E2open Parent - Q1 2024
July 10, 2023
Transcript
Operator (participant)
Greetings. Welcome to the E2open First Quarter Fiscal Year 2024 Earnings Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. A question and answer session will follow the formal presentation. If anyone should require operator assistance during the conference, please press star zero on your telephone keypad. Please note, this conference is being recorded. I will now turn the conference over to your host, Dusty Buell. You may begin.
Dusty Buell (Head of Investor Relations)
Good afternoon, everyone. At this time, I would like to welcome you all to the E2open Fiscal First Quarter 2024 Earnings Conference Call. I am Dusty Buell, Head of Investor Relations here at E2open. Today's call will include recorded comments from our Chief Executive Officer, Michael Farlekas, and our Chief Financial Officer, Marje Armstrong. After those comments, we'll open the call for a live Q&A session. A replay of this call will be available on the company's investor relations website at investors.E2open.com. Information to access the replay is listed in today's press release, which is also available on our investor relations website. Before we begin, I'd like to remind everyone that during today's call, we will be making forward-looking statements regarding future events and financial performance, including guidance for our fiscal second quarter and full year 2024.
These forward-looking statements are subject to known and unknown risks and uncertainties. E2open cautions that these statements are not guarantees of future performance. We encourage you to review our most recent reports, including our 10-Q or any applicable amendments, for a complete discussion of these factors and other risks that may affect our future results or the market price of our stock. Finally, we are not obligating ourselves to revise our results or these forward-looking statements in light of new information or future events. Also, during today's call, we'll refer to certain non-GAAP financial measures. Reconciliations of non-GAAP to GAAP measures and certain additional information are included in today's earnings press release, which can be viewed and downloaded from our investor relations website at investors.E2open.com. With that, we'll begin by turning the call over to our CEO, Michael Farlekas.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Thank you, Dusty. Thanks to everyone for joining us today. I'll begin with some high-level remarks on our fiscal first quarter performance, as well as an update on our key strategic focus areas. I'll highlight a few important client success stories and provide my perspective on what they indicate to our strategic market position and our go-forward growth potential. Finally, Marje will review our first quarter financial results and provide our second quarter guidance. We'll open up the call for your questions. Let's begin with our first quarter performance. Overall, we had a solid quarter led by our subscription business. Subscription revenue for the first quarter was $135 million, representing 84% of our total revenue and above the high end of our quarterly guidance. Although we beat guidance, our Q1 subscription growth rate of 4%, in my view, is below our potential.
Despite the slower growth period we are experiencing in FY 2024, during the quarter, we maintained high profit margins, drove strong cash flow, and continued to build operating leverage in our business as we grew Adjusted EBITDA faster than revenue. As we communicated on our Q4 earnings call, the softer subscription revenue growth we are experiencing this year is primarily a function of two factors. The first is the delay in large deal closings as clients continue to scrutinize their spend on long-range strategic projects due to the current macro environment. The second is the timing of churn being more heavily weighted in Q4 of 2023 and the first half of 2024. So far in FY 2024, as we had expected, the overall macro trends have remained similar to the second half of 2023. It is still taking longer to close new deals.
However, during the first quarter, we were able to close several deals that were delayed in FY 2023. I'll describe one of those for you in more detail in a few moments. Our professional services business continues to be impacted by weaker spending by some of our larger technology clients on ongoing services projects. That said, our professional services results also reflect the early signs of success in building a robust ecosystem of system integrators as part of our broader growth strategy. As a reminder, our system integrator strategy, as well as our addition of new subscription products that have little to no attached services revenue, will cause our services growth rate to be lower than our subscription growth rate as we transition a portion of the implementation services work to the SI ecosystem.
This is consistent with our bedrock principle of profitable growth as we focus our attention on driving very high-margin subscription revenue. As I emphasized on last quarter's call, a top priority for E2open is transitioning from an acquisition-oriented company to one that can drive rapid and sustainable organic growth at scale. Over the last year, we have taken multiple actions to strengthen our go-to-market capabilities, including a brand refresh, hiring our first regional EMEA president, and bringing in new leadership in professional services and sales operations. During Q1, we made changes to our sales model to increase sales coverage ratios for high-potential clients and reallocate spend toward account-based marketing. Today, we took another important step in this process with our announcement that Greg Randolph will join E2open in the newly created role of Chief Commercial Officer.
In this new role, Greg will lead our commercial organization with a keen focus on increasing our subscription growth rate. Greg is a highly accomplished executive who has led high-performing sales teams and go-to-market transformation at leading software enterprises such as Quest Software and CA Technologies. He has significant hands-on experience in selling motions that are similar at E2open, including managing complex sales cycles with large enterprise clients, marketing and selling a platform that consists of diverse solutions, and utilizing cross-sell to expand existing clients' use of our platform. Greg is a great fit for our organization and for the new role of Chief Commercial Officer. He and I will work closely over the coming quarters to enhance and further build out our repeatable sales model to drive the organic phase of E2open's growth.
Before concluding my remarks and turning the call over to Marje, I want to describe for you some exciting business highlights from the first quarter. In the first quarter, we closed a large project with Ford Motor Company that builds on E2open's prior success and strength in the automotive industry transformation. We believe this win demonstrates our ability to deliver on multiple levers of E2open strategy. It advances E2open's path to become the SaaS supply chain platform provider of choice, the largest network enabling multi-tier supplier collaboration across the automotive industry. It exemplifies the need for multiple solutions across our connected supply chain platform for business operations. It also proves our ability to engage our clients for cross-sell opportunities and demonstrates that system integrators are integral strategic partners, particularly on large projects.
This new project deserves special attention because it highlights the value and potential we see in our platform in areas such as technology leadership, strategic partnerships, and organic growth. Our prior work with this iconic client allowed us to build deep, collaborative relationships and provide a strong basis for engaging them on additional areas of their business. The automotive industry is undergoing a major technology shift from traditional internal combustion engine vehicles to smart electric vehicles that heavily rely on microchips and sensors. These critical components are globally constrained. There are simply not enough of them to meet the diverse needs of a global economy. As a result, the auto industry has been challenged to meet customer demand for cars and is now adapting to manage constrained supply, much in the same way that the high-tech industry adapted over the past 20 years.
Our network and applications were built specifically for this purpose and are ideally positioned to help the auto sector adapt to an increasingly complex manufacturing process. Drawing on E2open's deep experience in executing transformative projects with automotive leaders, this win demonstrates E2open's ability to expand client relationships and implement multiple solutions across our connected supply chain platform. A key ingredient to this success, especially for supplier collaboration, is E2open's reusable network of over 420,000 connected parties. This win and several other transformational wins in the quarter highlight our primary competitive advantages, namely, the unique nature of our network-centric software platform and our deep experience serving large customers with complex global supply chains. We also had several other success stories from our first quarter.
During the quarter, a leading provider of IoT services for transportation and logistics applications selected E2open's advanced supply chain planning and collaboration solutions to manage demand, supply, and inventory across its operations. The client will now be able to automate more tools and communications across its supply chain network, stay ahead of potential disruptions, and respond more quickly to changes in customer demand. Our technology leadership also received a major recognition during the first quarter. For the first time, E2open was named a leader in the 2023 Gartner Magic Quadrant for Transportation Management Systems. We believe that combining key aspects of our global network and platform, with the highly scalable, multi-mode, and multi-regional transportation management system we acquired as a BluJay combination, helped us achieve this improved position. During the quarter, we completed multiple go-lives across a number of product suites, industries, and geographies.
This includes deploying E2open's Global Trade Management solution for Rio Tinto, the world's second-largest metals and mining company, operating in 35 countries. Each quarter, we add new functionality to our software platform to better serve the supply chain needs of our diverse client base. As just one example, during the first quarter, we released enhancements to our Global Logistics Orchestration solution, or GLO, that further automates and reduces risks associated with global shipments. These enhancements automate previously time-consuming manual tasks, such as rebooking all legs of committed shipments and screening against government lists of denied or restricted parties. Speaking more broadly about software innovation, I also want to comment on our company's approach to artificial intelligence.
While the world is now paying close attention to how AI can be commercialized more fully, I want to make clear that E2open has used artificial intelligence and machine learning to enhance our software offerings for nearly two decades. AI is a core element of our Demand Sensing and inventory optimization solutions that support the global operations of some of the world's largest companies. We also rely heavily on AI to process the billions of transactions that flow through our network and perform critical functions such as data anomaly detection. AI is, and will remain, very important to our product innovation strategy. As we make further investments in our software platform, we will continue to look for ways to further leverage the power of AI for the benefit of all of our clients and our company.
Before closing, I want to express my many thanks to E2open's 4,000 talented team members around the world for demonstrating our company's operating principles and values every day. Your commitment to build stronger client relationships, to innovate, and to operate efficiently are key to our company's success and to the unique value proposition we provide to our clients. Now, I'd like to hand the call over to Marje to review our first quarter financial results. Marje?
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
Thank you, Michael. Good afternoon, everyone. I want to start by thanking the E2open finance team, as we've had an incredibly productive start to the year, with several notable accomplishments. We went live with the ERP integration of our acquired logistics business, drove a variety of improvements focused on driving cash flow and operational efficiency across multiple company functions, completed the build-out of our finance leadership team. These efforts helped E2open achieve strong profitability and drive operating leverage during the first quarter, despite the below normal top-line growth rate. As I mark my one-year anniversary as the CFO of E2open, I'm proud of what the finance team has accomplished in a short time. Turning to results, I'll start by reviewing our fiscal first quarter 2024, then close with a discussion of our Q2 and full year FY 2024 guidance.
Subscription revenue in the fiscal first quarter 2024 was $134.9 million, reflecting an organic growth rate of 4.2%, and 4.4% on a constant currency basis, when adjusting for the -$0.3 million year-over-year impact from foreign exchange fluctuations. Our subscription revenue came in above the high end of our $131 million-$134 million guidance range, primarily due to the timing of large deals that closed earlier than expected during the quarter. Professional services and other revenue in the fiscal first quarter was $25.2 million, reflecting an organic growth rate of -18.2% and -17.1% on a constant currency basis, when adjusting for a -$0.3 million year-over-year impact from foreign exchange fluctuations.
On our last earnings call, we noted that our fiscal 2024 first quarter services revenues were expected to decline sequentially from our Q4 of FY2023. We expected this decline in part due to the strategy we have undertaken to transition services revenue to our system integrator partners. However, Q1 services revenues came in weaker than expected, primarily due to the continuing trend of weak spending by large customers on ongoing service projects that have traditionally been an important source of baseline service revenues for us. As Michael noted earlier, we have recently brought new leadership into our services organization as part of our larger plan to enhance and reorganize our go-to-market function. These changes should help us maintain our profitable services franchise, even as we continue our strategic pivot to shift services work to integrators partners as a means to drive faster future subscription growth.
We're seeing positive momentum with our customer base on expanding existing PS projects and discussing new engagements. We expect services revenue to be sequentially flat to slightly higher in the second quarter and to further improve sequentially in the second half of the year. Total revenue for the fiscal first quarter was $160.1 million, reflecting organic growth of -0.2% over the prior year quarter, and 0.2% growth on a constant currency basis, after adjusting for a -$0.7 million year-over-year impact from foreign exchange fluctuations. Turning to gross profit, in the fiscal first quarter of 2024, our gross profit was $110.4 million, reflecting a 0.8% decrease on an organic basis and 0.7% decrease on a constant currency basis.
Gross margin was 69.0% in the first quarter, or 68.7% on a constant currency basis, compared to 69.4% in the prior year quarter. The small year-over-year reduction was mainly due to lower Q1 professional service margins, which we expect to improve in the second half as services resource utilization improves. Turning to EBITDA, our first quarter Adjusted EBITDA was $53.8 million, compared to $51.4 million in the prior year quarter, an increase of 4.6% and 3.4% on a constant currency basis. First quarter Adjusted EBITDA margin was 33.6%, or 33.0% on a constant currency basis, compared to EBITDA margin of 32.0% for the prior year quarter.
This continued growth in Adjusted EBITDA, which grew faster than total revenue during the first quarter, reflects an incremental benefit in the first quarter from headcount-related cost actions, as well as lower spend on consulting, contractors, and facilities. More broadly, our EBITDA performance again demonstrates our ability to realize the benefits of operating leverage, which is fundamental to how we run the business. While accelerating growth is our number one goal, and we are committed to invest as needed to drive the top line, we will maintain our strong focus on an efficient cost structure and operational discipline. Finishing up on profitability, net loss for the fiscal first quarter of 2023 was $360.9 million. This net loss figure includes a non-cash goodwill impairment charge of $410.0 million during the quarter.
As previously discussed, the carrying value of E2open's goodwill increased significantly as part of our IPO transaction because it was reset using the offering price of $10 per share. GAAP requires companies to continually monitor goodwill carrying value by evaluating potential triggering events, including share price decline. It is important to note that the triggering event for the Q1 impairment was the decline in our share price that took place following our Q4 FY23 earnings release. We want to emphasize that the impairment charge was not driven by operational or performance issues related to any of our products or acquired businesses. Turning to cash flow. During the first fiscal quarter, we generated $37.3 million of adjusted operating cash flows.
The primary driver of this strong cash flow was good collections performance during the quarter, which is a testament to the broader finance team's commitment to driving working capital improvements this year. I would note that due to a combination of seasonal factors and our annual cash bonuses being paid now in the beginning of Q2, we expect sequentially lower cash flow in the second quarter. Growth in cash flow continues to be a core objective for our management team, and we view cash flow growth as a strong indicator of the competitive advantage of our business model and as an important source of financial flexibility as we seek to optimize our capital structure and fund future strategic growth. Before turning to guidance, I want to provide an update on our integration efforts related to our acquisition of Logistyx.
Since closing this transaction in 2022, multiple E2open teams have worked hard to drive the integration process and meet our cost and operating synergy targets. I'm very pleased to report that shortly after the end of the first quarter, we completed the integration of Logistyx into our existing ERP platform. With this project behind us, the logistics integration is now substantially complete, and all of E2open's core business operations and entities are on a single ERP instance. I'm also pleased to report that we have exceeded our synergy targets for the logistics acquisition. Total transaction synergies were originally projected to be just over $10 million. As of the end of Q1, we have actioned $10.1 million of synergy and now expect to realize approximately $11.6 million in synergy savings for full year FY 2024. This completes my remarks on our fiscal Q1 2024 results.
At this point, I'll turn to a discussion of financial guidance. In terms of new guidance for the fiscal second quarter of this year, we expect FY24 second quarter subscription revenue to be in the range of $132 million-$135 million. This represents a growth rate of 0.3%-2.6% as compared to the prior fiscal year first quarter. Turning to full fiscal year 2024, we're reiterating the full year guidance we issued last quarter, which, as a reminder, consists of the following elements. We expect subscription revenue in the range of $545 million-$555 million for FY24. We expect FY24 total revenue to be within the range of $655 million-$670 million.
We expect FY 2024 gross profit margin to be within a range of 68%-70%. We expect FY 2024 Adjusted EBITDA to be within the range of $218 million-$228 million. This range implies an Adjusted EBITDA margin of 33%-34% for FY 2024. On our fourth quarter earnings call, in addition to providing formal guidance on revenue margin and Adjusted EBITDA, we also provided additional details around certain key drivers of cash flow generation for FY 2024. Emphasizing the strong importance we place on cash flow generation as a key performance indicator, I would like to provide an update on our cash flow-related expectations for the year. We continue to expect FY 2024 to be a strong cash flow year, and we're off to a strong start with our robust Q1 cash performance.
In terms of key drivers for FY 2024 cash flow, our expectation around full year CapEx have not changed. We still expect it to be approximately 5% of revenue in FY 2024 versus 7% of revenue in FY 2023, which included M&A-related CapEx. We still plan to drive significant year-over-year improvements in working capital and expect FY 2024 working capital to be a modest use of cash. We now expect net cash interest to be within a range of $95 million-$99 million, an increase of approximately $5 million from our estimate provided last quarter. This increase is primarily because the LIBOR SOFR curve through our fiscal year-end has steepened, reflecting revised market expectations for sustained higher Fed funds rates.
Our new projection for full-year cash interest includes the benefit of interest incomes we are earning due to our strong cash generation, and also cash receipts on the interest rate collars we executed during Q1 that have now moved into the money because of rising rates. We still expect one-time cash costs, including M&A integration, which were $29 million in FY 2023, to be substantially lower in FY 2024. Given our outlook for strong FY 2024 cash generation, we still expect to reduce our net leverage to 4x or below by the end of the fiscal year. To sum up, we continue to focus on driving cash flow and profitability, while strategically investing in our business to lay the foundation for faster organic revenue growth. That concludes our prepared remarks.
Thank you all for joining us today. We look forward to continuing the dialogue as we move throughout the year. With that, Michael and I are ready to take your questions. Operator, please open up the line and begin the Q&A session.
Operator (participant)
At this time, we will be conducting a question-and-answer session. If you would like to ask a question, please press star one on your telephone keypad. A confirmation tone will indicate your line is in the question queue. You may press star two if you would like to remove your question from the queue. For participants using speaker equipment, it may be necessary to pick up your handset before pressing the star keys. One moment please, while we poll for questions. Our first question comes from Adam Hotchkiss with Goldman Sachs. Please proceed.
Adam Hotchkiss (VP and Equity Research Analyst in Emerging Software and Technology)
Great. Thanks very much for taking my question. You talked a little bit about the organic sales efforts and some of the spend reallocation, in reorganizing your sales efforts, for organic growth. Could you just talk a little bit about how that's been going? You know, how you think about what the right level of spend there is? What do you think about, when you think about the timeframe around ramping that new sales coverage for that reallocation, you know, what does that look like in terms of driving, business outcomes for you guys? Thanks so much.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Hey, thanks, Adam. Good to hear your voice. Yeah, we've done most of that work in the early part of the fiscal year. We've kind of are through kind of the change. The change is really more allocating more resource to our largest clients, where we have the most opportunity. In the middle and back half of the year, we'll start adding, you know, additional headcount as we kind of work into next year. That kind of lift is behind us now, we would expect to see, you know, that step up with the other initiatives we have, you know, through the rest of the year, all, the idea of getting our growth back to where we think it should be.
Adam Hotchkiss (VP and Equity Research Analyst in Emerging Software and Technology)
Great. No, that's super helpful, Michael. Then, Marje, just on the subscription revenue guidance, it looks like you maintained that despite the pretty strong results in the first quarter. Anything to read in there other than just being prudent around the uncertain macro environment?
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
Yeah, thank you for the question, Adam. We're very proud of our Q1 results and coming in above our guidance range. As mentioned in my prepared remarks, it was really primarily due to sort of timing of some large deals closing earlier in the quarter, which again, is a good sign, but, you know, this early in the year, we think it's prudent to maintain the guidance range as set. Again, you know, it was set really two months ago. Overall, I would say things are progressing as we had expected, no update to full-year guidance.
Adam Hotchkiss (VP and Equity Research Analyst in Emerging Software and Technology)
Great. That's really helpful. Last one for me, just wanted to touch on the services business. Could you just give us a sense on how you parse out that base of revenue between things like ongoing discretionary services that may be impacted, like things you saw in the quarter, versus the more one-time implementation costs? Just it'd be great to understand and get some more color on, you know, how much of that services revenue is exposed to some of the headwinds that you mentioned in the first quarter number. Thanks.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Yeah, thanks for that. We have a fair amount of ongoing services work, mostly from many of our very large, you know, high-tech customers who've been with us a long time, where they continually, you know, adjust and upgrade and, you know, tweak the implementation. Many customers have been, you know, using the platform for 8 to 10 years. That got, you know, curtailed a bit, really in, you know, this period and a little bit after that, last year, as you know, most of the technology companies were suffering from, you know, everybody saw macro conditions and their own desire to get more profitable.
We haven't really kind of broken that out, but it's a, it's a fairly large percentage of that, and that kind of reset, which I think on a year-on-year basis is why it's come down. We expect that to kind of normalize as you get in the back half of the year, as that work kind of comes back on. The other thing that I'll mention is that on the service business, we are giving up, you know, some of our services revenue to the system integrators, as that part of our growth strategy, you know, starting to materialize. Lastly, we are having additional subscription products that come with very low attach rates, mostly on the network side of our business.
Those three things kind of in unison are affecting our services, you know, business for now, which is why we expect that to continue to decouple from our subscription growth rate going forward.
Adam Hotchkiss (VP and Equity Research Analyst in Emerging Software and Technology)
Great. Really helpful. Thanks, Michael. Thanks, Marje.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Thanks, Adam.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Taylor McGinnis with UBS. Please proceed.
Taylor McGinnis (Equity Research Analyst)
Yeah, hi, thanks so much for taking my question. The first one I have is, I know Greg hasn't started yet, but just any high-level thoughts you can share on expectations, you know, you have for him in this new role? I know, you know, last quarter, you talked about some of the sales disruption and, you know, some of the changes it sounds like that you've made. You're starting to see some normalization there. Just curious if there's any, you know, future sales changes that you're anticipating or anything on that front. The second part of this question is, Marje, just curious how this, you know, impacts or not your comfort level with the guidance on the top line and the margins.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Taylor, thanks for the question. You know, as we've kind of articulated, you know, we built this business over the past, you know, almost decade, now, eight years, around the idea of scaling rapidly. We did that, grew the business, you know, 10x, and became, you know, a very profitable company in doing so. We kind of centered our attention on operations, as that was the necessary requirement for that part of our growth strategy and our COO, and it was titled that way because it was operationally oriented.
I think our, you know, as part of our, you know, multi-step plan, and we're kind of getting, you know, to the place where we want to be, is that we really need to have a regular way, you know, organic, sales-driven leader that has grown up in that part of the world. Greg brings all his attributes from his experiences and mostly around selling for large companies at scale. Last company is worth $1.2 billion and really understanding how to build a scaled sales team that is on repeatable, you know, process. That's kind of what's necessary for us going forward. Super thrilled to have him, then, you know, really excited about the go forward in terms of that.
In terms of, you know, next steps, we've been making these incremental steps along the way. I don't expect a rapid or dramatic shift, but, just incremental improvement as we kind of build a, you know, a very repeatable organic sales engine. Marje?
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
Yeah, absolutely. You know, just to add to that, in terms of the impact to our top line, again, we're reiterating our full year guidance. You know, a lot of the changes that we've talked about, it's all part of the plan for the year, right? Was contemplated when we set guidance. In terms of the cost impact, you know, goes same way. There's no change to guidance from this change. We talked about incremental investments on the sales team and go-to-market overall, but nothing really to update. Again, this is all part of the plan sort of for the year.
Taylor McGinnis (Equity Research Analyst)
Awesome. Super helpful. Then, my last question is, you talked about, when you think about the, like, back half, you know, of the guidance or what's, you know, implied for the full year, on a sequential basis, it sounds like, you know, subscription revenue, improving versus what we saw in 1Q. You talked about services revenue, you know, sequential growth improving versus what we saw in 1Q. Just curious, what you guys are seeing maybe from, you know, a bookings perspective, or you talked about some large deals that closed in the quarter that I guess is giving you that comfort that we could see, you know, some recovery in those numbers?
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
Absolutely. You know, as mentioned, as you're referencing, we had mentioned that we expect, you know, second half of the subscription business to be better, and that's primarily driven really, the first half churn being more first half weighted this year. Then, you know, as you mentioned, we have seen some large deals, you know, close in Q1, which is encouraging. Again, in terms of the macro and overall, I would say it's as expected, you know, sort of stabilizing, but we're not seeing, you know, anything very different than what we discussed, two months ago in terms of the macro impact.
On the services side, as we mentioned earlier, we do expect services revenues to be sort of flat to slightly up in Q2. We are seeing some encouraging signs in the business. Very excited about the new leadership there and just really the momentum that some of the changes are taking on, and we're really hopeful that second half will be better based on the initial signs. No real change in terms of what we saw when we last spoke two months ago.
Operator (participant)
Okay, the next question comes from Fred Lee with Credit Suisse. Please proceed.
Fred Lee (Equity Research Analyst in Technology and Software)
Hi, Michael, good to hear from you. last quarter, just to expand a little bit more on macro, just because last quarter, you talked about the first half being tougher than the second half for fiscal 2024. I was just wondering if macro deteriorated sequentially from fiscal Q from Q4-Q1? It sounds like it stabilized a little bit, but I was just wondering, just to be crystal clear, if it's deteriorated or if it's stabilized into the end of Q1.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Hi, Fred. How you doing? No, I don't think it's deteriorated. I mean, it's still, you know, the market's still choppy, and, you know, you look at kind of, you know, and other parts of our business, especially on the freight side, still kind of trying to work it through its process. You know, on the trucking side, you see that all over the place. I don't really think it's deteriorating, I just think it's choppy. You know, some companies doing well, some companies not doing so well. I just think it's choppy for right now, but I would not say it's deteriorating. I'd say more, it's more on the stabilizing side than deteriorating at this point. That's how I'd characterize it.
Fred Lee (Equity Research Analyst in Technology and Software)
Okay, that's good to hear. My second question is related to your appetite for incremental acquisitions. Now that the integration of Logistyx sounds like it's largely behind the company, sounds like most synergies have been realized. Have valuations come in the private marketplace enough to pique your interest?
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Listen, we've we grew our business through acquisitions, and we have a great mechanism to do that. However, you know, for us to really realize the potential we see, we really kind of need to, you know, focus our attention on a sustainable organic growth rate and kind of a more regular way sales organization as we are a scale business now in our revenue size. That's our primary focus. I don't think it'll be our primary focus forever, but it is our primary focus for the time being. And in terms of valuations, look, there's there's gonna be a time when all these smaller companies come to market. I don't think it's there yet, and I think, you know, price expectations are still, you know, pretty high.
I think, now's a great time for us to, you know, build an organic sales engine that we know we can.
Fred Lee (Equity Research Analyst in Technology and Software)
Got it. Thank you. My last question is, just related to your conviction in churn declining in the back half. As we kind of look through your subscription revenue, the implied numbers and the growth in the back half of the year, how do we gain conviction that churn is going to downtick over the next couple of quarters? Thank you.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Yeah. We've done a lot of analysis on this, and we kind of looked at it, you know, nine pages from Sunday, Fred. You know, we have a very specific way of understanding, you know, where our clients are. And we have a pretty strong conviction that in the back half of this year and into next, that churn normalizes. It and remember, we have world-class churn, and it ticked up a bit. It just happened that it happened, just happened to happen in Q4 and the first half of this year. We expect it to normalize and then kind of be back where we were.
obviously, that has an impact for revenue, and as a lagging indicator, and we expect that to kind of get better as we go into next year.
Operator (participant)
Okay, the next question comes from Mark Schappel with Loop Capital. Mark, please proceed.
Mark Schappel (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Technology and Software)
Hi, good afternoon. Thank you for taking my question. Michael, starting with you, I was wondering, if you could just give a little more comments or details on the Ford win? I appreciate your comments, but I was wondering if you could provide additional details on maybe some of the products or solutions that they're using? Also, you know, what were some of the drivers for their decision to, it looks like, deepen the relationship with you?
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Yeah, it was a great win. They're a great company, obviously iconic company, and couldn't be any happier. They're super important to us, have been and are obviously now. Unfortunately, we're not really able to kind of go into more details. We're thankful for them to allow us to use their name. That was a big lift, and a big appreciation that I have for them. I can speak a little bit about the automotive industry and what I see there, from a supply chain perspective. This is a generalized comment about, you know, automotive supply chains. Automotive supply chains are multi-tier, and everyone knows this, you know, tier one, two, and three suppliers. For a long time, automobiles were made with readily available materials.
You know, I need aluminum, I need, you know, tires, I need things that are made in mass and readily available. The change that has happened in the last three years is that the supply materials and componentry is much more constrained on a global basis. Understanding deeper into a company's supply chain, what their constrained supply is, has a really big impact to what they can actually produce every day on a production line. The further they can look out into what that supply base looks like, the more the confidence they'll have to be able to not have, you know, a car that's, you know, 99.9% complete, but doesn't have the right chip, has to be reworked.
This is the same problem that the high tech industry solved literally 20 years ago, which has to do with making a much more network-based, connected supply chain. That's an industry, automotive industry, you know, perspective that I have, and I've been talking to many automotive companies. I just want to give you that perspective in terms of the auto industry and kind of the change that is happening within the auto industry. Ford's a great company, and I really can't speak any more about, you know, what we're doing with them other than what our, you know, comments I've made in the press release.
Mark Schappel (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Technology and Software)
I appreciate your comments there. Secondly, in your prepared remarks, you noted that subscription growth, while above guidance, was still below what you thought was the company's potential. I was wondering if you just maybe add some clarity to those remarks. Was there something you saw in the quarter that led you to that, or is it, is this just going back to prior quarters?
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
No, this is just a general comment, Mark. I appreciate that clarification you allow me to make. I just think we have more potential to grow this business organically, and, you know, I think we have to kind of change our business a bit, to kind of get to that potential. It's nothing to do with the quarter. You know, listen, we have long-term guidance out there, you know, that's in 12% plus. We think that's very possible, at these margin levels, and I, and I think that's an important clarification. We, we are focused on generating high margins in a business. We think we can do both, which makes us a, you know, very unique kind of company. That's what I meant by below our potential.
I believe that we have, you know, greater potential to grow, and we have some operational things to, you know, take care of in terms of our go-to-market.
Mark Schappel (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Technology and Software)
I appreciate that. That's all for me. Thanks.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Thanks.
Operator (participant)
Okay, the next question is from Chad Bennett with Craig-Hallum. Please proceed, Chad.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Great, thanks for taking my question. Just wanna make sure I understand the large deal commentary. I think, Marje, you indicated in your prepared remarks that you saw several large deals hit earlier in the quarter, and then I think Michael indicated that there were large deals that you actually recouped from prior quarters this quarter. Are those one and the same, commentary-wise?
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Yeah, I, good to hear your voice, Greg. Yeah, I think what we're saying is, we had, as we said last time, our large deal pipeline is grown. A lot of that's because they pushed. Because of that, we were able to get some of those in. We had a pretty good quarter with large deals, and they just happened to happen a little earlier in the quarter, which kind of helped us out from a revenue perspective. We signed, you know, we signed large deals that are, they're somewhat impactful given the kind of the quarterly revenue flow. I think they are one and the same. That's a good catch.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Okay. With that in mind, if you recoup some and I guess you incrementally added some, your calculated subscription billings were effectively flat year-over-year, and you guided for subscription growth of, call it 1.4, mid 1% growth for the second quarter here, year-over-year. I, and I think other people have asked this on the call. The conviction, I guess, churn improving in the second half, are you expecting, you know, the macro to improve in the second half? How do we...
I'm not saying it's a high bar, but you got to see pretty significant reacceleration in the second half relative to where we are in Q2 and where billings were in Q1, to get to, you know, kind of your midpoint. I'm just kind of trying to understand the logic there.
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
Chad, I think when you're looking at billings growth, it was over 4% in Q1. I think maybe what you're not doing is normalizing out the logistics impact from a year ago. you know, happy to go through.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Subscription billing? Subscription billing.
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
Yes.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Okay.
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
Happy to go through those numbers specifically with you later.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Sure.
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
I think you're not taking out the logistics from last year.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Well, logistics should have annualized, right?
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
Normalized for logistics, subscription billings year-over-year growth was, you know, just over 4%.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
So-
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
Sorry, what was the follow-up from that question? I just wanted to correct that, but.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Okay. Didn't you have the logistics a full quarter last year also, or am I wrong?
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
That's a, you basically need to normalize that out from the balances from that quarter. It's a normalized change in the accounts receivable.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Okay.
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
Happy to walk through on that. Happy to walk through how that normalization works.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Okay. You don't expect any macro improvement in the second half? Maybe that's the best way to ask it.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
I think we're expecting it to be, as we kind of said, Greg, I think we're kind of seeing, as expected. We didn't build a lot of macro build into our overall plan for the year. I think things are progressing as expected.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Okay. Is there a way to think about just in the existing base today, Michael, how many customers have, you know, more than two, three, four modules from a penetration standpoint?
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
You know, we do some of that work. We know that especially with the addition of the last two acquisitions, which had more customers. Specifically, BluJay had a lot of larger customers added. We are seeing incremental pickup, but many of them have either one or two still, when we kind of bring them in. By definition, they come in with a single point solution company, because that's.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Yeah
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
... all that company had. That, that process, you know, that doesn't happen overnight. We have many examples of adding, you know, solutions to clients, and we've kind of mentioned one on the call today. You know, that process continues. I think that's really the long-term, you know, potential we see in the business, is that, you know, people don't change their supply chain applications overnight. They don't just change them out because, you know, they now have more access under a single partner. Over time, our probability of success is incremented because they're already clients, already know us, already have proven success with us.
kind of what takes me back to, you know, to, you know, Mark's question around our conviction about, you know, growth, is because we have a lot of solutions, we have a lot of customers, and, you know, it's just a matter of, you know, penetrating that over time. Which gets us back to, you know, the long-term nature of our strategy, because those customers aren't going to go away, and their need for supply chain software only increases over time.
Chad Bennett (SVP and Senior Equity Research Analyst in Software)
Got it. Thanks for taking my question.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Great. Great hearing your voice.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Andrew Obin, with Bank of America. Please proceed.
David Ridley-Lane (Equity Research Analyst in Multi-Industrials and Technology)
Good evening. This is David Ridley-Lane, on for Andrew Obin. Just wondering on the second quarter guidance, and what that implies sort of on a sequential basis for subscription revenue, how much of that is just the last bit of this elevated churn, versus what you're expecting in bookings? What are sort of the puts and takes if you looked at it sequentially?
Marje Armstrong (CFO)
I would say, you know, churn, as you mentioned, is a big part of that. You know, again, we don't provide specific bookings guidance, but, you know, obviously, churn the elevated churn in the first half that we've talked about in prior quarter, and this quarter has, you know, the main impact here.
David Ridley-Lane (Equity Research Analyst in Multi-Industrials and Technology)
Got it. Based on the, on the bookings so far this year, are you starting to you know, I know you mentioned a couple of client wins, but more broadly, I think, you know, the large client behavior was the sort of the thing that had shifted on you. Are you starting to see signs that that's improving?
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
I'd say, you know, it's partly because we had a number of deals that were in our pipeline for a long time that have come through. I don't really see. I still think big companies are very judicious about, you know, writing, you know, long-term commitments for large ticket items overall. They're very cautious at this point, so they're not rushing to do that. The things that do get approved go through multiple steps. I don't think that really has changed, so the duration has increased in our pipelines. We see that. Obviously, that means they tick up a bit, and then when you have a lot of large deals go, it goes down a bit.
I don't, I don't think there's a lot of change in behavior or sentiment at this point. I think people are still trying to understand this macro environment, where you have high inflation, high employment at the same time, and you have an increasingly aggressive monetary policy. I think everybody's trying to figure out what that looks like in the, as the year goes on. There's been a forecasted recession now for the last 5 quarters or 6 quarters, and I think everybody's trying to figure out, is that gonna happen or not happen?
you know, I think this is for us, in our particular markets, a bit of a normal, and I think that normal is gonna last a bit, to be honest with you.
David Ridley-Lane (Equity Research Analyst in Multi-Industrials and Technology)
Understood. Thank you very much.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Great. Thank you.
Operator (participant)
We have no further questions in queue. We have reached the end of the question and answer session. This concludes today's conference, and you may disconnect your lines at this time. Thank you for your participation.
Michael Farlekas (CEO)
Thank you.