Sign in

    CarGurus Inc (CARG)

    Q2 2024 Earnings Summary

    Reported on Feb 25, 2025 (After Market Close)
    Pre-Earnings Price$22.40Last close (Aug 8, 2024)
    Post-Earnings Price$25.06Open (Aug 9, 2024)
    Price Change
    $2.66(+11.88%)

    What went well

    • CarGurus is experiencing significant margin expansion in its Marketplace business, with gross profit margins "grinding higher and higher" due to high flow-through revenues and value-added products, indicating sustainable profitability growth.
    • The company is gaining market share, with customers showing unprecedented enthusiasm and commitment. CarGurus' platform is becoming a "winner-take-most" marketplace, attracting both consumers and dealers, leading to network effects and sustained growth.
    • Dealers are upgrading to higher tiers and adopting more add-on products, resulting in higher spending and retention, especially among larger dealers with higher advertising budgets. CarGurus is viewed as the "profit maximization platform", suggesting strong dealer reliance and potential for increased revenues.

    What went wrong

    • Digital Wholesale revenue was $13 million for the second quarter, down 59% year-over-year, driven by a decline in dealer-to-dealer transaction volume, highlighting significant challenges in the wholesale segment.
    • The company recognized a noncash goodwill impairment charge of $127 million associated with the CarOffer business, indicating a substantial decrease in the value of this acquisition and potential issues with the integration and performance of the CarOffer platform.
    • Transaction volumes in CarOffer have declined by 50% year-over-year and are 87% below the highest quarter level, raising concerns about the platform's ability to regain momentum and uncertainty regarding when or if the volumes will recover.

    Q&A Summary

    1. Margins Expansion Drivers
      Q: What's driving the margins expansion and is it sustainable?
      A: Jason Trevisan explained that the momentum is due to several factors, including dealers focusing on channels that deliver volume post-COVID, CarGurus' continuous innovation adding products that help dealers run better dealerships, and better ROI from leads. He believes this flywheel effect is likely to continue, as marketplaces tend to be winner-take-most models.

    2. CarOffer Challenges and Recovery
      Q: What needs to be done to regain volumes at CarOffer?
      A: Jason Trevisan stated they are restructuring the sales organization and investing in product improvements, specifically around data integration into the CarOffer matrix to give buyers and sellers confidence. They are making progress but acknowledge it's taking longer than expected, without specifying a timeline.

    3. Impact of CDK Outage and Opportunities
      Q: Was there any impact from the CDK outage, and are there opportunities as a result?
      A: Management reported no impact from the CDK outage on billing or collections and do not anticipate any carryover impact. They believe there may be pipeline opportunities from dealers who delayed decisions during the outage and see potential in providing analytics and integrating into dealers' systems in the future.

    4. Growth in OEM Advertising Revenue
      Q: How did OEM ad revenue perform, and what's the outlook?
      A: Samuel Zales stated they are proud of the growth in OEM advertising as manufacturers are eager to promote new inventory. Advertisers are moving from programmatic buys to direct buys with CarGurus. However, their priority remains on leads and digital transactions rather than increasing ad load.

    5. Top Dealer Offer Expansion
      Q: What's needed to expand Top Dealer Offer beyond current metros?
      A: Samuel Zales explained they focus on ensuring an exceptional consumer experience by working with large, sophisticated dealers capable of managing sell-my-car leads effectively. They are balancing growth with maintaining quality and are not aiming to rapidly expand to thousands of dealers.

    6. Shift to Larger Dealers
      Q: Why is the customer base shifting to larger dealers?
      A: The shift is due to larger, more sophisticated dealers seeking better ROI and profit maximization. These dealers retain longer, spend more, and adopt more products. Offerings like Top Dealer Offer and Digital Deal are particularly attractive to them.

    7. Impairment of Digital Wholesale
      Q: Does the impairment change the outlook for Digital Wholesale?
      A: Elisa Palazzo clarified that the impairment does not alter their belief in the strategic value of Digital Wholesale. They view it as a strategic asset with a large TAM and are working on returning the business to profitable growth.

    8. Consumer Experience Enhancements
      Q: How is the new simplified vehicle search impacting leads?
      A: Jason Trevisan stated that investments in consumer experience, including personalization and AI in search, have resulted in a simpler experience, improving conversion rates and lead quality, positively impacting the broader business.

    9. Marketplace Gross Margin Trends
      Q: Is the high gross profit margin in Marketplace sustainable?
      A: Elisa Palazzo mentioned that the high margins are due to revenue with very high flow-through, including subscription-based listings and high-margin advertising. She doesn't consider it unusually high and expects margins to continue improving.

    Related Publications