PRG Q2 2025: EPS $1.02 beats guidance as GMV drops 8.9%
- Strong earnings performance: Q2 non‑GAAP EPS came in at $1.02 per share, outperforming the high‑end of guidance, which underscores resilient profitability despite challenging macro conditions.
- Impressive growth in the BNPL segment (four Technologies): Four Technologies delivered over 200% revenue growth with a trailing twelve‑month take rate of approximately 10% and transaction frequency of about 5 times per quarter, suggesting strong scalability and margin expansion potential.
- Effective portfolio management and proactive cost control: With Q2 write‑offs at 7.5%—20 basis points better than last year—and initiatives to recapture customers amid Big Lots headwinds, management demonstrated disciplined portfolio performance that supports sustainable growth.
- GMV Headwinds: The call highlighted a -8.9% YoY decline in Progressive Leasing GMV driven primarily by the Big Lots bankruptcy (a roughly $40M GMV headwind) and an additional 8-9% drag from tighter decisioning, suggesting that underlying growth may be undermined by external shocks and stricter underwriting.
- Margin Pressure from Credit and Portfolio Dynamics: Executives pointed to margin challenges, noting that the need for significant upfront CECL credit reserves—especially visible with the four business—and a decreasing portfolio size could result in compressed margins, with indications that Q4 might swing to an adjusted EBITDA loss due to these factors.
- Soft Consumer Demand in Core Leasing Categories: Persistent weakness in key discretionary sectors (such as furniture, mattress, and large appliances) and an overall soft demand environment were repeatedly mentioned as concerns, signaling that recovery in these high-ticket areas might be slower than investors hope.
| Metric | YoY Change | Reason |
|---|---|---|
Total Revenue | +2.1% (from $592.16 million to $604.7 million) | Overall revenue growth is driven by modest gains from high-growth segments; specifically, a 5% increase in Vive and a dramatic over 200% surge in Other (including Four) more than offset the nearly flat performance in Progressive Leasing, reflecting effective leveraging of high-growth initiatives compared to the previous period. |
Progressive Leasing | -0.15% (from $570.52 million to $569.7 million) | The nearly flat performance indicates offsetting factors—while previous periods saw notable variations due to portfolio adjustments and shifting early purchase dynamics, Q2 2025 reflects stabilization in the lease portfolio as growth initiatives and normalization effects balance each other out. |
Vive | +5% (from $15.42 million to $16.2 million) | Vive’s revenue increase is attributed to improved loan origination programs and stronger customer demand from national retail merchants, echoing earlier improvements that helped boost performance despite entering the quarter with a smaller loan portfolio. |
Other (including Four) | Over +200% (from $6.22 million to $18.8 million) | The dramatic surge in Other revenues is primarily driven by Four Technologies’ outstanding performance, marked by triple-digit revenue growth, a significant expansion in active customer numbers, and the achievement of positive adjusted EBITDA—continuing a turnaround that began in previous periods. |
| Metric | Period | Previous Guidance | Current Guidance | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Revenue | FY 2025 | $2,425,000,000 to $2,500,000,000 | $2,450,000,000 to $2,500,000,000 | raised |
Adjusted EBITDA | FY 2025 | $245,000,000 to $265,000,000 | $255,000,000 to $265,000,000 | raised |
Non-GAAP EPS | FY 2025 | $2.90 to $3.30 | $3.20 to $3.35 | raised |
Effective Tax Rate for Non-GAAP EPS | FY 2025 | Approximately 28% | Approximately 27% | lowered |
Portfolio Write-Off Range | FY 2025 | 6% to 8% | 6% to 8% | no change |
No Impact from Additional Share Repurchases | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Assumes no changes due to share repurchases | no prior guidance |
| Topic | Previous Mentions | Current Period | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
Big Lots | Previously discussed as a significant headwind with bankruptcy-induced GMV losses (e.g., $30 million headwind in Q1 and detailed impacts with potential loss of high-margin customers in Q4 , with earlier mention of store closures in Q3 ) | Currently, Big Lots remains a major concern with a reported $40 million GMV headwind, accompanied by active retention efforts and a forecast for its effects to be largely lapped by Q4 2025 | Continued negative impact with persistent concerns, although retention and customer redirection initiatives are in play, sentiment remains cautious |
Retail Partner Dynamics | Previously noted for customer redirection and strong renewal contracts (with Q1 efforts to transfer Big Lots’ customers and Q4 renewals and multi‐year exclusives , plus Q3 emphasis on exclusive partnerships ) | Currently highlights robust GMV growth with partners, new partnerships (e.g., with ASI), active pipeline development, and initiatives addressing category challenges | Evolving strategy with expanded initiatives and new partner engagement, showing an improving sentiment despite an ongoing competitive backdrop |
Credit Portfolio Management and Credit Quality | Earlier periods described proactive decisioning adjustments, tightening measures, and stable write-offs (e.g., Q1 write-offs at 7.4% , Q4 dynamic decisioning adjustments , and Q3 use of machine learning models for real-time portfolio management ) | In Q2 2025, portfolio performance remains consistent with 7.5% write-offs, continued proactive decisioning, and focused portfolio adjustments | Consistent management across periods with slight improvements in decisioning processes; sentiment remains stable and cautious |
GMV Performance Trends and Headwinds | Previously, Q1 reported a 4% decline due to headwinds including Big Lots and tighter approvals ; Q4 showed strong overall GMV growth but warned of significant Big Lots gaps ; and Q3 reported an 11.6% increase tempered by headwinds from Big Lots closures | Q2 2025 shows an 8.9% decline YoY primarily due to Big Lots and deliberate approval rate tightening, though underlying GMV (excluding Big Lots) is in the high single digits | Volatility persists with headwinds continuing to impact reported GMV while core growth potential remains; overall sentiment is mixed and cautious |
Expansion in Growth Segments (BNPL/Four Technologies and Digital Platforms) | Previously, Q1 highlighted strong triple-digit growth in BNPL with six consecutive quarters of robust performance , and Q4 noted Four Technologies’ tripled GMV ; Q3 had little on this segment | Q2 2025 emphasizes continued strong BNPL growth with 167% GMV YoY, profitability, a record 21% e-commerce contribution, and marked digital platform enhancements | Accelerated and positive growth in new segments drives a strong, optimistic sentiment about future scalability and digital expansion |
Margin and Profitability Pressures | Prior periods noted margin declines with drops of over 100 basis points (Q1: 112bps decline , Q3: 110bps lower gross margin , and Q4 discussing impacts from Big Lots loss and higher delinquencies ) | In Q2 2025, margins are pressured further by Big Lots’ loss, increased 90-day purchase activity, and higher SG&A (gross margin at 32.4% down 15bps), with overall profitability challenges noted | Persistent pressures on margins across periods create caution; despite cost discipline efforts, profitability challenges remain a consistent headwind |
Strategic Investments in Technology and Operational Efficiencies | Previously, Q1 and Q4 described investments in digital enhancements and technology to improve customer experience , while Q3 highlighted AI-driven solutions and operational improvements | Q2 2025 reaffirms heavy investment in AI-driven tools, enhanced chat features for consumer support, and technology initiatives aimed at operational efficiencies | Continued and even increased commitment to tech investments signals a long-term positive outlook, reinforcing efficiency and growth despite short-term cost pressures |
Consumer Demand and Macroeconomic Uncertainty | Earlier periods painted a picture of soft consumer demand and macroeconomic headwinds (Q1 noted declining discretionary spending and revised guidance ; Q4 mentioned weak demand in furniture and ongoing financial pressures ; Q3 observed a reliance on trade-down dynamics amid uncertain demand ) | Q2 2025 continues to face soft consumer demand across key categories and heightened macroeconomic uncertainty, resulting in a cautious outlook for the balance of the year | Persistent weakness in demand and ongoing macro uncertainty keep sentiment cautious, with consistent concerns about consumer spending habits affecting future performance |
-
Guidance & Margins
Q: What Q2 results won’t repeat next period?
A: Management explained that Q2 benefited from lower-than-expected write offs and favorable legacy effects from Big Lots, but these drivers will fade as portfolio size shrinks and upfront CECL provisions for BNPL weigh on margins, indicating tougher results later. -
Underlying Growth
Q: What is core GMV growth rate ex-headwinds?
A: Excluding Big Lots and tightening impacts, management indicated that core GMV was roughly +1% pro forma, with an underlying trajectory near 10% growth when those discrete headwinds are lapped—Big Lots by Q4 2025 and decisioning measures easing into Q1 2026. -
Economic Outlook
Q: Any signs of increased discretionary spending?
A: Management noted that despite some modest green shoots in consumer activity, the replacement cycle in key categories remains soft, while disciplined capital allocation—with ongoing repurchases and lower immediate cash tax outlays—keeps the balance sheet robust. -
Four Growth
Q: How will BNPL (four) scale profitability?
A: Management is very excited about four’s progress, citing over 100% YoY growth, a trailing take rate of approximately 10%, and around five transactions per quarter, all of which point toward meaningful margin expansion as credit reserve effects normalize. -
Decisioning Adjustments
Q: When will underwriting tightening unwind?
A: Management clarified that any easing of the tightened decisioning will be gradual, driven by improved consumer data; they do not plan to revert fully to 2024 levels, with incremental adjustments expected as early indicators improve over the back half of 2025. -
ASI Partnership
Q: Is ASI ramping as expected?
A: Management confirmed that the partnership with ASI is progressing on target, with performance metrics and balance of sales coming in as expected, while also leveraging marketing efforts to help retain Big Lots customers within the ecosystem. -
Channel Initiatives
Q: How will channels grow smaller, medium business?
A: Management emphasized that growth is being driven more by targeted initiatives at the partner and regional levels rather than by category-wide recoveries, focusing on joint efforts with retail partners to optimize performance even in softer demand segments.