximately $8M annually beginning Q2 2025; Opex/COS split: ~$7.8M, 74% COGS / 26% SG&A (run-rate) New
Magic Valley facilityEffective 12/31/2024OperatingCold idled; operating as a terminal to offset fixed costs Lowered capacity
Columbia CO2 processor acquisitionClosed 1/1/2025NoneImmediately accretive; ~56k tons annual output, >70k tons capacity; ~2-year payback; amended long-term offtake New
Strategic alternatives2025N/AConsidering asset sales, merger, or other strategic transactions New
Quantitative revenue/margin guidance2025NoneNone givenUnchanged

Earnings Call Themes & Trends

TopicPrevious Mentions (Q2 2024 / Q3 2024)Current Period (Q4 2024)Trend
Cost actions/footprintQ2: Incurred outage costs; Magic Valley operations resumed early July; Q3: operating improvements at Pekin, gross profit +40% YoY Cold-idled Magic Valley; headcount -16%; ~$8M annualized savings from Q2’25 Accelerated restructuring
Columbia economics/CO2Not highlighted in Q2; Q3 focused on TSA with Vault for Pekin CCS Acquired adjacent beverage-grade CO2 processor; accretive, ~2-year payback; >70k tons capacity Positive/structural improvement
CCS at PekinQ2: CCS as a strategic initiative; Q3: TSA executed with Vault 44.01 EPA Class VI app submitted; Illinois pipeline moratorium through July 2026; likely multi-year timeline (potential 2029–2030) Extended timeline but advancing
EU exports (ISCC)Not in Q2; Q3: preparing for lower-carbon opportunities ISCC-certified exports to EU commenced in Q4; plan to expand in 2025 Positive margin optionality
Western assets/marginsQ2–Q3: Western cost pressure; lower production Magic Valley unprofitable given corn basis/soy crush dynamics; idled; Columbia stabilized via CO2 Mixed: one idled, one strengthened
Derivatives/commodityQ2: realized losses; Q3: realized gains aided adj. EBITDA Q4: realized losses $3.5M; unrealized gains +$5.5M Volatile

Management Commentary

  • “We implemented cost saving initiatives, including cold idling our Magic Valley plant and lowering total company headcount by 16%. We expect these staffing reductions to save approximately $8 million annually beginning in the second quarter of 2025.” — CEO Bryon McGregor .
  • “Our restructuring has improved Alto’s financial position going forward… we recognized over $30 million in asset impairments and prior acquisition-related expenses, which reset our base.” — CFO Rob Olander .
  • “This [CO2] transaction… has a compelling payback of approximately two years.” — CEO Bryon McGregor .
  • “We began exporting certified product to Europe in Q4 and anticipate expanding exports further in 2025.” — CEO Bryon McGregor .

Q&A Highlights

  • Carbon monetization mix: Columbia is advantaged for premium liquid CO2 in a supply-constrained Northwest; CCS is less apparent there vs Pekin; CO2 processor supports long-term contracted premium sales .
  • 45Z/45Q positioning: Columbia is within “striking distance” of 45Z eligibility pending rule codification; management will update as regulations finalize .
  • Strategic alternatives: Management is considering “all options” (asset sales/merger/other) but will only update when actions occur .
  • CCS timeline: With EPA Class VI approval estimated at ~2 years, plus equipment/technology lead times, contribution could be late decade (potentially 2029–2030), with scope to accelerate depending on supply chains .
  • Columbia outlook: Without the CO2 acquisition, Western assets were at risk; the deal is called a “game changer” for Columbia and can ramp CO2 output toward >70k tons using only a portion of site CO2 .

Estimates Context

  • Wall Street consensus for Q4 2024 (revenue and EPS) from S&P Global was unavailable at the time of analysis due to provider request limits; we cannot assert a beat/miss versus consensus for the quarter [functions.GetEstimates error].
  • Given the structural changes (Magic Valley idle, cost resets, Columbia CO2 uplift), forward Street models may need to recalibrate mix, volume, and cost run-rates from Q2 2025 onward, and incorporate the absence of Magic Valley production alongside potential EU export premiums .

Key Takeaways for Investors

  • Restructuring inflection ahead: ~$8M annualized cost savings starting Q2 2025 should strengthen adjusted EBITDA run-rate if crush margins normalize; monitor commodity curves and LCFS/credit markets for earnings sensitivity .
  • Western footprint reset reduces drag: Idling Magic Valley removes persistent losses; Columbia’s CO2 processor materially improves site economics and asset value with ~2-year payback .
  • Pekin utilization and EU option: Nameplate utilization enables incremental specialty alcohol volumes; ISCC-certified exports create margin optionality vs domestic fuel markets .
  • Balance sheet adequate for near term: YE cash $35.5M and $88.1M in borrowing availability provide liquidity to navigate volatility and integrate CO2 acquisition .
  • Strategic review is a catalyst: Potential asset sales or merger could re-rate the equity; timing is uncertain, but formal consideration is active .
  • Watch derivatives and corn/ethanol spreads: Q4 derivative losses and weaker selling prices pressured results; realized vs unrealized swings remain a key volatility vector .
  • CCS remains a long-dated upside: TSA in place, Class VI submitted; timeline likely late decade; regulatory clarity (Illinois moratorium, EPA queue, 45Z) and financing are gating items .

Notes:

  • Financials, segments, and KPIs are sourced from the company’s Q4 2024 8-K/press release and call .
  • Prior quarter references from Q3 and Q2 2024 press releases .
  • S&P Global consensus estimates were unavailable at time of request [functions.GetEstimates error].