Blue Foundry Bancorp - Earnings Call - Q3 2025

Executive Summary

• Q3 showed continued core progress despite a small net loss: NIM expanded 6 bps to 2.34%, net interest income rose to $12.2M, deposits grew $77.1M (core +$18.6M) and loans +$41.9M; tangible book value reached $15.14 per share.
• Results modestly missed S&P Global consensus: EPS (-$0.10) vs -$0.095* and “Revenue” (proxy) $12.02M* vs $12.35M*; Q2 EPS beat but revenue missed slightly (context below). Values retrieved from S&P Global.
• Asset quality remained sound overall; NPLs rose to $11.4M (0.66% of loans) driven by one $5.3M commercial credit; management does not believe principal is at risk; ACL was 0.81% and coverage 121%.
• Management emphasized deposit mix shift (de‑emphasize CDs, more MMAs), 2026 repricing tailwind (notably in multifamily), and cost control; Q4 NIM expected roughly flat before improvement in 2026; Q4 opex expected “high $13M/low $14M”.
• Capital return continued: 837,388 shares repurchased at $9.09 (500k via a private block); 730k shares remained under the plan at quarter-end; tangible equity to tangible assets 14.58%.

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

• What Went Well

  • Net interest margin expanded again to 2.34% (+6 bps QoQ; +52 bps YoY) as asset yields increased and funding costs eased; net interest income rose to $12.2M (+$0.55M QoQ).
  • Healthy franchise growth: deposits +$77.1M QoQ (core +$18.6M) and loans +$41.9M QoQ; uninsured/uncollateralized deposits ~13% of total.
  • Capital and TBV strengthened: tangible equity/tangible assets 14.58%; tangible book per share $15.14; CEO: “tangible book value exceeded $15 per share … as profitability slowly continues to improve, we expect market valuation to follow.”.

• What Went Wrong

  • Bottom line remains negative: net loss of $1.9M (EPS -$0.10), with PPNR still modestly negative (-$1.28M) as the efficiency ratio remained elevated at 110%.
  • Nonperforming loans increased to $11.4M (0.66% of loans), largely from a single $5.3M commercial credit; coverage ratio fell to 121% given the NPL increase.
  • Opex rose $347k QoQ (compensation and professional services), and management cited competitive deposit markets in Northern NJ that require rate discipline and product shifts.

Transcript

Operator (participant)

Good morning and welcome to the Blue Foundry Bancorp's third quarter 2025 earnings call. Comments made during today's call may include forward-looking statements, which are based on management's current expectations and are subject to uncertainty and changes in circumstances. Blue Foundry encourages all participants to refer to the full disclaimer contained in this morning's earnings release, which has been posted to the investor relations page on bluefoundrybanc.com. During the call, management will refer to non-GAAP measures, which exclude certain items from reported results. Please refer to today's earnings release for reconciliations of these non-GAAP measures. As a reminder, this event is being recorded. Your line will be muted for the duration of the call. After the speaker's remarks, there will be a question and answer session. I'll now hand over to the President and CEO, James Nesci, to begin.

James Nesci (CEO)

Thank you, Operator. Good morning and welcome to our third quarter earnings call. I'm joined today by our Chief Financial Officer, Kelly Piperaro. She will provide a detailed financial review after I share updates on our strategy and recent progress. Earlier this morning, we reported a quarterly net loss of $1.9 million and a quarterly pre-provision net loss of $1.3 million. Both metrics have improved compared to the prior quarter. During the third quarter, we advanced our core objectives of growing core deposits, diversifying our loan portfolio to enhance risk-adjusted returns, and expanding our net interest margin. The progress against these strategic initiatives better positions us for continued growth and long-term value creation. Deposits increased by $77.1 million, loans grew by $41.9 million, and net interest margin expanded by six basis points. Capital remained strong, and we were able to increase tangible book value per share.

Our loan growth was driven by continued expansion in our commercial real estate and consumer loan portfolios. Our commercial portfolio grew by $7.2 million, reflecting strong origination activity of $81.3 million, including approximately $40 million in owner-occupied commercial real estate and commercial and industrial segments, offset by $66.8 million in payoffs. Our consumer loan portfolio increased by $38 million in the third quarter, supported by purchases of unsecured consumer loans with credit reserves. This growth allows us to improve yields while maintaining prudent credit risk. Our loan pipeline remains healthy, with over $41 million in executed letters of intent, primarily in commercial lending, with anticipated weighted average rates above 7%. Year to date, our relationship-driven approach has enabled us to grow core deposits by over 10% and commercial deposits by over 17%.

Our net interest margin expanded by six basis points to 2.34%, supported by a nine basis point increase in asset yields and a four basis point reduction in the cost of liabilities. Net interest income was $12.2 million, up $551,000 from the prior quarter. We remain focused on disciplined capital management and enhancing shareholder value. Tangible book value per share increased to $15.14 per share. During the quarter, we repurchased over 837,000 shares at a weighted average price of $9.09 per share, well below our tangible book value. Since instituting share repurchases, we have repurchased 8.65 million shares. Liquidity and capital remain strong. At the end of the third quarter, we had $423 million in borrowing capacity and an additional $178 million in unencumbered securities. Tangible equity to tangible assets stood at 14.58%, and we remain well capitalized with capital ratios among the highest in the industry.

With robust capital, ample liquidity, and a focus on deepening commercial relationships, we believe Blue Foundry Bancorp is positioned for continued growth. We expect downward rate movements, which will benefit our funding costs, and anticipated repricing in our loan portfolio to have a favorable impact on our net interest margin over time. With that, I'll turn the call over to Kelly for a deeper look at our financials. Kelly.

Kelly Piperaro (CFO)

Thank you, Jim, and good morning, everyone. As Jim mentioned, we reported a net loss of $1.9 million for the third quarter, or $0.10 per diluted share. This compares favorably to the $2 million loss in the prior quarter. This improvement was driven by an increase in net interest income, partially offset by an increase in provision for credit losses and an increase in operating expenses. Net interest income increased by $551,000 versus prior quarter to $12.2 million, driven by $693,000 of additional interest income, representing an 11.8% annualized increase. The yield on average interest-earning assets rose to 4.67%, while the cost of average interest-bearing liabilities declined to 2.72%. These improvements contributed to a six basis point expansion in our net interest margin. Non-interest expense increased by $347,000, primarily due to higher compensation and benefit expense and higher professional services expenses.

The increase in compensation and benefits is due to day counts and the prior quarter having higher forfeitures of equity grants. We recorded a provision for credit loss of $589,000, primarily driven by deterioration in economic forecasts. Our allowance methodology continues to place greater weight on baseline and adverse economic scenarios. The allowance for credit loss was 0.81% of gross loans, up one basis point from the prior quarter, primarily reflecting changes in economic forecasts, while charge-offs remained minimal at $25,000. Credit quality remained sound overall, and we continue to manage risk with discipline. During the quarter, a $5.3 million multifamily loan was added to non-performing loans. Currently, we do not believe that there is a risk of loss of principal associated with this credit.

Total non-performing loans were $11.4 million, or 66 basis points of total loans on September 30, up from $6.3 million, or 38 basis points at the prior quarter end, reflecting the increase in non-performing loans. Moving on to the balance sheet, we saw total loan growth of $41.9 million for the quarter. We continue to focus on optimizing our portfolio composition, and we are encouraged by the growth in owner-occupied commercial real estate and commercial and industrial loans this quarter. Our available for sale securities portfolio, with a modified duration of approximately 3.9 years, decreased by $10.3 million, primarily due to calls and maturity, partially offset by an improvement in the unrealized loss position. Deposits grew by $77.1 million, with core deposits increasing by $18.6 million. Brokered deposits increased $50 million, helping us manage funding costs and support loan growth.

Borrowings decreased by $42 million as we allowed them to roll off and replace them with brokered deposits. With that, Jim and I are happy to take your questions.

Operator (participant)

Thank you very much. To ask a question, please press star followed by one on your telephone keypad now. If you change your mind, please press star followed by two. In preparing to ask your question, please ensure your device is unmuted locally. Our first question comes from Justin Crowley from Piper Sandler. Your line is open, Justin. Please go ahead.

Justin Crowley (Senior Research Analyst)

Hey, good morning. I wanted to start off on the margin here. I saw continued progress with the lag from cuts we got last year. With the cuts that we got late this quarter, very likely another one today and more to follow. Can you talk a little bit about how you've already maybe responded on the deposit side and just what your expectations are for matching the Fed as rates continue to come down?

Kelly Piperaro (CFO)

Yes, Justin. Good morning. As we look at where the market's been in the rate cuts, we did take advantage during the quarter of putting on another brokered deposit. While we're trying to manage funding costs with that, we were able to swap that and get that into the lower rate. As we look at customer deposits as we move forward, a lot in our market is dependent upon competition. We've actively worked with our customers on core deposit growth, de-emphasizing CDs from a customer perspective. We continue to look at lowering those costs that we are paying on deposits, but again, being responsive to market and looking to see where our customers are and what's going on.

James Nesci (CEO)

To reinforce it a little bit, I think you'll see more shift from the CD to the money market product at Blue Foundry Bancorp.

Justin Crowley (Senior Research Analyst)

Okay, got it. With that, the de-emphasis of new CDs in terms of the backbook and what kind of benefit you could get as stuff comes up for repricing, I'm sure the book's relatively short. Can you quantify what that might look like over the coming quarters in terms of magnitude and yield pickup?

Kelly Piperaro (CFO)

As we are looking from a perspective of the customer deposits for the CDs, we do have, you know, durations out there of five months. Some of our specialists have been a five-month CD to shorten that life of the CD. We don't necessarily anticipate a tremendous pickup in Q4 with any rate movement, as those will be rolling off a little bit later, probably in January, February, we see more of the roll-off of those. We see benefit in 2026 from that. Again, we'll be looking from managing the core deposit component of that and lowering those rates as we move forward through the quarter.

James Nesci (CEO)

Justin, part of the cycle we've seen is as you get to year-end, the cost of deposit seems to tick up. We try to position ourselves not to end at 12/31. Obviously, we prefer to have some of that duration go out to January, February to reposition as opposed to just kind of stop at year-end.

Justin Crowley (Senior Research Analyst)

Okay. What would sort of be your near or medium-term expectations just for the margin? I think you've talked before about how multifamily repricing, how that really starts to become more of a tailwind next year. Can you remind us what that looks like in terms of magnitude, yield pickup, and then just anything else on the asset side and how that could inform benefiting the margin in lieu of maybe deposit costs not coming down as quickly?

Kelly Piperaro (CFO)

Yeah, I think as we look forward from a forecast perspective, we anticipate fourth quarter to be relatively flat given where we are and that we do see that repricing activity pick up. Specifically, the first half of 2026, we have probably around $45 million coming in. That's sub 4% from a repricing perspective, maturity and repricing. In the latter half, we have about another $35 million, $40 million that's really sub 3.75% that will be repricing. We really are looking for the 2026 pickup in net interest margin.

Justin Crowley (Senior Research Analyst)

I know it's hard to say, but could that pickup in net interest margin next year, you know, could it look like on a quarterly basis what you got this quarter? Would your bias be towards, you know, greater expansion? How do you see that?

Kelly Piperaro (CFO)

Yeah, I think it's going to be a combination, Justin, right? While we have repricing, we also have new products or new production that we're looking to put on. Depending upon what the market does and how we're able to execute will really drive that. It's hard to say exactly where as we're going through our strategic planning now and looking at our initiatives.

Justin Crowley (Senior Research Analyst)

Okay. On the commercial loan growth, I know it's just one quarter, but saw net growth in multifamily for the first time in a little while, and then some solid growth in commercial real estate, including the owner-occupied you mentioned, Jim. Can you talk a little on opportunities you're seeing there, how the pipeline looks, which I might have missed that, and just how you expect that could trend as rates continue to come down?

James Nesci (CEO)

Yeah. Obviously, we've tried to de-emphasize the multifamily. When we do multifamily, while we're adding multifamily assets, they're usually pretty strategic, working with borrowers that we've worked with before. Coupons are attractive to us. I think you'll see us back off of the multifamily a little bit unless there's a strategic reason. The commercial and industrial segments are where we try to focus, pulling in the full relationship so we get the deposit along with the asset. That's where the team is focused right now. It's really on that business banking side or commercial assets that are really driving that business loan to go through.

Kelly Piperaro (CFO)

Just to reemphasize, sorry, Justin, just to reemphasize, you know, the pipeline, as we discussed, we have over $41 million letters of intent out there with rates above 7%. In that bucket, there's less than $6 million of multifamily. Really de-emphasizing that asset class. As Jim said, it's really got to be relationship-driven for us to be engaging asset class.

Justin Crowley (Senior Research Analyst)

Okay. Just one last one quickly for me. On expenses, I'm not sure if I missed it. I'm not sure if you gave guide for the fourth quarter or not, but between that and just as we look out to next year, I guess you'll see the normal merit increases, etc., between the fourth quarter and 2026 as well. What do you think is a reasonable level of expense growth to expect for the company?

Kelly Piperaro (CFO)

At this point for fourth quarter as we look, we're going to be in that high 13, low 14 range. Again, as you noted, expenses were a little bit elevated, some on the compensation front. Also, as we look at the professional services, there's always initiatives that we're doing here. Those don't come in smooth over a time period. It all depends on what we're doing at the institution. We are not really prepared at this time to give guidance on 2026 as we're working through our initiatives and our strategic planning process.

Justin Crowley (Senior Research Analyst)

Okay, got it. Very helpful. I will leave it there. Thanks so much.

Kelly Piperaro (CFO)

Thanks, Justin.

Operator (participant)

Our next question comes from David Konrad from KBW. Your line is open, David. Please go ahead.

David Konrad (Managing Director)

Yes, thank you. Good morning. Just a couple of quick questions. One on the follow-up just on the loan growth outlook. You did have some really good loan growth in the kind of the structured consumer loan book. I think you're around 7% of loans. Is 7%-8% kind of still the range that you're thinking about for that portfolio?

Kelly Piperaro (CFO)

Yes, David.

David Konrad (Managing Director)

Okay. Capital remains really strong. You're trading below tangible book, so real good buyback activity. Is this a pretty good run rate for us to think of going forward, or how do you think about the buyback now?

James Nesci (CEO)

We had a transaction that we called out in the quarter. I don't think that's a usable run rate. I don't think you're going to see us put up another number at that level. You know, Kelly.

Kelly Piperaro (CFO)

I think as you look at, you know, we definitely believe the buyback could have been a very good use of capital. As we're looking at our structure here, we did at the end of the quarter still have another 730,000 shares under our current plan to repurchase.

David Konrad (Managing Director)

Okay, thank you. Appreciate it.

Operator (participant)

We currently have no further questions, so I'd like to hand back to Jim for some closing remarks.

James Nesci (CEO)

Thank you. Thank you for the question, David. Appreciate it. I want to thank all of our shareholders and our employees for dialing in today, and all of the communities that listen in to our call. We appreciate it, and we look forward to speaking to you again soon in the next quarter. Thank you.

Operator (participant)

This concludes today's call. We thank everyone for joining. Youmay now disconnect your lines.