Sign in

You're signed outSign in or to get full access.

DF

Discover Financial Services (DFS)·Q2 2024 Earnings Summary

Executive Summary

  • Strong headline quarter: Revenue net of interest expense rose 17% YoY to $4.54B, EPS printed $6.06 boosted by an $869M reserve release tied to classifying the private student loan portfolio as held for sale; underlying EPS was ~$3.63 excluding unusual items (litigation gain and expected regulatory penalties largely offset) .
  • Credit normalization steadied: Card net charge-off (NCO) rate fell QoQ to 5.55% (from 5.66%) and 30+ day delinquencies improved sequentially; management reiterated losses are near peak and should plateau in 2H24 .
  • Strategic catalysts: Agreed to sell ~$10.1B private student loan portfolio at a premium (up to ~$10.8B proceeds), boosting NIM guidance to 11.1–11.4% and simplifying the balance sheet; class action settlement in the card misclassification matter advanced remediation .
  • Mixed operating backdrop: PULSE debit network volume +18% YoY, but Discover card sales volume -3% YoY amid cautious low-income consumer spend; Payment Services pretax income benefited from a favorable litigation settlement .

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

  • What Went Well

    • NIM expansion and deposit discipline: NIM rose to 11.17% (up 14 bps QoQ) on lower promotional mix; management proactively lowered deposit pricing and raised full-year NIM outlook .
    • Payment Services strength: PULSE volume +18% YoY; Payment Services pretax income rose to $277M on higher debit processing and favorable litigation settlement .
    • Portfolio actions de-risked: Student loan sale agreed at premium with multiple closings expected by year-end; reserve release aided capital (CET1 11.9%) and raised NIM guidance by ~10 bps .
    • Management quote: “Discover's second quarter operating performance was very good, and we advanced several strategic priorities” — Interim CEO Michael Shepherd .
  • What Went Wrong

    • Expense pressure: Operating expense +23% YoY to $1.73B, driven by a charge for expected regulatory penalties related to card misclassification and higher compliance/risk spend .
    • Underlying consumer caution: Discover card sales -3% YoY; management cited lower spend among lower-income households and 5% category mix effects .
    • Credit still elevated YoY: Total NCO rate 4.83% (up 161 bps YoY) despite sequential improvement; card NCO 5.55% (up 187 bps YoY) .

Financial Results

MetricQ2 2023Q1 2024Q2 2024
Revenue net of interest expense ($MM)$3,878 $4,210 $4,538
Diluted EPS ($)$3.54 $1.10 $6.06
Net Interest Margin (%)11.06% 11.03% 11.17%
Provision for credit losses ($MM)$1,305 $1,497 $739
Total operating expense ($MM)$1,404 $2,309 $1,729
Net income ($MM)$901 $308 $1,530
ROE (%)26% 8% 40%

Notes: Q2 EPS includes unusuals (reserve release, litigation settlement, expected regulatory penalties); CFO indicated underlying EPS ~ $3.63 excluding unusual items .

Segment performance (Revenue and pretax):

SegmentQ2 2023Q2 2024
Digital Banking – Revenue net of interest expense ($MM)$3,763 $4,215
Digital Banking – Pretax income ($MM)$1,099 $1,793
Payment Services – Revenue ($MM)$115 $323
Payment Services – Pretax income ($MM)$70 $277

Key KPIs and credit metrics:

KPIQ2 2023Q1 2024Q2 2024
Total loans ending ($MM)$117,906 $126,555 $127,649
Credit card NCO rate (%)3.68% 5.66% 5.55%
Card 30+ day DQ rate (%)2.86% 3.83% 3.69%
Discover card sales volume ($MM)$55,229 $50,137 $53,482
Rewards rate (%)1.42% 1.39% 1.32%
CET1 capital ratio (%)11.7% 10.9% 11.9%

Payment Services volumes:

Volume ($Bn)Q2 2023Q1 2024Q2 2024
PULSE Network$69.0 $79.1 $81.7
Diners Club$9.9 $10.2 $9.4
Network Partners$10.4 $11.1 $8.1
Total Payment Services$89.3 $100.3 $99.3

Guidance Changes

MetricPeriodPrevious Guidance (Q1’24)Current Guidance (Q2’24)Change
Loan growthFY 2024Up low single digits Down low single digits (Δ driven by ~$10.1B student loan sale) Lowered (sale impact)
Net interest marginFY 202410.7%–11.0% 11.1%–11.4% (sale + ~10 bps) Raised
Operating expenseFY 2024Up mid-single digits excl. misclassification/merger costs No change Maintained
Net charge-offsFY 20244.9%–5.2% (base case low end) 4.9%–5.2% (includes +10 bps from student loans; base case low end) Maintained
Capital managementFY 2024Repurchases suspended; dividend ≤ $0.70 No change Maintained

Dividend actions: Board declared $0.70 per common share payable Sep 5, 2024; preferred dividends for Series C/D also declared .

Earnings Call Themes & Trends

TopicPrevious Mentions (Q4’23, Q1’24)Current Period (Q2’24)Trend
Regulatory/legal & misclassificationElevated compliance spend; remediation reserve increased; FDIC consent order scope separate; ongoing regulator dialogue Entered class action settlement agreement; charge recorded for expected regulatory penalties Resolution progressing; residual expense risk noted
Credit cycle (losses/plateau)Losses to peak mid-2024 then plateau; delinquency formation slowing; reserve near/at peak Losses near peak; plateau expected in 2H24; sequential improvement in card delinquencies Stabilizing
Deposit pricing/NIMManaging betas; NIM guide 10.7–11.0% (Q1) NIM guide raised to 11.1–11.4% with student loan sale; proactive deposit rate cuts Positive
Consumer spendSales flat to slight negative; low-income cohort pressured Card sales -3% YoY; cautious consumer; promo category effects Mixed to soft
Private student loansCeased new originations; marketing sale; expected above-par price Sale agreed at premium (up to ~$10.8B), multi-tranche closings by YE24 Executing exit
Payment ServicesPULSE growth strong PULSE +18% YoY; litigation settlement lift Strength sustained
Capital One mergerS-4 process underway; integration planning Planning and regulatory applications progressing; expected shareholder votes in fall Advancing

Management Commentary

  • “Discover's second quarter operating performance was very good, and we advanced several strategic priorities.” — Interim CEO Michael Shepherd .
  • “Excluding unusual items, we would have reported net income of approximately $915 million and EPS of about $3.63 per share.” — CFO John Greene .
  • “Credit continues to perform in line with expectations, supporting our view that losses are near peak and will plateau during the second half of 2024.” — CFO John Greene .
  • “We entered into an agreement to sell our private student loan portfolio… This agreement represents an important milestone in our journey to simplify our operations and business mix.” — Interim CEO Michael Shepherd .
  • Press release highlight: “We advanced several critical initiatives including entering into an agreement to sell our student loan assets, favorably resolving litigation in our Payment Services segment, and entering into a class action settlement agreement for the card misclassification matter.” — Interim CEO Michael Shepherd .

Q&A Highlights

  • There was no Q&A session for Q2 2024; prepared remarks only, with IR available for follow-up .
  • For context from prior Q4 2023 Q&A: themes included credit normalization and plateau, loan growth building blocks and conservatism, student loan sale timing and capital/NIM benefits, compliance expense trajectory and long-term efficiency ratio sub-40% target, and deposit/NIM sensitivity to rate cuts .

Estimates Context

  • S&P Global consensus estimates for Q2 2024 were unavailable via our SPGI tool at the time of analysis, so we cannot provide an authoritative actuals-vs-consensus comparison. The company reported diluted EPS of $6.06 and revenue net of interest expense of $4.54B; underlying EPS excluding unusual items was ~ $3.63 for context .
  • Implication: Street models may adjust for non-recurring items (reserve release, litigation settlement, regulatory penalties) and the student loan sale’s impact on NIM, OpEx classification of student loan charge-offs, and loan growth trajectory .

Key Takeaways for Investors

  • Quality of beat: Headline EPS was inflated by reserve release; underlying ~$3.63 EPS showcases solid core profitability aided by NIM expansion and Payment Services, but expenses remain elevated from regulatory issues .
  • Credit nearing inflection: Sequential improvement in card delinquencies and reiterated plateau in 2H24 reduces downside tail risk on losses; monitor seasonality and credit actions in 2H .
  • Structural simplification: Student loan sale at premium is accretive to NIM (~+10 bps to guidance), simplifies risk, and should free capital as the sale completes in tranches by YE24; watch closing cadence and proceeds .
  • Network diversification: PULSE growth (+18% YoY) continues to offset softer proprietary card sales; favorable litigation buttressed Payment Services earnings this quarter .
  • Expense overhang persists: Expected regulatory penalties and ongoing compliance spend (with upside bias) keep a lid on margin expansion; sustained sub-40% efficiency ratio remains medium-term target post-remediation .
  • Merger optionality: Capital One transaction progressing through regulatory and shareholder processes; buybacks remain suspended, dividend capped at $0.70 until close .
  • Trading setup: Near-term sentiment hinges on regulatory clarity (misclassification settlement finalization), student loan sale closings, and validation of credit plateau; underlying NIM momentum and PULSE strength are offsets .

Appendix: Additional Press Releases (Q2 2024)

  • Private Student Loan Portfolio Sale: ~$10.1B principal as of 6/30, price up to ~$10.8B; servicing to Firstmark (Nelnet); multiple closings expected by end-2024 .