Q2 2024 Earnings Summary
- Accretive Flagstar Acquisition: The Flagstar deal is expected to boost returns significantly—with current ROTCE at 15.3% and guidance positioning 2025 in the mid‐to‐high teens—while adding scale through a balanced mix of owned MSRs and subservicing, which enhances profitability.
- Operational Efficiency & Cost Leverage: Strong investments in technology—such as AI-driven tools that lower cost per loan and improve process efficiency—are driving operating leverage and margin improvements.
- Robust Origination & Replenishment Capacity: The company is replenishing over 100% of its portfolio and expanding its capacity (including adding nearly 100 loan officers), while integrating Flagstar’s TPO business that originates over $1B per month, positioning it for solid organic growth.
- Integration and execution risks: The Flagstar acquisition involves integrating both MSR and subservicing operations, including onboarding new team members and aligning technology systems, which could lead to higher-than-expected operating expenses and delays in realizing synergies.
- Increased leverage and liquidity concerns: The acquisition is entirely debt-funded using cash on hand and MSR line draws. This could reduce liquidity—from a reported $3.3 billion to a pro forma high $2 billion—potentially limiting financial flexibility if market conditions worsen.
- Margin pressure and uncertainty in earnings accretion: Guidance on accretion suggests a modest improvement (approximately 1 to 1.5 percentage point increase in ROE) and there are indications that higher operating costs from integrating the new business may pressure margins, possibly delaying or dampening expected earnings enhancements.
-
Earnings Accretion
Q: Earnings accretion impact?
A: Management expects the Flagstar deal to add accretion by blending high‐teen returns on MSRs with subservicing, helping drive ROTCE toward the upper end of the 14–18% target for 2025. -
Deal Structure
Q: Flagstar debt vs. equity?
A: The acquisition is entirely debt-financed—about $1.1B for MSRs plus $85M in advances—with goodwill pending final calculations. -
Funding Impact
Q: MSR line draw affects liquidity?
A: While drawing on MSR lines will reduce liquidity, management expects post-deal liquidity to remain in the high $2B range with additional facility capacity. -
Fed Rate & Hedge
Q: Fed cuts affect MSR values?
A: The forward curve already prices in anticipated rate cuts, and a consistent 75% hedge ratio is expected to offset most adverse effects. -
Valuation Multiple
Q: Value split: platform vs. MSR?
A: The MSR component trades at roughly 5.3x the base servicing fee, while overall deal metrics—factoring in subservicing and origination—suggest a slightly lower effective multiple than 5.6x. -
Origination Scale
Q: Can origination handle increased recapture?
A: COOP is expanding capacity with nearly 100 new LOs and enhanced digital tools to efficiently manage growing recapture volumes and first-lien activity. -
Credit Ratings
Q: Ratings agencies’ view on Flagstar?
A: Management reported positive feedback from rating agencies regarding the transaction, with capital ratios remaining within targeted ranges, though no specific details were disclosed. -
Recapture Agreements
Q: Details on recapture agreements?
A: The team noted a mixed approach with some clients relying on COOP’s recapture capability while others use their own, without divulging detailed figures.
Research analysts covering Mr. Cooper Group.