Sign in

You're signed outSign in or to get full access.

RT

Rubicon Technology, Inc. (RBCN)·Q3 2016 Earnings Summary

Executive Summary

  • Q3 revenue rebounded to $7.09M, driven by a one-off surge in wafer sales as a key customer increased orders and drew down consignment inventory; however, the quarter included large non-cash charges tied to exiting LED/mobile and closing the Malaysia plant, resulting in a GAAP EPS loss of $0.94 .
  • Strategic pivot: management is exiting LED/mobile substrates and focusing on optical/industrial sapphire, shuttering the Penang, Malaysia facility by year-end and consolidating U.S. operations, with headcount targeted at roughly 40 to lower fixed costs .
  • One-time charges materially impacted results: $10.2M asset impairment (Malaysia), $4.0M raw material write-down, $0.9M severance; plus $2.3M write-down of excess 2-inch core inventory and $0.18M U.S. severance .
  • Near-term outlook turns down for wafers: management explicitly guides wafer revenue to “significantly decrease” starting Q4 as Malaysia production ceases; revenue “will be smaller for a period of time,” though cash flow is expected to improve meaningfully post-restructuring .

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

  • What Went Well

    • Temporary revenue surge: Q3 sales rose to $7.09M (+$3.55M q/q) as a key patterned wafer customer boosted purchases and drew down consignment inventory .
    • Strategic refocus: decisive exit from LED/mobile markets to concentrate on optical/industrial segments where Rubicon sees superior margin potential and competitive differentiation .
    • Technology milestones: completed crystal growth development for LANCE, enabling the world’s largest sapphire windows (36 x 18 x 1 inches) and began commercializing; SapphirEX coatings advanced in customer qualifications across POS scanners and other niches .

  • What Went Wrong

    • Heavy non-cash charges: $10.2M impairment (Malaysia), $4.0M raw material write-down, $0.9M severance; additional $2.3M 2-inch core inventory write-down and $0.18M U.S. severance drove a larger loss .
    • Gross losses widened on restructuring: Q3 gross loss was $(11.65)M vs $(4.05)M in Q2 and $(3.89)M in Q3’15 as the exit actions flowed through COGS and impairments .
    • Structural step-down ahead: wafer revenue expected to “significantly decrease” from Q4 onward due to Malaysia shutdown; management cautioned revenue “will be smaller for a period of time” .

Financial Results

  • P&L summary vs prior year and prior quarters
MetricQ3 2015Q1 2016Q2 2016Q3 2016
Revenue ($M)$5.35 $4.29 $3.54 $7.09
Gross (Loss) ($M)$(3.89) $(5.42) $(4.05) $(11.65)
Loss from Operations (EBIT) ($M)$(47.37) $(8.16) $(8.15) $(24.77)
Net Loss ($M)$(48.20) $(7.33) $(8.21) $(24.80)
GAAP EPS (Basic)$(1.84) $(0.28) $(0.31) $(0.94)
  • Revenue by product group
Product Group ($000s)Q3 2015Q2 2016Q3 2016
Core – 2”$551 $0 $3
Core – 4”$1,233 $689 $421
Core – 6”$40 $0 $0
Total Core$1,824 $689 $424
Wafers – Polished$763 $488 $994
Wafers – PSS$1,373 $1,342 $4,513
Total Wafers$2,136 $1,830 $5,507
R&D$270 $112 $80
Optical & Other$1,116 $904 $1,075
Total Revenue$5,346 $3,535 $7,086
  • Balance sheet KPIs
KPI ($000s)Q3 2015Q2 2016Q3 2016
Cash & Equivalents$21,428 $17,067 $16,370
Inventories$23,112 $21,210 $10,644
Total Current Assets$68,382 $49,684 $35,977
Total Assets$128,953 $103,579 $77,720
Stockholders’ Equity$124,388 $97,182 $72,730

Notes:

  • Q3 revenue spike was primarily one customer-related (patterned wafer) and inventory drawdown; not indicative of run-rate as wafer revenue to decline post-closure .

Guidance Changes

MetricPeriodPrevious GuidanceCurrent GuidanceChange
Wafer revenueQ4 2016 onwardN/A“Will significantly decrease” as Malaysia ceases production Lowered
Total revenueNear-termN/A“Revenue will be smaller for a period of time” as the model pivots to optical/industrial Lowered
Cash flowPost-restructuringN/A“Meaningful improvement in cash flow” expected once changes fully implemented Improved
Headcount2017 entryN/A“Reduced to roughly forty employees” to lower fixed costs Reduced
Crystal growth opsNear-termN/A“Very limited in the near-term” as existing crystal inventory supports orders Reduced
Asset salesNear-termN/ASelling Penang assets; considering Batavia plant sale; seeking buyers for furnaces Monetization plan

Earnings Call Themes & Trends

Note: No Q3’16 earnings call transcript was located in our sources; the company furnished a Stockholder Letter on Nov 9, 2016 instead . We verified RBCN transcript listings; Q3’16 is not available on common repositories .

TopicPrevious Mentions (Q-2 and Q-1)Current Period (Q3 2016)Trend
Business focusEmphasis shifting toward optical/industrial; building pipeline; limited core sales due to weak pricing .Exiting LED/mobile; closing Malaysia; focusing on optical/industrial sapphire Acceleration of pivot
LANCE large windowsGovernment-funded development; delivered largest required window; nearing completion of growth deliverables .Growth development completed; 36x18x1 inch windows; permitted to commercialize; working on yields and market development Transition to commercialization
SapphirEX coatingsTool delivery and pilot production planned; progressing in qualifications (POS, defense, electronics) .Continued qualification; targeting niche markets (POS) with longer-term potential in phones/tablets; outsourcing production to avoid capex Advancing trials; asset-light approach
LED substrate economicsExcess capacity; low pricing; targeting 6” PSS but cost reductions needed; volumes expected to rise in 2H’16 .Strategically exiting LED/mobile; PSS spike in Q3 partly from consignment drawdown; steep decline expected from Q4 Exit/decline
Cost structurePursuing wafer and SG&A cost cuts; capex constrained .Headcount to ~40; consolidate IL sites; selling assets to strengthen cash Structurally lower opex
Customer concentration & consignmentQ3 expected step-up in PSS from a key customer .Q3 uplift driven by key customer purchases and consignment inventory drawdown One-off tailwind fading

Management Commentary

  • “While margin pressure in the LED and mobile device segments of the sapphire market continue to be severe, there remains good margin opportunity in the optical and industrial segments.” — CEO Bill Weissman .
  • “Once the changes are fully implemented, our revenue will be smaller for a period of time… however, we anticipate a meaningful improvement in cash flow.” — Stockholder Letter .
  • “We have now completed crystal growth development for our LANCE technology… including the largest size sapphire window available in the world at 36 x 18 x 1 inch.” — Stockholder Letter .
  • “We… decided to close the plant in Malaysia and sell the real estate and equipment located there… [and] are considering the sale of the Batavia plant once the relocation is complete.” — Stockholder Letter .

Q&A Highlights

  • No Q3’16 earnings call transcript was available; the company furnished a Stockholder Letter instead .
  • Relevant prior Q&A (Q1’16) for context:
    • PSS capacity and linearity: management expected a step-up in 2H and to be “maxed out on our patterning capacity” absent new investment .
    • Cost reductions: most opportunities seen in polishing (Malaysia), with ongoing SG&A and yield initiatives across operations .
    • Core sales cadence: expected to keep similar volumes to retain key crystal growth talent while new markets develop .

Estimates Context

  • We attempted to retrieve S&P Global consensus for Q3’16 EPS and revenue, but the data was unavailable due to system limits at time of request; as such, we cannot assess beats/misses to Street estimates for this quarter [S&P Global data unavailable]. Where estimates are unavailable, we anchor our analysis on company-reported results and disclosures .
  • Given the one-time, customer-driven PSS uplift and explicit guidance for wafer revenue to decline from Q4, consensus estimates (where they exist) may need to move down for near-term revenue while potentially improving cash burn trajectories post-restructuring .

Key Takeaways for Investors

  • The quarter’s revenue strength was transitory, fueled by a key customer’s orders and consignment drawdown; management cautions wafer revenue will fall significantly from Q4 as Malaysia shuts down .
  • The strategic exit from LED/mobile and consolidation of operations should materially lower fixed costs (headcount to ~40) and improve cash flow after near-term revenue declines .
  • Technology catalysts—LANCE mega-windows now commercializable and SapphirEX coating progress—support the pivot to higher-margin optical/industrial niches, but commercialization ramps, customer qualifications, and market development will take time .
  • Balance sheet contraction continues (cash $16.37M; inventories down to $10.64M), with planned asset sales (Penang, potential Batavia) to bolster liquidity and strategic flexibility .
  • Expect elevated near-term earnings volatility due to restructuring charges and mix shift; monitor progress on asset monetization, optical order flow, and outsourcing execution to validate the cash-flow improvement thesis .
  • Stock narrative should trade on execution of the pivot and cash preservation: confirmation of optical/industrial bookings, LANCE wins, and SapphirEX customer adoptions are key catalysts, while any delays in asset sales or demand could weigh on sentiment .

Appendix: Source Documents Reviewed

  • Q3 2016 8-K and Exhibits (Press Release and Stockholder Letter) filed Nov 9, 2016 .
  • Q2 2016 8-K Press Release filed Aug 9, 2016 .
  • Q1 2016 8-K Press Release filed May 10, 2016 .
  • Q1 2016 Earnings Call Transcript (for historical context) .
  • Transcript availability check: No Q3’16 RBCN call transcript located; confirmation via 8-K furnishing a Stockholder Letter and external listings .