AMSF Q2 2024: 2.7% Premium Growth, 1.48 ELCM Amid 8–9% Cuts
- Consistent Business Growth: The company reported 2.7% voluntary debt premium growth this quarter and has achieved growth in policy count for five consecutive quarters, indicating sustained momentum in expanding its book of business.
- Improving Underwriting Metrics: An increase in the ELCM to 1.48 on a year-over-year basis reflects adaptive pricing and disciplined underwriting in a competitive environment, supporting long‑term profitability.
- Proactive Claims and Reserve Management: Executives highlighted proactive claims handling and robust reserving practices—demonstrated by strong favorable reserve development—underscoring the carrier’s effective risk management and its ability to adjust to market conditions.
- Lower favorable reserve development: The favorable reserve development decreased from $10.9 million in Q2 2023 to $8.1 million this quarter, which could indicate weakening claims management performance.
- Rising expense ratio: Increased investments in sales and underwriting have driven the expense ratio up by 90 basis points over six months, potentially pressuring overall margins.
- Competitive market pressures with declining approved loss costs: Approved loss costs are down by 8–9%, which, amid a competitive market with softer rate environments, may negatively impact underwriting profitability.
-
Growth Strategy
Q: Is policy count growth sustainable?
A: Management highlighted improving pipeline efficiency and agent engagement that drove 2.7% voluntary premium growth and consistent policy count increases over five quarters, underscoring a broad-based, organic growth approach. -
Underwriting Margin
Q: What was the Q2 ELCM value?
A: The reported ELCM of 1.48 reflects disciplined underwriting and proactive pricing despite compressed loss cost pressures in a competitive market. -
Pricing & Loss Cost Outlook
Q: When will loss costs bottom out?
A: They cautioned that with approved loss costs declining 8–9%, rising combined ratios may eventually prompt rate adjustments, especially with factors like Florida’s reimbursement changes being closely monitored. -
Reserve Development
Q: Why is reserve development lower this quarter?
A: Favorable development was $8M this quarter versus $10.9M previously, attributed to timing differences in case resolutions and consistent reserving practices that reflect individual claim outcomes. -
Retention Management
Q: How do rate hikes impact retention?
A: While pricing adjustments are necessary for underwriting profitability, management maintains that deep account knowledge and proactive service help sustain strong retention levels even if rates are adjusted. -
Audit Premium Comparison
Q: What was last year’s Q3 audit premium?
A: The Q3 ’23 audit premium stood at $5.6M, compared to the current quarter’s $4.8M, reflecting variable impacts from wage inflation on premium volumes. -
Expense Ratio Trends
Q: Why did the expense ratio rise 90 bps?
A: The increase is due to upfront investments in sales and underwriting functions aimed at driving future growth, with expectations that expenses will level off over time. -
Large Claims Frequency
Q: How many claims exceeded $1M in six months?
A: In the past six months, there were only 4 claims over $1M, indicative of proactive claims management and historically low frequency of high-severity losses. -
Policy Growth Source
Q: Is growth concentrated in specific channels?
A: Growth has been broad-based across independent agents with no concentration in a single distribution channel or geography, reflecting enhanced pipeline efficiency. -
Severity Costs Outlook
Q: How will Florida fee changes affect severity?
A: Although Florida’s fee schedule increases may pressure reimbursement levels, established provider networks help mitigate the cost impact, and such factors are already being integrated into pricing strategies. -
Construction Market Trends
Q: What is the impact of wage inflation?
A: Wage inflation of around 6% is steadily boosting insured payrolls among small and midsized employers, supporting overall premium growth despite a challenging market environment.
Research analysts covering AMERISAFE.