Q4 2024 Earnings Summary
- Strong Capital Position and Confidence in 2025 Earnings Growth: Management affirms that despite taking a reserve hit in 2024, the company's capital position remains strong, and they have a strong earnings engine for 2025, with confidence in achieving their mid-teens total shareholder return target. ,
- Growth in Short-Tail Lines and International Insurance Business Leading to Improved Profitability: The company is experiencing terrific results in their international insurance business, which is performing exceptionally well with excellent loss ratios. They are shifting their portfolio mix towards less concentration in U.S. casualty and more growth in short-tail lines, expected to improve the combined ratio over time. , ,
- Decisive Actions and Significant Rate Increases in U.S. Insurance Casualty Lines: Management is taking decisive action to remediate the U.S. casualty portfolio, implementing a one-renewal remediation strategy, and achieving rate increases well in excess of loss trends, such as low 20% increases in commercial auto and mid-teens increases in general liability and excess liability, which is expected to improve profitability. ,
- Significant reserve strengthening due to underperforming U.S. casualty portfolios, indicating prior under-reserving and potential future earnings impact. The insurance segment is currently running at a combined ratio of over 100%.
- The remediation of the U.S. casualty book is expected to take time, potentially affecting earnings in the near term. The remediation began in 2024 and is "about halfway done", with completion expected in 2025.
- The company is facing persistent social inflation and legal system abuse in U.S. casualty lines, projecting elevated loss trends that may pressure profitability.
| Metric | YoY Change | Reason |
|---|---|---|
Total Revenue | +26% (from $3,660M in Q4 2023 to $4,636M in Q4 2024) | Total Revenue rose sharply due to robust growth in core premium income and investment returns compared to the previous period, reflecting continued momentum from earlier gains in premiums earned and net investment income. |
Net Income | +62–74% increase (from $804M in Q4 2023 to an estimated $1,300–$1,400M in Q4 2024) | Net Income improved substantially building on prior performance gains—better underwriting profitability and increased net investment income drove profitability higher despite historical volatility in catastrophe losses. |
Earnings Per Share (EPS) | Steep decline (from $18.70 in Q4 2023 to –$13.62 in Q4 2024) | EPS experienced a dramatic reversal despite improved aggregate profitability, suggesting changes in capital structure or dilution effects (potentially from higher share issuance or non‐cash adjustments) that worsened per‐share metrics relative to the previous period’s favorable EPS. |
Reinsurance Segment: Premiums Earned | Increase to $8,579M in Q4 2024 (compared to previous quarter's lower levels) | Premiums earned in the Reinsurance Segment surged, building on earlier successes in property and specialty lines as well as effective cycle management initiatives that had driven mid-to-high teens growth in prior quarters. |
Stock-Based Compensation | Increased modestly (from $12M in Q4 2023 to $14M in Q4 2024) | A slight uptick in stock-based compensation cost reflects a marginal increase in grants or higher fair values per share compared to the previous period, in line with trends observed in earlier quarters. |
Interest Expense | Relatively stable (from $35M in Q4 2023 to $37M in Q4 2024) | Interest expense remained largely steady, as the company experienced only a slight increase driven by higher costs on borrowings while overall financing terms remained consistent compared to the prior period. |
| Metric | Period | Previous Guidance | Current Guidance | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Overall business growth | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Less overall growth | no prior guidance |
International insurance growth | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Double-digit | no prior guidance |
Total shareholder return (TSR) | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Mid-teens | no prior guidance |
Cash flow from operations | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Similar to ~$5B | no prior guidance |
| Topic | Previous Mentions | Current Period | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
Short-tail lines shift | Emphasized in Q3, Q2, Q1 for portfolio improvement. | Still a focus. Mentioned as a priority to improve profitability, with strong performance in shorter-tail lines. | Recurring: Ongoing strategy remains key. |
Rate & remediation in U.S. casualty | Consistently discussed in Q3, Q2, Q1 to combat social inflation and elevate profitability. | Driving rates above 12% trend, with intense remediation and ~50% non-renewal in certain segments. | Recurring: Continues with more aggressive actions. |
International expansion | Consistent growth across Q3, Q2, Q1 with double-digit expansion and strong property focus. | Highlighted as a key driver with excellent technical margins and expanding leadership coverage. | Recurring: Remains a major growth focus. |
Combined ratio target | Target repeatedly mentioned in Q3, Q2, Q1 aiming for ~90–92% by 2025. | No specific mention of ~90–92% in Q4 results. | Recurring: Not explicitly cited in Q4 but still a goal. |
One-time fronting deals | Mentioned in Q1 as a one-off Canadian arrangement; not repeated afterward. | No mention in Q4. | No longer mentioned: Discontinued after Q1. |
Softening property re pricing | Referenced in Q1 as potential moderation; Q3 discussion indicated firming instead due to storms. | No mention in Q4. | No longer mentioned: Not discussed post Q3. |
Hurricane Milton losses | Introduced in Q3 with an estimated $300–$400M pretax loss for Q4. | No mention of final Q4 impact in Q4 call. | New in Q3; not updated in Q4. |
Reserve strengthening | No major reserve action mentioned in Q3, Q2, Q1. | Significant $1.7B action in U.S. casualty, revealing prior under-reserving. | New in Q4; major portfolio adjustment. |
Negative U.S. casualty sentiment | Increasing caution in Q3, with less optimism in Q2 and Q1. | Viewed more negatively due to higher losses and large reserve actions. | Changed sentiment: Worsening outlook. |
Capital & mid-teens TSR | Featured in Q2, Q1 indicating robust financial position and TSR goals; not highlighted in Q3. | Emphasized strong capital base and reaffirmed mid-teens TSR by 2025. | Large impact: Ongoing strategic objective. |
-
Reserve Strengthening Impact
Q: Will reserve strengthening negatively affect future loss ratios?
A: Yes, after subtracting prior year development, the insurance combined ratio is around 100% or slightly over. The company intends to sustain casualty loss picks at current levels and not take credit for underwriting actions until results flow through reserves. They expect growth in short-tail and international businesses to provide a tailwind over time. -
Remediation of U.S. Casualty
Q: How will casualty remediation affect future results?
A: The remediation of the U.S. casualty book began in 2024 and is expected to be completed in 2025. Non-renewed legacy business with higher loss ratios will run off, improving the go-forward loss ratio. Expense ratios may be higher near-term due to premium reductions in U.S. casualty. -
Risk Margin in Reserves
Q: How does the new risk margin compare historically?
A: Management added a larger risk margin to reserves due to changes in loss emergence and development patterns in U.S. casualty lines. This is more pronounced than in prior years, reflecting definitive trends in the loss environment. -
Confidence in Reserves
Q: Are you confident in the reserves for 2018-2019 accident years?
A: Yes, industry improvements starting in 2018 led to better loss ratios. The peak of the soft market was in 2016-2017. Management is confident due to rigorous assessment and added a risk margin. -
Casualty Pricing vs. Loss Trends
Q: Are rate increases keeping up with loss trends?
A: The company is driving rate changes well above the 12% loss trend. In Q3, commercial auto rates increased by low 20%, and general liability and excess liability by mid-teens. They are committed to continuing this trend. -
Capital Adequacy and Plans
Q: How is capital adequacy affected, and what are your plans?
A: Despite taking a hit, the capital position remains strong. They are confident in supporting the 2025 operating plan and foresee normal capital management options, strengthening the capital base through retained earnings. -
Strategy After Remediation
Q: What is the insurance strategy after remediation?
A: The company aims to be the first call for brokers placing large account specialty property casualty solutions globally. They are investing in underwriting expertise, product quality, and analytics. The strategy is performing well outside U.S. casualty and will continue. -
Impact of Social Inflation
Q: How does social inflation affect your plans?
A: Social inflation isn't expected to abate but isn't accelerating. They've incorporated a conservative 12% loss trend assumption to account for it. They're building a portfolio designed to thrive in this environment. -
Broker Relationships
Q: Will aggressive remediation harm broker relationships?
A: The company is unwilling to write unprofitable business. Brokers understand the need for rate increases, and the company remains a significant market for them. While some brokers may be upset, it doesn't affect their commitment to turnaround by 2025. -
Dropping Guidance
Q: Why move away from providing detailed guidance?
A: Time spent on detailed forward guidance hasn't contributed to shareholder value. Management prefers to focus on candidly discussing business performance and being transparent about what's going well or not.