Q3 2024 Earnings Summary
- The company's digital transactions have grown over 60% year-over-year, significantly outpacing the market growth rate of 30% for digital remittances to Mexico, indicating strong traction in digital channels and positioning the company well for future growth. ,
- Gross margin per digital transaction has increased from $1.50 to over $6, surpassing the profitability of retail transactions and demonstrating significant improvement in unit economics, which makes the digital business more profitable and attractive. ,
- The company is currently undervalued given its strong cash flow and earnings per share growth, and is considering strategic alternatives, including a potential sale in a private transaction, which could unlock significant shareholder value.
- Slowing growth in the core retail market, particularly in transfers to Mexico, may impact Intermex's ability to maintain retail transaction growth. Bob Lisy noted that "the Mexico business is about 12% slower growth than it had 2 years ago" and that "the market that just 2 years ago was growing in double digits, about 12% is now growing somewhere around flat to 2%". This slowdown presents challenges in a key market.
- Increased competition and pricing pressures in retail during a down market could compress margins and reduce competitive advantage. Lisy mentioned that "the difference between us and the rest of the market has... is smaller today than it was" and that competitors "are more aggressive in a down market". This suggests heightened competition may impact profitability.
- Uncertainty regarding future earnings due to withdrawal of guidance and planned investments in digital initiatives may affect profitability. When asked about guidance, Lisy responded, "Well, that would be guidance, which we're not giving" and indicated that investments would begin immediately, affecting the bottom line: "So it's not going to be something we're going to do right now and giving guidance". The strategic review process adds further uncertainty.
| Metric | YoY Change | Reason |
|---|---|---|
Total Revenue | –0.3% (from $172.4M to $171.9M) | Total Revenue remained virtually unchanged in Q3 2024, which follows previous periods where robust revenue growth from increased transaction volumes and acquisitions (Q2 2023) was later moderated by competitive pricing and market stabilization, keeping revenues flat despite ongoing network integration challenges. |
Operating Income (EBIT) | +14.5% (from $24.3M to $27.8M) | A 14.5% increase in operating income is attributable to improved operational efficiencies and cost control measures that offset earlier higher integration and acquisition costs, reflecting a successful consolidation of initiatives from prior periods where revenue gains were partly diluted by increased expenses. |
Net Income | +16.7% (from $14.8M to $17.3M) | The 16.7% increase in net income reflects a recovery from prior cost pressures and interest expense challenges; enhanced profitability in operating segments, along with strategic restructuring, allowed the company to convert higher operating income into improved bottom-line performance compared to previous quarters. |
Basic EPS | +26% (from $0.42 to $0.53) | Despite nearly flat revenue, Basic EPS improved by 26% due to impactful share repurchases reducing the weighted-average shares outstanding and better earnings conversion from improved profitability, continuing an established trend from earlier periods where EPS was bolstered by similar capital management initiatives. |
Net Change in Cash | Swing from +$75.1M to –$76.6M | The net change in cash experienced a dramatic reversal from a positive $75.1M in Q3 2023 to a negative $76.6M in Q3 2024 primarily because of increased investing activities (capitalizing on leasehold improvements and equipment for the new headquarters) and aggressive financing outflows (notably, enhanced share repurchases and stock-based awards), which contrasts with previous periods of strong cash generation. |
| Metric | Period | Previous Guidance | Current Guidance | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Revenue | Q3 2024 | $170.6M to $175.8M | No formal guidance | no formal guidance |
Fully Diluted GAAP EPS | Q3 2024 | $0.49 to $0.54 per share | No formal guidance | no formal guidance |
Adjusted Diluted EPS | Q3 2024 | $0.57 to $0.62 per share | No formal guidance | no formal guidance |
Adjusted EBITDA | Q3 2024 | $32.1M to $33.1M | No formal guidance | no formal guidance |
Revenue | FY 2024 | $657.6M to $677.6M | No formal guidance | no formal guidance |
Fully Diluted GAAP EPS | FY 2024 | $1.73 to $1.87 per share | No formal guidance | no formal guidance |
Adjusted Diluted EPS | FY 2024 | $2.07 to $2.25 per share | No formal guidance | no formal guidance |
Adjusted EBITDA | FY 2024 | $121.1M to $124.7M | No formal guidance | no formal guidance |
| Topic | Previous Mentions | Current Period | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
Digital Growth and Transformation | Q1 highlighted 60% YoY growth, strategic partnerships, enhanced digital margins ( , , ); Q2 emphasized nearly 70% growth with improved gross profit margins, omnichannel integration ( , ); Q4 noted 42% growth with best digital margins and progressive digital investments ( , ) | Q3 reported over 66% YoY growth, digital gross profit per transaction now surpassing retail, with a continued focus on investing in digital channels and leveraging its omnichannel strategy ( , , ) | **Consistent bullish sentiment with enhanced profitability and scalability, reinforcing a strong long‐term digital transformation narrative. , , ** |
Retail Market Performance and Challenges in Mexico | Q1 described volatile growth influenced by currency dynamics and slower-than-expected market expansion ( , , ); Q2 noted macro-driven retail softness and a contraction of 3-4% ( , ); Q4 reported modest 3.5% growth with efforts to gain market share and manage costs ( , ) | Q3 continued to face retail market challenges with flat to slightly negative growth, yet noted profitability and market share gains in the face of a growing digital segment ( , , ) | **Ongoing retail struggles amid macro headwinds, with a persistent focus on maintaining profitability while digital growth increasingly offsets retail declines. , ** |
Sales Force Expansion and Staffing Initiatives | Q1 saw aggressive expansion (tripling inside sales; adding outside roles) to capture more opportunities ( , , ); Q2 reorganized and expanded its retail sales force with geographic focus ( , ); Q4 emphasized significant expansion with cost‐efficient offshore hiring ( , ) | Q3 stated that the sales team is now fully staffed with no need for further expansion, noting a shift to greater efficiency and lower staffing costs through offshore task shifting ( , ) | **A strategic transition from rapid expansion to optimizing existing resources, focusing on cost efficiency and streamlined operations. ** |
International Expansion Opportunities and Global Partnerships | Q1 stressed European market entry and partnerships like Felix Pago and Visa ( , , ); Q2 highlighted European acquisitions and digital growth in Europe via strategic partnerships ( , ); Q4 discussed initiatives such as Visa Direct for expansion into India, the Philippines, Italy, and more ( , , ) | Q3 maintained the focus on European licenses and global reach—expanding capabilities to over 90 destinations—with robust digital partnerships supporting significant growth ( , , ) | **Stable international expansion with a consistent and positive outlook on global partnerships, reinforcing a strong omnichannel strategy. , ** |
Capital Allocation and Strategic Alternatives | Q1 emphasized strong cash generation and disciplined buybacks supporting growth ( ); Q2 balanced share buybacks with M&A opportunities and capital discipline ( ); Q4 detailed buyback programs and selective M&A approaches to leverage liquidity ( , , ) | Q3 continued to generate strong cash and execute buybacks but introduced a formal strategic review process to explore long-term strategic alternatives ( , , ) | **Emerging focus on strategic alternatives, signaling an increased pivot toward long-term repositioning while maintaining disciplined capital allocation. , ** |
Competitive Landscape and Pricing Pressures | Q1 noted efficient, granular pricing strategies and awareness of digital margin dynamics ( , ); Q2 addressed tactical pricing adjustments and operational efficiencies amid pressure from smaller competitors ( , , ); Q4 focused on selective pricing to extend margins in key areas despite competitive challenges ( , , ) | Q3 reaffirmed similar competitive pressures with continued tactical pricing adjustments and market share gains despite a competitive retail environment ( , ) | **A steady, pragmatic approach with stable sentiment; the company continues to leverage operational efficiencies to manage pricing pressures. , ** |
Guidance Withdrawal and Earnings Uncertainty | Q1, Q2, and Q4 consistently provided detailed forward guidance with clear earnings projections ( , , , ) | Q3 withdrew guidance due to the initiation of a strategic review and immediate digital investment plans, introducing near-term earnings uncertainty ( ) | **A new development indicative of increased short-term uncertainty and a shift toward long-term strategic repositioning. ** |
Partnership Dependence for Digital Growth | Q1 emphasized partnerships such as Felix Pago to expand the “wires as a service” offering ( ); Q2 reinforced the role of strategic alliances in reducing CAC and boosting digital engagement ( , ); Q4 introduced the Visa Direct partnership for digital expansion ( ) | Q3 continued to underscore partnerships—especially the wires-as-a-service model—highlighting how collaborations reduce CAC and drive digital revenue growth ( , ) | **A consistent reliance on strategic partnerships, reinforcing the digital business model and delivering a sustained competitive advantage. , ** |
Investment in Digital Marketing and Customer Acquisition | Q1 focused on strategic investments in digital marketing to lower CAC and support omnichannel initiatives ( , , ); Q2 shifted emphasis to product management and enhanced marketing efforts to further reduce CAC by about 50% ( ); Q4 stressed highly efficient digital marketing spend achieving 43% growth in digital transactions ( ) | Q3 maintained strong investments in digital marketing with continued efforts to fine-tune CAC (estimated at $40-60) and boost profitability via efficient customer acquisition strategies ( , , ) | **A sustained and positive commitment to digital marketing investments, with an evolving focus on efficiency and scalable customer acquisition driving long-term growth. , ** |
-
Guidance Removal and Strategic Review
Q: Why did you remove guidance during the strategic review?
A: The company decided not to provide guidance due to entering a strategic process. They are focusing on investing in digital initiatives and believe that not giving guidance is appropriate during this period. -
Digital vs Retail Economics
Q: How do digital transfer economics compare to retail?
A: Digital transfers have a gross revenue per transaction around $11, with a gross margin of $6 to $6.50 per transaction. Unlike retail, digital transactions avoid agent fees and offer better unit economics. -
Investment in Digital Growth
Q: What are your near-term investment plans in digital?
A: The company plans to invest in customer acquisition to grow their digital business, leveraging their improved app and efficient unit economics. They are prepared to make necessary investments considering current customer acquisition costs and expect exponential growth opportunities ahead. -
Challenges in Retail Market
Q: How are you addressing challenges in retail?
A: Despite the retail market being flat, the company continues to outperform competitors. They are increasing sales staff, focusing on strategic pricing, and targeting areas with opportunities to gain market share, despite the overall market challenges. -
Impact of Potential Trump Administration
Q: How might a Trump administration affect your business?
A: Historically, during the last Trump administration, the company experienced strong business performance. Economic factors like a strong economy and favorable exchange rates led to growth. They anticipate similar positive impacts if such conditions arise again. -
Mexican Market and Currency Trends
Q: What trends are you seeing in Mexico and currency?
A: A weaker peso benefits the business by encouraging remittances. Recent shifts suggest potential growth if the peso continues to weaken, and lower interest rates could boost housing starts, which impacts remittance flows. -
Change in Loyalty Program
Q: Is changing loyalty terms affecting retention?
A: After analysis, the company restructured the loyalty program, finding it wasn't optimally effective. They do not expect any negative impact on customer retention from these changes.
Research analysts covering International Money Express.