Sign in
BC

Burford Capital Ltd (BUR)·Q3 2025 Earnings Summary

Executive Summary

  • Q3 2025 was soft on earnings as unrealized losses on non-YPF assets from duration extensions drove a GAAP loss and negative EPS, while core portfolio activity and commitments stayed robust; management reiterated confidence in long-term doubling by 2030 and highlighted record rolling three-year realizations .
  • Results missed S&P Global consensus: revenue $69.8M vs $136.0M est. and EPS $(0.09) vs $0.31 est.; management attributed the miss largely to valuation timing (duration) rather than adverse case outcomes; estimate values from S&P Global* .
  • Portfolio engines remained active: 61 assets generated proceeds YTD; Burford-only cash and marketable securities rose to $740M aided by a $500M 7.50% 2033 notes issuance; leverage metrics remained within covenants .
  • YPF: management remains “bullish,” citing SDNY’s $16B judgment and October 29 Second Circuit oral argument; enforcement actions continued (e.g., turnover order appeal briefing through December), with management pushing back on market concerns after the hearing; timing remains uncertain and legal risk remains .

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

  • What Went Well

    • New business momentum: YTD new definitive commitments $637M (+52% YoY); deployments $329M (+20% YoY); portfolio base up 15% YTD, exceeding trajectory to double by 2030 .
    • Realization breadth: 61 assets produced proceeds YTD (vs 50 last year), and rolling three-year realizations at an all-time high; Q3 net realized gains implied ~60% ROIC on Q3 realizations .
    • Liquidity and funding: Cash and marketable securities increased to $740M after issuing $500M 7.50% 2033 notes; debt WAL ~4.9 years; leverage 0.9x indebtedness/net tangible equity (within covenants) .

    Selected quote: “The portfolio is also active and delivering attractive amounts of cash, with rolling three-year realizations at their highest level ever… We are bullish on [YPF’s] prospects” — CEO Chris Bogart .

  • What Went Wrong

    • P&L impact from non-YPF unrealized losses: Q3 saw meaningful negative fair value changes from extended durations on certain assets, pressuring earnings despite no spike in losses; management emphasized this does not change case outcomes .
    • Asset management income headwind in Q3: $(0.2)M (Burford-only) in the quarter due to profit-sharing reversals tied to fund fair value movements, though YTD remained $21M .
    • YoY revenue/EPS decline: GAAP consolidated revenue fell YoY to $69.8M (vs $249.1M) and EPS turned negative $(0.09) (vs $0.61), with net income attributable at $(19)M (vs $136M) .

Financial Results

Company-reported quarterly (YoY compare) – GAAP consolidated and Burford-only

MetricQ3 2024Q3 2025
Total Revenues – GAAP ($M)249.1 69.8
Net Income – GAAP ($M)157.9 (20.3)
Net Income Attributable to BUR Shareholders ($M)135.6 (19.2)
Total Revenues – Burford-only ($M)226.0 68.7
Diluted EPS – Burford-only ($)0.61 (0.09)
Operating Expenses – Burford-only ($M)46.0 42.7

Company-reported segment details (Burford-only)

MetricQ3 2024Q3 2025
Capital Provision Income ($M)205.0 62.1
Net Realized Gains ($M)56.5 31.9
Unrealized Gains/(Losses) ($M)144.7 23.9
Asset Management Income ($M)11.1 (0.2)

Consensus vs Actuals (S&P Global; Q3 2025)

MetricConsensusActualSurprise
Revenue ($M)136.0*69.8 Miss
Primary EPS ($)0.31*(0.09) Miss

Values marked with * retrieved from S&P Global.

Quarterly trajectory (standardized; S&P Global)

MetricQ1 2025Q2 2025Q3 2025
Revenue ($M)118.9*—64.7*
Primary EPS ($)——(0.09)*

Values marked with * retrieved from S&P Global.

KPIs and operating drivers

KPI (Burford-only)Q1 2025Q2 2025Q3 2025
Deployments ($M)129.9 80.8 118.6
Realizations ($M)149 58 85
New Definitive Commitments YTD ($M)158 518 637
Cash Receipts ($M)258 48 118
Liquidity (Cash + Mkt Secs) ($M)548 —740
YPF Fair Value (Burford-only, $B)1.5 (Mar 31) —1.7 (Sep 30)

Guidance Changes

MetricPeriodPrevious GuidanceCurrent GuidanceChange
Formal Revenue/EPS/EBITDA GuidanceFY/Q4 2025NoneNoneMaintained – no formal guidance provided
Long-term Platform TargetThrough 2030Double platform by 2030Reiterated; YTD growth above trajectory
Capital ReturnsOngoingPreference to reinvest vs buybacks given leverage/cash flow timingReiterated prudential stance; open to feedback
Listing StrategyLSEEvaluating ISL vs AIM vs de-listPlan to retain AIM given fee hurdle for ISL

Earnings Call Themes & Trends

TopicPrevious Mentions (Q2, Q1)Current Period (Q3)Trend
YPF legal processQ2: Oral argument set for Oct; SDNY turnover order; continued enforcement . Q1: Fair value $1.5B; reiterated ten-figure potential, risk remains .CEO rebuts market concern post-oral argument; emphasizes low appellate reversal rates; duration to decision could be months; still “bullish” . Turnover appeal briefing through Dec; separate from main appeal .Ongoing progress; timing uncertain; enforcement active.
New business momentumQ2: YTD new commitments +71% YoY; record quarterly $361M in Q2 . Q1: Seasonally strong; $158M commitments .YTD new commitments $637M (+52% YoY); portfolio base +15% YTD; seeded high-ROIC pipeline .Strong and broad-based.
Realizations/cash receiptsQ2: YTD cash receipts $306M vs $245M; realizations building . Q1: Realizations $163M; cash receipts $258M .61 assets realized YTD; Q3 realized gains imply ~60% ROIC on Q3 activity; rolling 3-yr realizations at highs .Elevated activity; “chunkiness” persists.
Valuation/duration impactQ2: Discount rate tailwind; milestone/model updates drive fair value .Q3 unrealized losses ex-YPF driven by longer expected durations; management stresses no change in case prospects .Near-term headwind; not thesis-changing.
Capital allocation & buybacksQ2: Extended maturity ladder; conservative leverage; focus on growth .Management explains buyback caution given leverage/cash flow timing; remains open to dialogue .Unchanged stance; investor engagement ongoing.
Funding & liquidityQ2: $500M 2033 notes issuance executed efficiently .Cash + marketable secs $740M; WAL ~4.9y; leverage within covenants .Strengthened balance sheet.

Management Commentary

  • “We’re… above the level needed to double the size of the platform by 2030… rolling three-year realizations at their highest level ever… we are bullish on [YPF]… the bulk of Burford’s business doesn’t involve YPF and is also flourishing and growing.” — CEO Chris Bogart .
  • On YPF appellate risk: “It would be extraordinary for the appellate court to dismiss the YPF case on [forum non] grounds now… the trial judge twice exercised her discretion to deny… and dismissal after trial and judgment would be exceptional.” — CEO Chris Bogart .
  • On Q3 valuation impact: “Extension of fair model durations… correspondingly [reduced] fair value… not necessarily [changing] our view of the case or the outcome.” — CFO Jordan Licht .
  • On buybacks vs growth: “Diverting cash to a buyback meaningfully reduces debt repayment capacity… we’re conservative about leverage… not a closed book… will continue to think actively and welcome… dialogue.” — CEO Chris Bogart .

Q&A Highlights

  • YPF enforcement appeal timing: Turnover appeal fully briefed by December; argument to be scheduled thereafter; main appeal decision timing uncertain; likely a 2026 event for turnover appeal resolution .
  • Realization trajectory: More trials/hearings scheduled in next 12 months vs prior year; settlements catalyzed by trial dates; timing remains lumpy .
  • Duration change magnitude: Duration extension impact estimated at $40–50M on the non-YPF book this quarter (not tied to a single case) .
  • Capital allocation: Management reiterated prudential stance on buybacks given cash flow unpredictability vs fixed debt service; open to shareholder feedback .
  • Industry dynamics: Potential consolidation opportunities considered; disciplined valuation approach; peers face refinancing pressures .

Estimates Context

  • Q3 2025 vs consensus: Revenue $69.8M vs $136.0M est. (miss); EPS $(0.09)$ vs $0.31 est. (miss). Management pointed to unrealized losses from duration extensions on non-YPF assets as the primary driver of variance, not case losses . Values retrieved from S&P Global.*
  • Q4 2025 consensus: Revenue $168.3M*, EPS $0.41*; limited estimate coverage (one to two analysts), suggesting potential for estimate volatility.*

Values marked with * retrieved from S&P Global.

Key Takeaways for Investors

  • Near-term earnings were pressured by model duration extensions, not an uptick in losses; the core realization engine and new business growth remain healthy, supporting medium-term cash generation .
  • Balance sheet is fortified (cash/marketable securities $740M; extended maturities), giving Burford flexibility to fund growth while navigating lumpy realizations and appeals timing .
  • YPF remains a sizable asymmetric option; management rebutted forum non concerns and continues enforcement globally; expect multi-month cadence for Second Circuit decision and separate turnover appeal .
  • Capital returns likely back-end loaded; management favors reinvestment over buybacks until cash flows become steadier or a major monetization occurs; watch for post-YPF capital allocation discussion .
  • Estimate dispersion risk is high given limited coverage and the idiosyncratic nature of legal finance; quarter-to-quarter “noise” can create trading volatility around legal milestones and modeling updates .
  • Focus on KPIs that drive value: commitments, deployments, realizations, cash receipts, and TBVPS; Q3 showed solid momentum on most of these despite P&L volatility .