Sign in

You're signed outSign in or to get full access.

GI

Global Indemnity Group, LLC (GBLI)·Q4 2024 Earnings Summary

Executive Summary

  • FY 2024 delivered materially better underwriting and earnings: diluted EPS rose to $3.12 (+70%), consolidated combined ratio improved to 95.6% from 99.7%, and Penn‑America’s accident-year combined ratio hit 94.4% .
  • Sequentially, Q3 2024 showed improved profitability vs Q2 (combined ratio 94.3% vs 96.6%; EPS $0.92 vs $0.73), driven by lower loss and expense ratios .
  • Management prioritized growth over buybacks; discretionary capital rose to $255M and duration is set to increase as reinvestment proceeds at higher yields; dividend maintained at $0.35 per quarter .
  • A significant Q1 2025 event tied to Q4 themes: ~$15M loss from Los Angeles wildfires prompted reassessment of wildfire models and rate adequacy, a potential narrative catalyst for capital deployment, underwriting mix, and California exposure strategy .

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

  • What Went Well

    • Underwriting improvement: consolidated combined ratio improved to 95.6% FY 2024 (loss ratio 56.6%, expense 39.0%); Penn‑America posted 94.4% accident-year combined ratio and $22.1M accident-year underwriting income .
    • Investment income momentum: +13% YoY to $62.4M; book yield 4.4% with AA‑ credit quality; reinvestments at ~5.2% and plan to extend duration to ~1.25 years by end Q1 2025 .
    • Growth in focus segments: InsurTech +17% to $56.3M, Assumed Reinsurance +83% to $25.4M, Wholesale Commercial underlying policy premium +12% (incl. ~7% rate), supporting 12% Penn‑America GWP growth ex-terminated products .

  • What Went Wrong

    • Elevated expense ratio: Penn‑America expense ratio at 38.1% (above long‑term 36–37% target); corporate expenses rose ~$5M on Project Manifest professional fees .
    • Runoff drag: Non‑Core operations still produced high combined ratios (current accident-year combined ratio 145.6%), though exposure is shrinking .
    • Catastrophe exposure surprise: ~$15M loss from LA wildfires substantially exceeded wildfire model tail expectations; management is reassessing model validity and rate needs in California .

Financial Results

  • Quarterly sequential trends (older → newer):
MetricQ2 2024Q3 2024Q4 2024
Total Revenues ($USD Millions)$108.687 $111.761 N/A
Net Income Available to Shareholders ($USD Millions)$9.983 $12.650 N/A
Diluted EPS ($USD)$0.73 $0.92 N/A
Loss Ratio (%)56.5% 56.0% N/A
Expense Ratio (%)39.2% 39.2% N/A
Combined Ratio (%)95.7% 95.2% N/A
Combined Ratio (Consolidated, period press) (%)96.6% 94.3% N/A
  • Year-over-year quarterly comparison (Q3):
MetricQ3 2023Q3 2024
Total Revenues ($USD Millions)$126.061 $111.761
Diluted EPS ($USD)$0.55 $0.92
Loss Ratio (%)58.3% 54.9%
Expense Ratio (%)41.4% 39.4%
Combined Ratio (%)99.7% 94.3%
  • Annual performance:
MetricFY 2023FY 2024
Total Revenues ($USD Millions)$528.129 $441.187
Net Income Available to Shareholders ($USD Millions)$24.989 $42.801
Diluted EPS ($USD)$1.83 $3.12
Investment Income ($USD Millions)$55.444 $62.375
Loss Ratio (%)61.1% 56.6%
Expense Ratio (%)38.6% 39.0%
Combined Ratio (%)99.7% 95.6%
Book Value per Share ($)$47.53 $49.98
  • Segment breakdown (FY):
SegmentFY 2023 ($USD Millions)FY 2024 ($USD Millions)YoY
Wholesale Commercial (Penn-America GWP)$234.9 $248.6 +6%
InsurTech (Penn-America GWP)$48.3 $56.3 +17%
Assumed Reinsurance (Penn-America GWP)$13.9 $25.4 +83%
Specialty Products (Penn-America)$72.6 $69.7 −4%
Penn-America Total GWP$369.7 $400.0 +8%
Non-Core Operations GWP$46.7 $(10.2) −122%
Consolidated GWP$416.4 $389.8 −6%
  • KPIs (FY and balance sheet):
KPIFY 2023FY 2024
Catastrophe Losses ($USD Millions)$17.2 $12.7
Penn-America Expense Ratio (%)37.8% 38.1%
Cash & Invested Assets ($USD Millions)$1,390.4 $1,440.7
Shareholders’ Equity ($USD Millions)$648.8 $689.1
Book Yield (Fixed-Income) (%)4.0% 4.4%
Fixed-Income Duration (Years)1.1 (12/31/2023) 0.8 (12/31/2024)
Discretionary Capital ($USD Millions)$200 (12/31/2023) $255 (12/31/2024)

Guidance Changes

MetricPeriodPrevious GuidanceCurrent GuidanceChange
Penn‑America revenue growth (GWP)FY 2025Long‑term ~10% CAGR target Expect ~10% growth in 2025 Maintained
Penn‑America expense ratioFY 2025–2026Target 36–37% 38.1% in 2024; aiming ~37% over next years; room to reduce without compromising underwriting quality Maintained
Fixed‑income durationQ1 2025~0.8–1.0 years in 2024 Increase to ~1.25 years by end Q1 2025 Raised duration
Quarterly dividendOngoing$0.35 per share (Dec 2024) $0.35 per share (Mar 2025) Maintained
Share repurchasesNear‑termConsidered tender/special dividend if capital not deployed Board prioritizing growth investments; no special dividend planned; buybacks deferred Deferred
Annual cat loss expectationFY 2025Not specifiedExpect normal-year average ~$16–$17M cat losses based on current book New commentary
California rate actions (vacant property)FutureRate increases stalled in regulatory process Need at least ~50% rate increase; may reduce writings if rates inadequate Heightened focus

Earnings Call Themes & Trends

TopicPrevious Mentions (Q2 2024 and Q3 2024)Current Period (Q4 2024)Trend
Technology/cloud migrationBegan modular, cloud-based transaction platform; first releases planned for H2; book yields and duration positioning ~75% cloud completed; excess liability live; special events added; integrated underwriting workstation deploying Advancing execution
Investment portfolioBook yield ~4.5% (Q2), duration ~1.0; large maturities to redeploy Book yield 4.4%, duration 0.8; reinvested ~$320M at 5.2%; duration to ~1.25 by end Q1 2025 Higher reinvestment yields, modest duration extension
Cat exposuresH1 cat losses down 36%; managing property cat FY cat losses down 26% YoY; LA wildfires ~$15M; reassessing wildfire model tails One-off wildfire spike; ongoing model recalibration
Expense disciplineElevated expense ratio, plan multi‑year reduction to 36–37% Penn‑America expense ratio 38.1%; target maintained; corporate costs up ~$5M for Project Manifest Gradual improvement; near‑term cost investments
Assumed Reinsurance growth6 new treaties; GWP $9.4M H1 16 treaties; ~$45M in force; growth to continue in 2025–2026 Scaling niche reinsurance
Capital allocationDiscretionary capital ~$125–$200M deployable; considering tender/special dividend Discretionary capital $255M; prioritizing product expansion over buybacks/special dividend Growth > buybacks

Management Commentary

  • “It gives me great pleasure to report that the GBLI team achieved solid insurance results… Penn America… finished up 12% through 2024… InsurTech grew 17%… assumed reinsurance… finished up 83%” .
  • “Full year 94.4% underwriting result for the Penn America segment… cat losses… down roughly 26% from 2023” .
  • “We have just completed the first full year of a multi‑year effort to transform our technology… transition to the cloud about 75% completed… new transactional application went live in September” .
  • “Net income was $43.2M… current book yield… 4.4% with duration of 0.8 years… we expect… duration to about 1.25 years by the end of the first quarter of 2025” .
  • “Discretionary capital… increased to $255M at 12/31/2024… this will support the efforts to invest in the growth of Penn America Underwriters” .

Q&A Highlights

  • California wildfires: ~$15M loss affecting <10 properties; total CA exposure ~6 bps of property market; entirely direct book (not reinsurance) .
  • Reinsurance platform: 16 treaties, ~$45M in force; growth expected through 2025–2026 .
  • Project Manifest destacking: boosted statutory surplus by ~$50M; consolidated surplus ~$500M, enhancing capacity .
  • Capital return: Board prioritizing product expansion over buybacks; no special dividend currently planned .
  • Expense ratio: internal fixed costs ~12–13 pts of the 38% total; path to ~37% via growth and efficiency; corporate expenses up ~$5M from implementation fees .

Estimates Context

  • Wall Street consensus (S&P Global) for Q4 2024 EPS and revenue was unavailable due to a data access limit at the time of request; therefore, comparisons to estimates cannot be provided.

Key Takeaways for Investors

  • Underwriting quality improving: consolidated combined ratio down to 95.6% and Penn‑America’s accident-year at 94.4%; sequential Q3 trends were stronger than Q2, signaling momentum .
  • Investment tailwind: reinvestments at ~5.2% with duration extending toward ~1.25 years in Q1 2025 should support net investment income and ROE, all else equal .
  • Growth engines intact: InsurTech, Assumed Reinsurance, and Wholesale Commercial underlying premiums show double-digit trends; management is adding products and teams post‑Project Manifest .
  • Risk management recalibration: wildfire loss underscores model tail risk; expect rate push (esp. CA vacant property) and potential underwriting mix shifts; monitor regulatory outcomes and exposure limits .
  • Capital deployment: with $255M discretionary capital and rising surplus, near‑term emphasis is organic/inorganic product expansion over buybacks; dividend maintained at $0.35/qtr .
  • Expense pathway: expect gradual improvement toward ~37% expense ratio as scale returns and technology investments normalize; watch for timing/pace against double‑digit premium growth .
  • Trading implications: near‑term stock narrative hinges on underwriting stability post‑wildfire, reinvestment yields/duration extension, and visible progress in product expansion; estimate beats/misses were unavailable, so price moves may hinge more on these operational signals than consensus deltas.