EC
Equity Commonwealth (EQC)·Q3 2024 Earnings Summary
Executive Summary
- Q3 2024 GAAP results reflect wind-down actions: revenue was $13.99M and diluted EPS was $(0.26) driven by a $50.2M non-cash impairment on assets classified as held for sale; FFO/diluted share was $0.24 and Normalized FFO/diluted share was $0.25 .
- Portfolio metrics deteriorated further: same-property NOI fell 16.0% YoY and cash NOI fell 15.4% YoY; the same-property portfolio ended 69.7% leased and 69.4% commenced (no leases signed in the quarter) .
- Dispositions advancing: the two Austin assets and 1250 H Street (Washington, D.C.) are under contract with non-refundable deposits; pricing is consistent with the proxy’s distribution framework; Denver was formally brought to market in September .
- Capital return timeline and catalysts: shareholder vote on the Plan of Sale set for Nov. 12; if approved, company expects to pay off the Series D preferred, then declare an initial common distribution of $18.00–$19.00 per share in early December, with total distributions estimated at $19.50–$21.00 as remaining assets are liquidated through Q1 2025 .
What Went Well and What Went Wrong
What Went Well
- Executing the wind-down: “Our 2 Austin properties and our DC property are now under contract… The closing of these sales are expected to begin in early November, and the buyers have posted nonrefundable deposits.” Pricing, plus expectations for Denver, remain “consistent with the $234 million estimate” discussed previously, supporting the distribution framework .
- Distribution framework reiterated: “We continue to estimate the total distributions resulting from the Plan of Sale will be in the $19.50 to $21 per share range.” Initial common distribution targeted for $18–$19 per share shortly after preferred payoff if the Plan of Sale is approved .
- Balance sheet strength preserved: cash and cash equivalents of $2.225B as of Sept. 30, 2024, providing liquidity to execute the wind-down and distributions .
What Went Wrong
- Earnings hit by impairment: Q3 recorded a $50.2M non-cash impairment tied to assets held for sale, moving GAAP EPS to $(0.26) from $0.22 a year ago .
- Occupancy and NOI declines: same-property NOI decreased 16.0% YoY and cash NOI decreased 15.4% YoY, primarily from lower average commenced occupancy; no new or renewal leases were executed during the quarter .
- Leasing trend deterioration: same-property leased fell to 69.7% from 71.4% in Q2 and 80.8% in Q3 2023; commenced fell to 69.4% from 70.7% in Q2 and 79.9% in Q3 2023 .
Financial Results
Income Statement and Cash Flow Metrics
Portfolio/Operating KPIs
Notes:
- GAAP results include a $50.2M impairment charge related to assets held for sale (Austin x2, Washington, D.C.), of which $33.9M reduced real estate net book value and $16.3M related to non-real estate assets .
- Same-property NOI declines primarily reflect lower average commenced occupancy .
Segment Breakdown
- Not applicable; EQC reports a four-property office portfolio without distinct segments .
Guidance Changes
No revenue, margin, OpEx, tax-rate, or dividend run-rate guidance provided beyond wind-down and distribution framework .
Earnings Call Themes & Trends
Management Commentary
- “Our 2 Austin properties and our DC property are now under contract… The closing of these sales are expected to begin in early November, and the buyers have posted nonrefundable deposits.”
- “We continue to estimate the total distributions resulting from the Plan of Sale will be in the $19.50 to $21 per share range.”
- “Following shareholder approval of the Plan of Sale… we will pay off the Series D preferred and declare a common distribution of $18 to $19 per share with the payments made in early December.”
- “Assuming shareholders approve the plan of Sale, we will adopt liquidation basis accounting for our 2024 10-K.”
- Disposition caution: “Market conditions for selling office assets are uniquely challenging… we may not be able to complete sales in a timely manner… dispositions could be completed for less than estimated” (press release risk language) .
Q&A Highlights
- Preferred vs. common distribution sequencing: “The Series D preferred will be paid first, and then we expect to do the common distribution a few days later… within that 30-day window after the vote.”
- Earnest money and financing risk: Deposits range from 1% to 5% of purchase price; two buyers are all-cash, one subject to financing risk .
- Closing cadence and payout sensitivity: Closings expected to begin in early November and continue thereafter; initial distribution magnitude depends on closing status at that time .
- Wind-down cost check: Wind-down costs “have not changed”; management flagged the need to deduct preferred when reconciling per-share distribution math .
Estimates Context
- S&P Global consensus estimates for Q3 2024 revenue and EPS for EQC were unavailable via our SPGI tool at this time; therefore, we cannot provide a beat/miss assessment relative to Street expectations. We will update when/if S&P Global mappings become available. Values would have been retrieved from S&P Global.
Additional Disposition Detail (as disclosed)
Key Takeaways for Investors
- The quarter’s headline loss is a one-time impairment from classifying three assets as held for sale; FFO remained stable at $0.24–$0.25 per diluted share despite leasing softness, supported by interest income on EQC’s large cash balance .
- The wind-down is moving from concept to execution: vote on Nov. 12, initial common payout targeted for early December (post preferred payoff), and delisting/deregistration/liquidating trust targeted by Q2 2025 if Plan approved—key timeline catalysts for the stock .
- Distribution framework ($19.50–$21.00 total) is reaffirmed with current sales pricing consistent with proxy assumptions; timing and proceeds from Denver and closing mechanics remain the swing factors .
- Leasing is a headwind into the wind-down: no leases signed in Q3 and double-digit declines in same-property NOI/cash NOI underscore the rationale for portfolio exit vs. rehabilitation .
- Liquidity is ample to execute preferred payoff and initial distribution while awaiting closings; cash stood at $2.225B at quarter end .
- Monitoring points: 1) results of Nov. 12 vote; 2) November/December closing flow; 3) exact size/timing of initial common distribution; 4) Denver bids vs. book/implied proxy values; 5) any slippage in sale timelines that could push cash returns into 2025 .
- Consensus benchmarks were not available; price reaction likely to hinge on corporate actions (vote outcome and distributions) rather than operating beats/misses this quarter (S&P Global estimates unavailable).
References: Q3 2024 8-K press release and supplemental ; Q3 2024 earnings call transcript ; Q2 2024 8-K press release and supplemental ; Q1 2024 8-K press release and supplemental .