Sign in

Melanie Barstad

Director at CINTAS
Board

About Melanie W. Barstad

Independent director at Cintas since 2011; age 72 (as of the 2025 proxy). Former President of Women’s Health in Johnson & Johnson’s Medical Device & Diagnostics Division with 23 years at J&J (retired 2009), serving on multiple J&J operating company boards; honored by Auburn University (Lifetime Achievement Award, 2018) and Women Inc. (Most Influential Corporate Board Directors in 2019, 2023, 2025). Education not disclosed in the proxy. Core credentials: global healthcare operating executive, board leadership experience, and independence under NASDAQ rules.

Past Roles

OrganizationRoleTenureCommittees/Impact
Johnson & Johnson Family of CompaniesPresident, Women’s Health, Medical Device & Diagnostics; management board member (J&J Health Care Systems, Ethicon Endo Surgery, J&J Medical)23 years; retired 2009; management boards 1997–2009Led complex enterprise-wide businesses; deep healthcare industry expertise
Auburn University FoundationDirector; Chair, Directorship Committee; Executive Committee member2008–2016Governance leadership at a major academic foundation

External Roles

OrganizationRoleCurrent/PastNotes
Women Inc.Most Influential Corporate Board Directors2019, 2023, 2025Recognition for board influence
Agenda Compensation 100ListedPastRecognition noted in 2024 proxy

Board Governance

  • Independence: Determined independent under NASDAQ listing standards; all standing committees composed solely of independent directors.
  • Committee assignments (FY 2025): Chair, Compensation Committee; Member, Nominating & Corporate Governance Committee.
  • Attendance and engagement: Board met six times in FY 2025; each director attended ≥75% of Board and relevant committee meetings; independent directors held four executive sessions (Lead Director presiding). Committee meetings FY 2025: Nominating (3), Audit (7), Compensation (3).
  • Lead Independent Director: Joseph Scaminace; also chairs Nominating & Corporate Governance and Executive Committees.

Fixed Compensation

Nonemployee director cash program and Barstad’s cash fees:

ElementFY 2024 ($)FY 2025 ($)
Annual retainer100,000 100,000
Compensation Committee chair fee27,500 27,500
Compensation Committee member fee (if not chair)12,500 12,500
Nominating & Corporate Governance chair fee35,000 35,000
Audit Committee chair fee35,000 35,000
Audit Committee member fee15,000 15,000
Barstad – Fees Earned (Cash)FY 2024FY 2025
Fees Earned or Paid in Cash108,500 120,000

Notes:

  • Directors may defer cash into phantom stock units or a fixed-income account; Barstad elected phantom units and received 768 units in FY 2024 and 617 units in FY 2025.

Performance Compensation

Annual equity grants to nonemployee directors are time-based (not performance-tied); typical one-year cliff vesting.

Grant DetailFY 2024 (Oct 25, 2023)FY 2025 (Oct 30, 2024)
Restricted stock shares granted (to each nonemployee director)680 shares; 100% vest after 1 year 409 shares; 100% vest after 1 year
Stock options granted (to each nonemployee director)2,352 options @ $125.38; 100% vest after 1 year 1,393 options @ $207.85; 100% vest after 1 year
Barstad – Stock Awards (fair value)$85,257 $85,011
Barstad – Option Awards (fair value)$85,107 $85,043

Plan limits and governance:

  • Nonemployee director annual grant cap under Amended 2016 Plan: $500,000 grant-date value; increased from $300,000 in 2024.
  • Anti-hedging policy prohibits directors from hedging, short-selling, or derivative transactions in company stock (outside plan grants); all directors in compliance.
  • Equity awards for directors vest time-based; no director-specific performance metrics disclosed.

Other Directorships & Interlocks

PersonCurrent Public Company BoardsInterlocks/Relationships
Melanie W. BarstadNot disclosedNone disclosed in related party transactions section

Expertise & Qualifications

  • Healthcare operating executive (J&J) with enterprise P&L and board-level management experience; brings sector knowledge and large-company governance perspective.
  • Recognized for board influence (Women Inc.) and prior academic foundation governance (Auburn University).
  • Independent director, contributing to compensation and nominating/governance oversight.

Equity Ownership

Ownership ItemValue
Common stock beneficially owned (Sep 2, 2025)73,954 shares (<1% of class)
Options outstanding (as of FY 2025 table)47,865 options
Restricted stock outstanding409 shares
Phantom stock units credited (Sep 2, 2025)4,041 units (no voting rights)
Director stock ownership guidelineMinimum 5× annual cash retainer; all directors compliant
Anti-hedging policyApplies to directors; all in compliance

Compensation Structure Signals

ItemFY 2024FY 2025
Barstad – Total director compensation$278,864 $290,054
Mix (qualitative)Cash + time-based equity (RS + options) Cash + time-based equity (RS + options)
Plan governance changesAmended 2016 Plan extended to 2034; director cap raised to $500k; repricing prohibited; clawbacks apply

Say-on-Pay & Shareholder Feedback

YearSay-on-Pay Approval
2023 (proxy reference)~98% approval
2024 (proxy reference)~96% approval

Additional governance:

  • Majority voting in uncontested director elections with resignation policy.
  • Lead Director and independent committee leadership; annual evaluations and executive sessions.

Potential Conflicts and Related-Party Exposure

  • No related-party transactions disclosed involving Barstad.
  • Related-party items involve Executive Chairman family interests (aircraft) and law firm KMK (director Coletti); Audit Committee reviews such transactions for best interests of the company.

Governance Assessment

  • Strengths: Independent status; chairing the Compensation Committee; consistent attendance; robust equity/compensation governance (clawbacks, anti-hedging, option repricing prohibition, majority voting); strong say-on-pay support indicating investor confidence.
  • Alignment: Meaningful share/option holdings; adherence to 5× retainer ownership guideline; ability to defer fees into phantom stock units aligns incentives.
  • Watch items: Amended plan increased director award cap to $500k (still capped and subject to committee oversight); continued monitoring of compensation committee decisions under Barstad’s chair role for pay-for-performance rigor.

Best AI for Equity Research

Performance on expert-authored financial analysis tasks

Fintool-v490%
Claude Sonnet 4.555.3%
o348.3%
GPT 546.9%
Grok 440.3%
Qwen 3 Max32.7%

Best AI for Equity Research

Performance on expert-authored financial analysis tasks

Fintool-v490%
Claude Sonnet 4.555.3%
o348.3%
GPT 546.9%
Grok 440.3%
Qwen 3 Max32.7%