Q4 2024 Earnings Summary
- Travelers achieved record new business in their Personal Auto segment in Q4 2024, with new business up 6% compared to the prior year quarter, indicating successful growth strategies in Personal Auto.
- The company reports strong margins in their Business Insurance segment, with near double-digit renewal premium change (RPC), high retention, and a stable market outlook, suggesting continued profitability and growth opportunities in this segment.
- The underlying loss ratio in Business Insurance improved, driven by earned pricing, and the company maintained conservative reserving practices by adding IBNR to casualty lines, indicating strong underwriting discipline and financial strength.
- The underlying combined ratio in Business Insurance is as good as it's been in 20 years, suggesting that margins may have peaked and might not improve further. When asked about this, the CEO did not forecast future margin directions and stopped short of indicating further improvement.
- The company added more IBNR (Incurred But Not Reported) reserves to the casualty line, reflecting uncertainty in that line, which may indicate potential future losses.
- The California wildfires could have a significant impact on first quarter earnings, as the company expects the losses to be a "big number" and does not anticipate reinsurance recoveries at this point. This could lead to higher catastrophe losses in future quarters.
| Metric | YoY Change | Reason |
|---|---|---|
Total Revenue | +11% (from $10.892B to $12.063B) | Primarily driven by higher net earned premiums in Business & Bond segments and net realized investment gains, reflecting favorable market conditions and company initiatives focused on profitable growth and retention. |
Business Insurance | +11% (from $5.767B to $6.414B) | Growth stemmed from strong renewal premium changes, high retention rates, and new business across key lines; disciplined underwriting and improved risk selection further contributed to higher premium volume. |
Bond & Specialty | +9% (from $1.032B to $1.129B) | Revenue expansion was driven by robust performance in management liability and surety, supported by higher net investment income; partially offset by slower international markets, reflecting both external conditions and selective underwriting. |
Net Income | +28% (from $1.626B to $2.082B) | Primarily due to improved underlying underwriting margins, net favorable prior year reserve development, and increased net investment income; these gains reflect ongoing underwriting discipline and positive market trends. |
Diluted EPS | +29% (from $6.96 to $8.96) | Driven by higher net income and the impact of share repurchases (reducing shares outstanding), while net realized investment gains replaced prior year losses, boosting overall earnings per share. |
| Metric | Period | Previous Guidance | Current Guidance | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Fixed Income Net Investment Income (NII) | FY 2025 | $2.9B after tax | $3.0B after tax | raised |
Fixed Income Net Investment Income (NII) | Q1 2025 | $700M after tax | $710M after tax | raised |
Fixed Income Net Investment Income (NII) | Q4 2025 | $760M after tax | $790M after tax | raised |
Expense Ratio | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | 28.5% | no prior guidance |
Renewal Premium Change in Personal Insurance | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | high teens | no prior guidance |
| Topic | Previous Mentions | Current Period | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
Business Insurance | Q3: strong margins (95.8% CR). Q2: best second-quarter result ever (89.2% underlying CR). Q1: exceptionally strong (89.2% underlying CR). | Exceptional margins (combined ratio 85.2%, underlying 86.2%). | Consistently robust margins and combined ratios across periods. |
Personal Auto | Q3: CR of 93.4% , Q2: CR of 97.9% with 10+ point improvement , Q1: CR of 94.6%. | Record new business (+6%), combined ratio at 94.2%, improved by 6.4 points. | Continual improvements in profitability and growth momentum. |
IBNR | Q3: No mention [—]. Q2: Proactive IBNR approach in umbrella lines (2021–2023). Q1: Small IBNR additions in recent accident years. | Added IBNR reserves in casualty lines, reflecting uncertainty. | Steady adjustments earlier in the year, briefly referenced again in Q4. |
Workers’ Comp | Q3: contributed to $151M PYD, BI net written premium +9%. Q2: $300M reserve release, +7% BI NPW. Q1: $100M favorable dev, slight NPW shrink. | Remains favorable, ~$250M favorable prior reserve development; BI net written premiums up 8%. | Long-standing profitability, stable or positive pricing trends. |
Cat Risk | Q3: Focus on severe convective storms (e.g., Hurricane Helene), no wildfire mention. Q2: Record convective storms, $1.5B cat losses, minimal wildfire impact. Q1: Higher wind/hail/tornado deductibles. | Nonrenewing small commercial in severe storm areas, continued shrinking exposure in wildfire-prone CA. | Active exposure management to address convective storms and wildfire risks. |
Regulatory | Q3: Seeking adequate rates in tough states. Q2: Noted challenges in NJ. Q1: Florida issues remain; not reopening for new property business. | Tort environment still challenging, some positive developments on litigation finance disclosure. | Continuing challenges, slight optimism on legal reforms. |
Inflation & Geopolitics | Q3: Acknowledged inflation and geopolitical uncertainties as headwinds. Q2: No mention [—]. Q1: Listed among factors impacting risk environment. | No mention in Q4. | Intermittent focus, broader backdrop rather than a current highlight. |
Small Commercial | Q3: Slight dip in retention/new business due to portfolio optimization. Q2: Retention 83%, new business +8%. Q1: Retention 84%, new business +22%. | Retention at 80%, impacted by targeted nonrenewals; new business near historical highs. | Retention down but new business solid year over year. |
Nonrecurring | Q3: No meaningful nonrecurring factors. Q2: 2.5-pt impact in Auto, 5-pt in Home & Other. Q1: Mild winter benefit <1 point in Auto. | Favorable re-estimation provided a 1.5-pt benefit in Auto and 2-pt in Home & Other. | Frequent but varying impact from quarter to quarter. |
Corvus | Q3: Elevated expense ratio (+4.9 pts), improved renewal retention. Q2: Expense ratio up, expects it for a few quarters. Q1: 3.5 months in, comfortable with Corvus book, expense ratio higher. | Integration progressing; Corvus now writing on Travelers’ paper, boosting retention. | Ongoing integration with expenses elevated but strategic benefits emerging. |
-
California Wildfire Impact
Q: How will California wildfires affect earnings?
A: The California wildfires will significantly impact our first-quarter earnings, but it's too early to provide specific numbers. While the event will contribute toward our $4 billion catastrophe retention, making reinsurance recoveries possible if activity remains high, we have taken steps to manage our exposure in wildfire-prone areas. -
Business Insurance Margins
Q: Are current BI margins sustainable?
A: Our Business Insurance margins are exceptional, among the best in 20 years, driven by earned pricing and strong underwriting. We are pleased with our current business and market stability but won't forecast future margins. -
Workers' Comp Reserve Releases
Q: Any notable reserve releases in commercial lines?
A: We had approximately $250 million of favorable prior-year development in workers' compensation this quarter, reflecting ongoing favorable trends in that line. -
Reinsurance Strategy
Q: Why increase casualty reinsurance protection?
A: We enhanced our reinsurance coverage because market conditions allowed us to achieve a favorable risk-reward outcome, supporting our growth strategy in casualty lines. -
Pricing Trends
Q: What are current pricing trends in Business Insurance?
A: Pricing remains stable overall. In workers' comp, the renewal rate change is slightly negative, but with exposure growth, it becomes slightly positive. We haven't seen meaningful shifts in pricing trends. -
California Market Share
Q: How exposed are you to California wildfires?
A: Estimating our exposure is challenging due to outdated market share data and regional differences. While we've managed our exposure in wildfire-prone areas, it's difficult to quantify impacts at this time. -
Personal Lines Strategy
Q: Does strong Homeowners result change growth plans?
A: Not really. Despite favorable frequency in property, we're focused on improving profitability and achieving target returns before pursuing growth in Homeowners insurance. -
Technology Investments
Q: Can you provide details on technology investments?
A: We spent over $1.5 billion last year on technology, focusing on digitizing the value chain, modernizing infrastructure, and investing in talent, AI, and data analytics to enhance speed to market and pricing accuracy. -
Tort Environment
Q: Any improvement in the tort environment?
A: The tort environment remains challenging but is gaining recognition as a broader issue affecting businesses and consumers. Some states are enacting reforms, including litigation financing disclosure, which is a positive trend. -
Commercial Auto Growth
Q: What's driving Commercial Auto growth?
A: Growth in Commercial Auto is primarily driven by renewal premium changes, reflecting increases in rate and exposure. -
Personal Auto Competitive Landscape
Q: What's the current Personal Auto market like?
A: The competitive environment is consistent with previous quarters. We continue to make progress, achieving record new business in Auto during the fourth quarter. -
Policies Excluding Wildfire
Q: Do your policies exclude wildfire coverage?
A: In California, we offer standard policies that include wildfire coverage and DIC policies that exclude it. Customers may pair DIC policies with FAIR Plan coverage to obtain comprehensive protection. -
High-Value Home Exposure
Q: What's your appetite for high-value homes?
A: Our exposure to $5 million homes in California is very limited. We focus on middle-market and mass affluent segments, not the high-net-worth market.