Sign in

You're signed outSign in or to get full access.

CS

Container Store Group, Inc. (TCS)·Q4 2024 Earnings Summary

Executive Summary

  • Q4 results: revenue $206.0M, down 20.7% YoY; gross margin rose 50 bps to 59.4%; adjusted EPS loss narrowed to $0.04 from $0.18 profit last year; GAAP EPS loss of $1.24 driven by $73.8M non-cash trade name impairments .
  • Mix held up as Custom Spaces outperformed general merchandise; TCS segment gross margin +60 bps on lower freight, partly offset by promos and mix; Elfa third-party sales fell 24.6% with 980 bps gross margin pressure from mix .
  • Liquidity improved: cash $21.0M, liquidity $112.3M; FY23 free cash flow +$6.9M; Q4 leverage ~3.2x (net debt/EBITDA, company’s definition) .
  • Guidance withdrawn amid board-led strategic alternatives review; NYSE price non-compliance notice received; management to consider a reverse stock split (subject to shareholder approval) .

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

  • What Went Well

    • Gross margin expanded despite sales pressure: consolidated +50 bps to 59.4% (TCS +60 bps on lower freight) .
    • Custom Spaces showed relative strength; premium lines delivered “slightly positive comp” in Q4 per management .
    • Cost discipline: SG&A down 13.9% YoY to $107.0M; FY23 free cash flow turned positive at $6.9M .

  • What Went Wrong

    • Top-line headwinds intensified: comps -21.8% as general merchandise comps fell 26.7% (–1,620 bps impact); online sales -30.8% .
    • Non-cash impairments ($63.8M TCS trade name, $10.1M Elfa) and legal/severance drove GAAP loss (EPS -$1.24) .
    • Elfa third-party sales -24.6% (–25.3% constant currency) due to Nordic weakness; Elfa gross margin -980 bps on mix .

Financial Results

MetricQ3 FY2023 (13 wks to Dec 30, 2023)Q4 FY2023 (13 wks to Mar 30, 2024)
Consolidated Net Sales ($M)$214.9 $206.0
YoY Change-14.8% -20.7%
GAAP EPS-$0.13 -$1.24
Adjusted EPS-$0.08 -$0.04
Gross Margin (%)58.3% 59.4%
SG&A ($M)$111.8 $107.0
SG&A (% of Sales)52.0% 51.9%
Adjusted EBITDA ($M)$12.8 $15.4
TCS Retail Net Sales ($M)$202.5 $195.3
Elfa Third-Party Net Sales ($M)$12.4 $10.7

Segment & KPIs

KPIQ3 FY2023Q4 FY2023
Comparable Store Sales-16.8% -21.8%
General Merchandise Comps-20.4% -26.7%
Custom Spaces Comps-9.2% -14.2%
Online Sales YoY-26.3% -30.8%
TCS Gross Margin (%)57.6% 58.1%
Elfa Gross Margin YoY Δ-170 bps -980 bps
Website-Generated Sales Share of TCS21.8% 22.8%
Unearned Revenue ($M)$17.5 $14.4

Balance Sheet & Liquidity

MetricQ3 FY2023Q4 FY2023
Cash ($M)$16.0 $21.0
Total Debt, net ($M)$184.7 $176.8
Liquidity ($M)$99.6 $112.3
FY Free Cash Flow ($M)—$6.9
Current Leverage Ratio2.8x ~3.2x

Why vs prior quarter/year and vs expectations:

  • YoY: Sales declines driven by severe general merchandise pressure and lower online demand; Custom Spaces outperformed but still negative comps; Nordic weakness hit Elfa .
  • QoQ: Revenue dipped sequentially (seasonality plus Elfa non-promotional periods) while margin mix and freight tailwinds supported gross margin expansion; SG&A dollars fell on cost actions .
  • Versus company outlook: Q4 net sales of $206.0M slightly exceeded the $200–$205M outlook; adjusted EPS (-$0.04) was better than the guided (-$0.12)–(-$0.09), aided by cost discipline and mix .

Guidance Changes

  • Context: On May 14, 2024, the Board initiated a strategic alternatives review and suspended financial guidance .

Q4 FY2023 Outlook vs Actuals

MetricPeriodPrevious Guidance (2/6/24)ActualChange
Consolidated Net SalesQ4 FY2023$200–$205M $206.0M Above range
Adjusted EPSQ4 FY2023($0.12)–($0.09) ($0.04) Above range (less negative)
Effective Tax RateQ4 FY2023~21% 25.3% Higher
Comparable Store Sales DeclineQ4 FY2023Mid-20s -21.8% Better than mid-20s

Forward Commentary (FY2024)

MetricPeriodPrevious GuidanceCurrent CommentaryChange
Financial GuidanceFY2024N/ASuspended due to strategic review Withdrawn
Gross MarginFY2024N/AStable to modestly expanding on lower freight, disciplined promos, favorable mix New qualitative
SG&AFY2024N/A“Extremely disciplined” following FY23 actions New qualitative
CapexFY2024N/A~$20–$25M (4 new, 1 relocation, tech/manufacturing) New quantitative
Store OpeningsFY2024N/APlan to open 4 new small-format, relocate 1, close 1 New plan

Earnings Call Themes & Trends

TopicQ2 FY2023 (Q2 call)Q3 FY2023 (Q3 call)Q4 FY2023 (Q4 call)Trend
Custom Spaces vs General MerchandisePremium Custom Spaces strong; general merchandise weaker; early Elfa 75th promo pulled forward demand Sequential improvement in Custom Spaces comps; general merchandise still challenging Premium lines “slightly positive comp”; general merchandise remains pressured Custom Spaces resilient; Gen merch worsening
Marketing & Awareness“Uncontained” premium campaign; AI-generated site content tests Planning more integrated, data-driven messaging; awareness a focus “Make Space For” full-funnel in 5 markets; PR partnerships; in-store Elfa front fixtures Escalating brand/awareness push
Promotions & PricingDisciplined promos after Q1 learnings; earlier Elfa event Maintain promo discipline; weather headwinds in Jan contemplated in Q4 guide Continue discipline; pass vendor savings on select GM; expand private label to hit price points More surgical, value messaging
Freight/Supply ChainFreight tailwind supports margins Freight tailwind continues Tailwind expected to persist into 1H FY24; minimal Suez exposure; 85% contracted Tailwind moderating but intact
Elfa/NordicsElfa 3P sales -12.5%; Nordic macro weak Elfa 3P -4.2%; continued Nordic weakness Elfa 3P -24.6%; mix pressured margins; constant currency -25.3% Deteriorating
Cost StructureSG&A actions; FCF neutral to positive aim SG&A savings $30M through Q3; targeting up to $45M FY SG&A down 13.9% in Q4; remain disciplined in FY24 Ongoing discipline
Corporate Actions—Lease extension on DC (through 2035) NYSE price non-compliance notice; consider reverse split; strategic alternatives review; guidance suspended Heightened corporate activity

Management Commentary

  • “We ended fiscal 2023 with continued pressure on our general merchandise assortment while experiencing relative strength in our premium Custom Space offering.” – CEO Satish Malhotra .
  • “We are suspending financial guidance” as the Board “initiated a formal review process to evaluate strategic alternatives.” – CEO/Board statement .
  • “Our fourth quarter results saw relative strength within Custom Spaces while general merchandise continued to weigh on performance… consolidated gross margin for Q4 increased 50 basis points to 59.4%.” – CFO Jeff Miller .
  • “First quarter fiscal 2024 to date, we have seen an improvement in year over year sales trends when compared to the fourth quarter of fiscal 2023… general merchandise remains challenged.” – CFO Jeff Miller .

Q&A Highlights

  • Demand cadence and general merchandise: Trends improved quarter-to-date vs Q4, but general merchandise remains “pretty challenged”; premium Custom Spaces (Elfa/Preston) showing growth .
  • Promotions and pricing: Management remains disciplined; will pass vendor savings in select categories and expand private label to present competitive price points without sacrificing gross margin .
  • Elfa event timing: No notable change in cadence YoY; plan to run 4 Elfa events in FY24 .
  • Freight risk: Limited exposure to Suez/Red Sea; 85% of shipments under contract; spot rate impact monitored .
  • Cost opportunities: Additional efficiencies sought without impacting customer experience; FY23 saw two large SG&A actions; marketing reinvestment planned to build Custom Spaces awareness .

Estimates Context

  • S&P Global (Capital IQ) Wall Street consensus for Q4 FY2023 was unavailable via our data connection at this time; therefore, estimate comparisons are not included. We instead benchmarked actuals against the company’s Q4 outlook (sales $200–$205M; adjusted EPS -$0.12 to -$0.09), which TCS exceeded on both revenue and adjusted EPS .

Key Takeaways for Investors

  • Mix resilience: Custom Spaces continues to outperform and support gross margin; premium lines positive comps in Q4, a core lever as marketing scales in FY24 .
  • Top-line fragility: General merchandise and e-commerce remain under pressure; Elfa third-party sales and margins weakened on Nordic macro and mix .
  • Margin discipline: Freight tailwinds, mix, and promo discipline underpin margin stability; SG&A actions reduced expense base, aiding adjusted EPS vs guidance .
  • Liquidity intact: Higher cash and liquidity with positive FY free cash flow; leverage manageable but ticked up to ~3.2x per management .
  • Corporate catalysts: Strategic alternatives review and possible reverse split are near-term stock catalysts; guidance suspended limits visibility .
  • Execution focus: FY24 playbook emphasizes Custom Spaces awareness (“Make Space For”), designer capacity, integrated merchandising, and selective value messaging to stabilize general merchandise .
  • Trading setup: Near-term moves will likely hinge on headlines from the strategic review and early read-throughs from marketing pilots vs persistent general merchandise softness .