CL
Chubb Ltd (CB)·Q3 2025 Earnings Summary
Executive Summary
- Core operating EPS of $7.49 beat S&P Global consensus of $6.16 and GAAP diluted EPS was $6.99; strength was driven by record underwriting income, lower CAT losses, and adjusted net investment income above expectations . Consensus values marked with an asterisk are from S&P Global data.*
- Record P&C combined ratio of 81.8% vs 87.7% last year, with favorable prior period development of $361M and pre-tax CAT losses of $285M vs $765M last year; current accident year combined ratio ex-cat improved to 82.5% .
- North America Personal P&C combined ratio improved sharply to 65.1% (from 81.3%), Overseas General grew 9.7% NPW with combined ratio of 83.3%, and Life Insurance NPW rose 24.6% with segment income up 14.2% .
- Capital return accelerated: $1.23B of buybacks at ~$277.67 average price plus $385M dividends in Q3; management reiterated increased buyback activity given valuation below intrinsic value .
- CFO guided Q4 adjusted net investment income to $1.775–$1.81B and full-year core operating effective tax rate to 19.5–20%; both support durable earnings power into Q4 and FY25 .
What Went Well and What Went Wrong
-
What Went Well
- Record underwriting and investment results: P&C underwriting income $2.26B; adjusted net investment income $1.78B; core operating income $3.00B with core EPS $7.49 .
- Loss ratio improvements and favorable reserve development: combined ratio 81.8% with -3.0 pts PPD impact; favorable prior period development $361M; current accident year ex-cat combined ratio improved to 82.5% .
- North America Personal turnaround: combined ratio down 16.2 pts YoY; improvement from lower underlying losses in homeowners/auto and expense savings; CAE ex-cat down 6.6 pts .
-
What Went Wrong
- CAT volatility through nine months: YTD pre-tax CAT losses $2.56B vs $1.78B last year (convective storms, CA wildfires in Q1) .
- Global Reinsurance NPW declined 13.5% YoY, reflecting disciplined pullback amid softening property cat pricing; combined ratio improved but growth headwind remains .
- Expense mix pressures in NA Commercial (flat CAE ex-cat combined ratio with +0.6 pt expense ratio change from business mix) and continued softness in international financial lines pricing .
Financial Results
Note: Values marked with an asterisk are from S&P Global. Values retrieved from S&P Global.
Segment breakdown (Net Premiums Written and Combined Ratios):
KPIs:
Guidance Changes
Management additionally signaled continued elevated repurchase activity given valuation vs intrinsic value .
Earnings Call Themes & Trends
Management Commentary
- CEO: “Published underwriting income of $2.3 billion was up 55%… with a record combined ratio of 81.8%… Current accident year underwriting income excluding CATs was a record $2.2 billion, up 10%… most all of it coming from loss ratio improvement” .
- CEO: “Adjusted net investment income of $1.8 billion was up 8.3%… Financial, economic and fiscal conditions favor continued attractive fixed income and alternative investment portfolio returns” .
- CEO: “In the quarter, we increased share buybacks since our stock is trading well below intrinsic value. Given our earning power, increased buyback activity will continue” .
- CFO: “Adjusted net investment income was $1.78 billion… above our previously guided range by ~$40M due to higher private equity income… We now expect adjusted net investment income in the fourth quarter to be between $1.775 billion and $1.81 billion” .
- CFO: “Pre-tax prior period development… favorable $422M… short tail +$460M; long tail -$38M. Corporate runoff adverse development of $61M” .
Q&A Highlights
- ROE Path: Management raised medium-term ROE outlook to 14%+ driven by underwriting, life income, and invested assets; buybacks to continue while building invested assets .
- Overseas General Composition: Majority is middle market, small commercial, and consumer—not large account/E&S; property is most competitive while casualty generally adequately priced .
- E&S Dynamics: Property shrank given pricing; growth in casualty and small commercial E&S supported by digital capabilities; programs like pet insurance contribute .
- Investment Allocation: Increasing alternatives/private equity allocation to boost coupon and IRR; current yields ~7–7.5% with IRR ~15%+, supporting faster book value compounding .
- Personal Lines Competitiveness: High net worth franchise differentiation in product richness, claims, global underwriting appetite; competition mainly on price in CAT-heavy areas .
Estimates Context
Actuals vs S&P Global Consensus:
Note: All consensus and actual revenue/EBITDA values marked with an asterisk are from S&P Global. Values retrieved from S&P Global.
Implications:
- Strong beats on EPS and revenue across all three quarters suggest upward pressure on FY estimate revisions, particularly in core EPS and investment income-driven items, with Q3’s combined ratio and PPD providing additional support .
Key Takeaways for Investors
- Core earnings power is accelerating: record underwriting, improved loss ratios, and higher adjusted net investment income drive EPS beats and durability into Q4; CFO’s Q4 NII guidance underpins near-term visibility .
- Underwriting discipline through cycle: property softening in large accounts/E&S offset by strong middle market and personal lines; expect continued margin resilience with targeted growth .
- Reserve position and development trends are supportive: significant favorable short-tail development in Q3 and management confidence in reserve strength reduce tail risk perception .
- Capital deployment is a catalyst: stepped-up repurchases ($1.23B) and ongoing dividend ($0.97) provide shareholder return while intrinsic value gap is emphasized by management .
- Segment mix is a differentiator: NA Personal P&C improvement, Overseas General breadth (Asia/LatAm growth), and Life expansion (one-time NZ premium aside) diversify earnings drivers .
- Watch reinsurance/property pricing: disciplined exposure in property cat and reinsurance may constrain growth but protect margins in a transitioning market .
- Estimates likely to revise upward: consistent beats and Q4 NII guidance suggest consensus EPS/EBITDA/Revenue moves higher; monitor tax rate guidance (19.5–20%) for EPS sensitivity .
Additional Document References:
- Q3 earnings press release and 8-K incorporation include full financial supplement and detail on non-GAAP definitions and reconciliations .
- Prior quarters trend: Q2 record underwriting with combined ratio 85.6%; Q1 impacted by California wildfires with 95.7% combined ratio but strong CAE ex-cat .