Lennox International - Q2 2023
July 27, 2023
Transcript
Operator (participant)
Your program is about to begin. If you should need any audio assistance during your call today, please press star zero. Welcome to the Lennox Second Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. All lines are currently in a listen-only mode. There will be a question-and-answer session at the end of the presentation. You may enter the queue to ask a question by pressing star and one on your phone. To exit the queue, press Star two. As a reminder, this call is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Chelsey Pulcheon from Lennox Investor Relations team. Chelsey, please go ahead.
Chelsey Pulcheon (Director of Investor Relations)
Thank you, Ashley. Good morning, everyone. We are excited to have you here with us this morning. Joining me today is CEO, Alok Maskara, CFO, Joseph Reitmeier, and VP Finance, Michael Quenzer. Alok will discuss quarter highlights, and Joe will go into depth on the company's quarterly financial results and our updated guidance for fiscal 2023. After that, we will have a Q&A session with Alok, Joe, and Michael. Turning to slide two, a reminder that during today's call, we will be making certain forward-looking statements, which are subject to numerous risks and uncertainties, as outlined on this page. We may also refer to certain non-GAAP financial measures that management considers to be relevant indicators of underlying business performance. Please refer to our SEC filings available on our website for additional details, including a reconciliation of all GAAP and non-GAAP measures.
The earnings release, today's presentation slides, and the webcast archive link for today's call are available on our new investor relations website at www.investor.lennox.com. Let me turn over the call to our CEO, Alok Maskara.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Thank you, Chelsey. Good morning, everyone. I am delighted to share our impressive results from the recent quarter, ending on June 30th, during which we delivered record revenues, record profit, record EPS, record margins, and record cash flow. These results demonstrate the power of our focused growth strategy and the progress of our commercial turnaround plan. I am grateful to our dealers and customers for their continued loyalty towards our products and services as we remain committed to further improving our service levels and enhancing their customer experience. I'm also thankful for the dedication and hard work of my 13,000 Lennox colleagues, whose relentless efforts have contributed to our outstanding performance this quarter. This successful quarter demonstrates the power of our laser-focused strategy, which builds on our existing strong direct customer relationships, advanced products platform, and our unique distribution network.
These factors will continue to fuel our share gain and margin expansion for the foreseeable future. Now, I want to discuss some key highlights of the quarter on slide three. First, core revenues grew 3%, and our adjusted segment margin expanded 320 basis points to 20.9%, resulting in our adjusted earnings per share increasing 22% to $6.15. Additionally, our operating cash flow increased nearly 100% to $196 million. Second, we are extremely proud of our commercial team's execution of our profitable growth strategy. Both revenue and profits for the commercial segment hit a record this quarter, driven by favorable price mix and improved production output from our Stuttgart manufacturing location. Third, residential end markets were challenging, which resulted in our residential segment delivering lower revenue, margins, and profits.
Margins were also impacted by lower factory output and absorption as we normalize our own inventory levels post the SEER transition. We remain cautiously optimistic about the second half, as we believe that the industry's inventory right-sizing is decelerating. Our recent price increase will enable us to deliver improved margin performance during the balance of the year. Fourth, finally on this page, we are pleased to share the revised fiscal guidance for this year as we anticipate higher revenues, higher earnings per share, and higher operating cash flow for the full year. Joe will review the revised guidance in greater depth later in the call. Please turn to slide four for our view on the current business conditions impacting the industry. For the residential end market, we experienced higher-than-expected distributor destocking and a cooler start to the summer selling season.
We are now anticipating unit volumes for the full year to decline by high single digits versus prior expectation of a mid-single-digit decline. Looking at the second half, we expect the impact of distributor destocking to diminish, and we have started to see an uptick in our replacement sales, consistent with higher summer temperatures. In commercial, we now anticipate sales to be up low double digits for the full year, versus prior expectations of high single digits to low double-digit sales increase. The order backlog remains strong, although delivery lead times remain extended, they are 50% lower than last year and in line with the industry. Regarding price versus inflation, we are pleased to report that the industry pricing remains disciplined, our own media price increase has been broadly successful.
Our outlook on both components and commodity cost inflation remains stable and unchanged, and we expect the second half of the year to deliver a positive price versus inflation spread. Ultimately, our improved service levels and increased commercial production gives us confidence that we are well positioned to gain share in the second half of this year. We continue to invest SG&A dollars toward improving our go-to-market processes while deploying incremental frontline resources to win over more dealers and more key accounts. We believe that Lennox outperformed the industry in successfully launching the product portfolio to meet the new minimum efficiency standards, gaining further loyalty from customers and our dealers. During future regulatory transitions, including the upcoming low GWP refrigerant requirements on January 1st, 2025, Lennox aims to deliver similar outperformance and capture additional share.
Please turn to slide five for more details regarding ongoing Lennox activities related to the upcoming refrigerant transition. We are pleased to announce that Lennox will transition to R-454B from R-410A refrigerant to meet the EPA's requirement, effective January first, 2025. The R-454B choice was driven by our commitment to provide the best option for our valued customers and the environment. Compared to the existing R-410A refrigerant, R-454B reduces greenhouse gas emissions and has approximately 80% less global warming potential. Lennox has demonstrated a solid track record of successfully navigating regulatory changes, and this will be no exception. We have completed most product redesign and are now in the testing phase for this transition. The redesign includes updated compressors and other components for refrigerant compatibility and high-efficiency performance.
To address safety requirements for the new A2L refrigerant, we will have additional safeguards on all our products that use this refrigerant. These safeguards may include sensors, controls, and algorithms, which will mitigate any leaks if and when they occur. Safety of all our products remains our highest priority, and our redesign will meet or exceed applicable safety standards. As you know, Lennox has a structural advantage of primarily selling direct to dealers. This enables our team to deliver advanced training to dealers and equip them with accurate information to share with the end consumers. This helps us and our dealers to win during the regulatory transition while addressing all the safety requirements for manufacturing, distribution, and installation. Throughout this transition, we do not expect a significant inventory pre-build as the transition to R-454B would likely happen faster compared to similar refrigerant transitions in the past.
We intend to deliver a safe, seamless transition, supported by appropriate inventory levels. By maintaining strong relationships and timely communications with our suppliers, we will avoid supply chain disruptions. While we are still reviewing this transition's financial impact, we expect it to be neutral or accretive to our margins. We are confident that the increase in the product cost will be offset by price. Overall, we anticipate that once again, we will outperform the industry and garner additional loyalty from our dealers and customers during this refrigerant transition. Now, let me hand the call over to Joe, who will take us through the details of our Q2 financial performance.
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
Thank you, Alok. Good morning, everyone. Please turn to slide six. As Alok mentioned earlier, the company posted strong revenue and earnings growth. Core revenue, which excludes our European operations, was a record $1.34 billion, up 3% compared to prior years' price and mix benefits, more than offset residential sales volume declines. Total adjusted segment profit increased $50 million or 22% versus prior year. Price and mix increases increased profit by $106 million and were partially offset with $43 million from lower volume and $13 million for inflationary effects and investments in distribution and SG&A. Total adjusted segment margin was 20.9%, up 320 basis points versus prior year. For the quarter, corporate expenses were $25 million, a decline of $2 million as we continued to tightly control corporate spending.
The second quarter not only achieved record levels of revenue and segment profit, but also marked record earnings per share, with GAAP earnings per share rising 23% to $6.10, and adjusted earnings per share growing by 22% to $6.15. Our second quarter tax rate was 17.6%, and diluted shares outstanding were 35.6 million, compared to 35.7 million in the prior quarter. Turn to slide seven. As we saw in the first quarter, industry-wide distributor destocking continued in the second quarter, and the summer season began with cooler temperatures, resulting in a 12% volume decline. The volume decline was partially offset with 2% favorable price and 6% favorable mix.
Our direct-to-dealer sales, which are around 75% of our segment revenues, experienced a revenue increase in the low single digits. The remaining 25% of our revenue, which goes through distributors, was down approximately 20%. Residential segment profit fell 6% to $203 million, and segment margin dipped 50 basis points to 21.6%, driven primarily by lower volume, inflation effects, and selling and distribution investments. The headwinds were partially offset with Price Increases and favorable mix, partially driven by the new minimum efficiency standards. Turning to slide eight in our commercial business, that delivered another quarter of exceptional results. Revenue was $408 million in the quarter, up 24%. Combined price and mix were up 22% and volume was up 4%.
Commercial segment profit was $103 million, up 150%, and segment margin more than doubled to 25.3%. Price and mix had an outsized impact in the quarter, delivering $66 million, and of the total $62 million of the profit increase. Last year, we provided guidance on a multiyear a profit opportunity of $100 million, and I'm delighted to share that our trailing twelve-month segment profit has already surged by $120 million compared to the same period last year. Our rooftop production output continues to increase, and we are maintaining a robust commercial backlog while steadily improving delivery lead times, which now align with the industry. Moving to cash flow performance and our debt to EBITDA, starting on slide nine.
Operating cash flow for the quarter was $196 million, compared to $97 million in the prior quarter. Capital expenditures were $49 million for the quarter, an increase of $28 million compared to the prior year. Our capital deployment priorities remain consistent, supporting organic growth investments like our new commercial factory in Mexico, driving industry-leading innovation, and exploring potential bolt-on acquisitions. In the quarter, the company paid $38 million in dividends. Total debt was approximately $1.6 billion at the end of the quarter, and our debt-to-EBITDA ratio was 1.9. Cash, cash equivalents, and short-term investments were $58.6 million at the end of the quarter. Turning to slide 10, let's review our 2023 full-year guidance. As a result of our strong first half performance, we are increasing our full-year outlook.
We expect core revenue to be up between 2% and 4% for the year and earnings per share of $15.50 per share to $16 per share. We're increasing our free cash flow target to a range of $300 million to $350 million. Our guidance for capital expenditures remains consistent with our prior guide at $250 million. As a reminder, that includes investment in a second commercial factory and investments related to the refrigerant transition to take effect in 2025. Price benefit is now expected to be $250 million. We now expect net material costs to be a $25 million headwind in 2023.
The material cost headwind is driven by component cost inflation of $90 million, net of $30 million in savings from cost reduction initiatives, along with a $35 million commodity cost benefit. Our new target for corporate expenses is $95 million, attributable to higher incentive compensation expenses. We will continue to manage SG&A expenses tightly while simultaneously making essential investments in the business to support growth initiatives, advance our innovative products and solutions, and enhance productivity. Finally, we still expect the weighted average diluted share count for the full year to be between 35 and 36 million shares. With that, let's turn to slide 11, and I'll turn it back over to Alok.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Thanks, Joe. In addition to solid short-term results, we are also making significant progress towards transforming the company for longer-term shareholder value expansion. Last quarter, we shared the key initiatives that pave a clear path towards our 2026 financial targets. Today, we would like to share three transformation phases that will clarify the execution time frame of those initiatives. Collectively, these initiatives will deliver on the 2026 targets and set up Lennox for even longer-term value creation. We are currently in the self-help phase of the plan, which delivers execution consistency to our customers and shareholders. We have already demonstrated success in our commercial recovery and portfolio simplification initiatives. Our pricing excellence initiative will drive favorable margins through improved price setting, getting, and netting. We are strengthening our core foundation by enhancing talent and reinforcing culture with an emphasis on accountability.
This stronger foundation will serve as a springboard for accelerated growth in 2025 and beyond. Looking into 2025, Lennox is prepared for growth acceleration in several areas. Our up-to-dated go-to-market sales strategy will increase our growth capacity and grow our core dealer base with a renewed focus on premium margin products. As we highlighted earlier, we anticipate accelerated share gain during the upcoming refrigerant change. Our technology advantage in cold climate heat pump will enable additional share gain during ongoing industry electrification. While we remain committed to delivering our 2026 financial targets, we also recognize the opportunities to continue expanding shareholder value even beyond 2026. We will build upon our structural competitive advantage with an expanded distribution network to increase our North American coverage.
We will also capitalize on this expanded distribution network to expand our share of wallet through higher commercial service penetration, higher attachment rates for parts, supplies, and adjacent products used by HVAC dealers. In summary, we are committed to our 2026 fiscal targets and also have a clear line of sight to strategic imperatives that will continue creating differentiated shareholder value. Now, please turn to slide 12, where I would like to recap why I believe that Lennox's structural competitive advantage is poised to deliver long-term differentiated shareholder value. Let me highlight the five pillars of our structural advantage. First, our direct-to-dealer model uniquely positions us to deliver accelerated growth. To capture this, we will enhance our sales go-to-market effectiveness, consistently elevate the customer experience, and make necessary investments in growth capacity to meet market demand.
Second, because we own our own primary distribution channel, we can deliver sustainable and resilient higher margins by leveraging scale and technology to reduce cost and increase the efficiency of our distribution network. Third, our balanced scorecard-based operating system, dual source supply chain, and lean digital processes deliver execution consistency throughout our operations. The fourth pillar is our advanced technology portfolio that is perfectly suited to serve the North American heating and cooling industry with environmentally sustainable, innovative solutions. Finally, we have high-performance talent and culture that is nurtured by our core values and recently launched guiding behaviors. We are continuously engaged in talent development and succession planning, while diligently ensuring that our compensation structure is closely aligned to shareholder value creation. I would like to close by reaffirming my gratitude to our employees and our customers.
We are proud of our accomplishments in the first half of this year and continue to believe that our best days are ahead of us. Thank you. Joe, Michael, and I will be happy to take your questions now. Ashley, let's go to Q&A.
Operator (participant)
Certainly. At this time, if you would like to ask a question, please press star one on your touchtone phone. You may withdraw your question at any time by pressing star two. Once again, that is star and one. We will take our first question from Jeffrey Hammond with KeyBank. Please go ahead.
Jeffrey Hammond (Managing Director and Equity Research Analyst)
Hey, good morning, everyone.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Hey, Jeff.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Morning, Jeff.
Jeffrey Hammond (Managing Director and Equity Research Analyst)
Just, just on commercial, I mean, the margins were just exceptional, so just wanted to understand, you know, margin sustainability, any aberrations in the quarter. Maybe just speak to, you know, the backlog and, you know, how much. You know, lead times are improving versus peak and just the level of reduction, you know, it, that, that kind of contributed to the quarter.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Yep. From a sustainability perspective, first, the backlog remains resilient. It's down a little bit, mostly because the lead times are improving. Margins within the backlog remain strong, reflective of the margins we saw in Q2. Pricing mix is solid in that business, and again, we continue to see output coming out of the factory, which is a good sign for volume growth to continue.
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
Yeah, I think the one thing you'll see, Jeff, you know, for the quarter price and mix propped up the quarter. Back half of the year, you should see volume, you know, even more, you know, from the commercial segment. We're excited about the future there. Once again, I think we've achieved getting this business back to the trajectory that it was once on, and we're excited about our ability to now, you know, demonstrate, you know, our, our trajectory of getting in, into our target margins by, 2026.
Jeffrey Hammond (Managing Director and Equity Research Analyst)
Okay, great. Then just in resi, anything more than really weather that's informing, you know, kind of the lower trajectory there? Just maybe speak to how your, you know, destocking is going for your company-owned stores are. Thanks.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Sure. This is Alok. Yeah, listen, on resi, I don't wanna talk just about weather, but we all know Q2 was softer. I think the distributor destocking was also more pronounced than we had expected. I mean, at the end, we took our volume guide down and talking about high single digits. That's also to just reflect our learning in 6 months of the year. As you see, notice, we kept our revenue the same. From my perspective, our own inventory destocking is going fine. You know, I think it will take us another 6-9 months to bring it down to more normal levels, that's because internally, we are just more cautious and don't wanna lay off a lot of people just to turn around and try and hire them, which we know was a struggle in the past.
From what we hear from the distributors, Most of them expect destocking to be over by Q3. If there's a little bit that bleeds into Q4, that's likely to be seasonal products like furnaces and things that don't sell well in Q3. That view hasn't changed for us. Overall, in resi, it's slightly worse than we had talked about last time, but within the overall guide range, we think it's similar outlook to what we previously disclosed.
Jeffrey Hammond (Managing Director and Equity Research Analyst)
Okay. Appreciate the call.
Operator (participant)
Thank you. We'll take our next question from Thomas Moll with Stephens Inc. Please go ahead.
Thomas Moll (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research)
Good morning, and thanks for taking my questions.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Morning, Tommy.
Thomas Moll (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research)
I wanted to follow up with, with one more on the resi volume trends and outlook. Are you able to share the, the volume trends in the quarter for direct to dealer versus Allied? You've talked on several occasions about the distributor destocking, which I would think is more an Allied-driven comment, but is there anything on a sell-through basis other than, like you said, Alok, the cooler weather in the second quarter, that's changed in terms of your outlook? Thank you.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Yeah. Clearly, Allied and ADP, which makes up our indirect channel, they had significant decline. Our core Lennox business was kind of flattish, maybe slightly down in terms of units. I mean, that gives us a lot of confidence that the industry is holding quite well. All the current softness is mostly driven by just de- distributor destocking. Now, you gotta ignore things like weather, because June was a little colder, July is gonna be a little bit harder, but that just get washes out for the full year, Tommy. Net-net, I think overall, industry is holding up well, and the current impact is almost all driven by channel destocking.
Thomas Moll (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research)
Thank you. That's helpful. I also wanted to follow up on a theme you highlighted earlier, Alok, just on the accountability and growth culture that you really wanna drive. Can you just bring us in a little bit more on what that means and what some of the initiatives are?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Sure. I mean, Lennox has a great culture, has always had a great culture. The past 5 years were just strange for Lennox. You know, starting with the Marshalltown tornado, which, as you saw, we finally finished the rebuilding, and we never wanna use the T word again in any of our conversations. To COVID and many other pieces, where supply chain, we got disproportionately negative impacted versus the industry because the supply chain was more reliant on China. I think the past five years, we just got beaten down and started using all of those as excuses. I think going forward, we have relaunched our core values. We have nine guiding behaviors. You may have seen some of those posters when you were here. Each and every employee is going through a training that's gonna be over the next 12 months, complete.
We really wanna emphasize things such as customer experience, accountability, innovation, sustainability, and of course, that depends on where you are in the organization. You know, we are very pleased with the results. Employees are generally excited about the path forward, everybody's ready to put the past five years behind us and truly embrace the next five, 10 years.
Thomas Moll (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research)
Thanks, Alok. I appreciate it, and I'll turn it back.
Operator (participant)
Thank you. We'll take our next question from Gautam Khanna with TD Cowen. Please go ahead.
Gautam Khanna (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
Hey, thanks, great numbers, guys.
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
Thanks. Good morning.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Morning, Gautam.
Gautam Khanna (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
I wanted to ask about that refrigerant change next year, and when you expect the mix to transition to that to that new refrigerant system. What are the pricing implications of that change? You know, when, when do you start to see the product transition into the channel, and do we get another lift like we did this year with the SEER transition in terms of average selling price and the like?
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Hey, Hey, Gautam, this is Michael. Yeah, so the transition really won't happen until pretty much January, but you will start to see in January 2025, some of that price mix dynamic where we'll lift up the price to more than offset the cost. But really, that'll be more of a 2025 impact than 2024. We'll be preparing for that through inventory preparations and transitioning and preparing the dealer network, but really no financial impact in 2025 or 2024.
Gautam Khanna (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
Okay. Just a quick follow-up. On the commercial side, where are you with respect to the emergency replacement market? Have you kind of reentered it? Do you have the capacity to do that yet?
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
No, I think.
Gautam Khanna (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
When do you expect to?
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
Yeah, Gautam, the way I would characterize that, right now, we're still focused on the plan replacement and national account segment of the business. You know, we're early innings in reengaging in emergency replacement as our factory continues to increase output. By the end of the year, we'll be more fully engaged in that, but it's early innings right now, and that remains a significant upside opportunity for us going forward.
Gautam Khanna (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
Thank you very much. I'll turn it back to you guys.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Thanks, Gautam.
Operator (participant)
Thank you. We'll take our next question from Nicole DeBlase with Deutsche Bank. Please go ahead.
Nicole DeBlase (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst)
Yeah, thanks. Good morning, guys.
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
Morning.
Nicole DeBlase (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst)
just maybe on the revised full year guidance. I think you're kind of implying that sub 50% of earnings is going to come in the second half now, and, you know, typically, that's more like 55% in the second half. just trying to understand, like, the dynamics between potential conservatism in the guidance or something that we should be factoring in from one half to two half?
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
Yeah, I think, you know, once again, Nicole, we've been accused of being conservative in the past, and I think, you know, even though we've had a strong first half, there still remains some uncertainty around the economy and, you know, certain residential end markets. You know, whether, you know, it, it is certainly cooperating now, you know, it tempered second quarter results a little bit, and you saw that in our commentary about our, our, our residential segment. Going forward, you know, once again, I think we probably have upside in the number, but once again, you know, we're going to be cautiously optimistic as we move forward.
Nicole DeBlase (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst)
Got it. That's clear. Thanks, Joe. With respect to the resi margins, so I guess, you know, normally margins are kind of flattish sequentially between two Q and three Q from a seasonal perspective. Do you guys see opportunity to improve resi margins as we move into the third quarter because of some of those specific headwinds that you called out on the call related to two Q?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Nicole, this is Alok. On the resi margins, you know, I was disappointed on where the margins turned out to be. While we understand the seasonal trend, and I don't want to bake up, like, you know, a lot of upside in the model, you know, from my perspective, resi margins have a lot more room for the upside. If you think about just the things we talked about, we need to get both manufactured margin and distributor margin to have margin performance that's much, much higher than where we are today. I think there's a lot of room. Our pricing excellence initiative, which only starts in Q3 from delivering results perspective, is going to have benefit. Right now, the factories are building less than we are selling, so there's a clear negative absorption impact, which is going to last through the year.
We think margins are going up in the second half, and then I think same will continue in 2024 as well.
Nicole DeBlase (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst)
Thanks, Alok. I'll pass it on.
Operator (participant)
We will take our next question from Ryan Merkel with William Blair. Please go ahead.
Ryan Merkel (Analyst)
Hey, good morning. Thanks for taking the question. I wanted to follow up on the commercial margin. Joe, you said it was price mix, I think, that boosted the quarter. It seems like the second half, the guidance is more like EBIT margins in the 15, 16 range. Can you just help us bridge kind of 2Q to the second half and what's changing?
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Yep. Obviously, we don't give really second-half guidance. Implied in that is still some conservativeness. What you really saw in the first half was a lot of carryover price benefit that we started to get in the second half last year. You will see some more price benefit in commercial in the first half than the second half. With that said, our backlog still has solid margins, and they should reflect that way through the balance of the year.
Ryan Merkel (Analyst)
Okay. Makes sense. Then, I had a question on resi, just the second half sales. It seems to imply maybe down 1, and it seems like what are the big drivers? Is it destock, decelerating and a bit more price? Is there anything else?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
I think those are the two right ones, Ryan, is, like, you know, it's destocking that caused most of the decline, and obviously July weather has been a tailwind for us as we move forward. I think those would be the two things I would call out.
Ryan Merkel (Analyst)
Got it. All right. Thanks. Appreciate it.
Operator (participant)
We will take our next question from Joshua Pokrzywinski with Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead.
Joshua Pokrzywinski (Equity Analyst)
Hi, good morning, guys.
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
Good morning, Josh.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Morning.
Joshua Pokrzywinski (Equity Analyst)
I guess one thing I want to follow up on is, you know, we talked about commercial margins a little bit. Obviously, you know, big turn versus where we were a year ago. Alok, how much of what you're seeing today or what you're seeing this year is sort of a pull forward of, you know, maybe kind of this three-year discussion that you originally laid out last year? Are you just ahead of plan by, you know, 12, 18 months? Is it, you know, more of the price cost stuff, which maybe normalizes? Maybe walk us through that journey and, you know, how we should think about linear progression from here.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Sure. You know, last year, about this time, we were at, I think, at Ryan's conference in Chicago, we talked about $100 million. As Joe said, we have got $220 million. What happened is the price cost turned out to be well, as we expected. That's because the team did a really good job, kind of, you know, getting the cost benefits, getting the right kind of negotiations and repricing some of the backlog. The upside continues from a lot of other factors, such as manufacturing. We are still below historical levels, which we talked about in terms of output. I think our factory still has a lot more room for productivity.
I still feel there's a lot more opportunity for us, as Joe mentioned earlier, on getting into things like emergency replacement, which we are barely scratching the surface of. Remember, we have a second factory that we're spending money on right now with no output. Net-net, it's not necessarily kind of pull forward, I would say. It's kind of things that just went better than we had communicated. Now, clearly, when we promised three years for $100 million on external basis, our internal plan called for half of that, and now we are six months ahead of it. Glad to put that $100 million behind us. We would not be making a new commitment.
We talk about a long-term margin range of, we've always said we want both segments to be in the 80%-20% range on a sustainable basis, and that's what we're gonna be focused on.
Joshua Pokrzywinski (Equity Analyst)
Okay, that's helpful. Just transitioning to, this refrigerant transitions, you talked about, you know, kind of the, the new equipment coming out in 25. I know next year there's a big step down in, in allocation for R-410A. Any sense for what you think that does to refrigerant prices or the replacement market? If folks are like, "Hey, this refrigerant is getting much more expensive, do I really wanna replace something where, you know, availability is gonna get tough?" How do you think about, you know, that, you know, equipment transition being a couple of years away, but, you Alok, refrigerant gap up maybe being a little more near term? Just, you know, open-ended question, anything on your mind.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Sure. A lot in there, I'll tell you, we don't have a crystal ball looking into 2024 yet. Each of the things that you mentioned is true. We don't have final price on the R-410A for next year. There's always gonna be an inventory drawdown that we'll have to do to make sure we're not stuck with legacy R-410A beyond what we need. From a consumer perspective, I think this is gonna be a small change. You know, we have gone through changes before. Consumers really don't think about refrigerants. It's more gonna be educating our dealers and a few consumers who are probably more well-versed in this than others. Still a lot of moving pieces. Net-net, I think there's a danger of overanalyzing this because the industry is used to these changes. We are very used to this change.
Our dealers are now getting used to this change. I think this is gonna happen more seamlessly than we all expect, with some, you know, pluses and minuses. As Michael said earlier, we think this helps our mix upwards in 25, but some of might start happening in 24 if the R-410A pricing is higher and we are, like, forced to increase our price in conjunction. Stay tuned, lots of moving pieces. For product design, dealer training, and truly having confidence in the transition, I think we are way ahead.
Joshua Pokrzywinski (Equity Analyst)
Understood. Thanks for the color.
Operator (participant)
Thank you. We'll take our next question from Nigel Coe with Wolfe Research. Please go ahead.
Nigel Coe (Managing Director and Senior Research Analyst)
Thanks. Good morning, everyone. Thanks for the question. I guess beating a dead horse here, but this R-454B transition investment spending, how does that sort of shake out through the next couple of years? I mean, you talked about investment spend this year, how does that look into next year? Clearly, you don't know the mix impact that's gonna be posted. From your understanding, is this an installation deadline or is it a production deadline? Do you think there's gonna be any sort of channel impact as we transition to this new refrigerant?
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
Yeah, I think this will be a situation where, you know, maybe a little bit different, you know, than the larger, transitions we've had in the past, going back to the 10-13 SEER transition, which was traumatic for the industry. I don't think that's gonna be anywhere near this, as Alok mentioned, probably a little bit more seamless. We'll just play it out the way that it is. You know, once again, we're in great shape. You know, we typically do very well during these transitions because, you know, we're on the leading edge of innovation. This requires a significant investment, $50 million this year, probably $50 million next year, to prepare, you know, the factory and processes, et cetera, to make the appropriate investments.
We've made some of those investments already, and as Alok mentioned, are ahead of things. This usually creates opportunities for us. You know, there's typically one or two competitors that stumble, and they leave some share on the street. You know, once again, we're well positioned for this transition. We're excited about what we're, you know, what lies ahead in front of us, and we typically win when, you know, these things come to fruition. We're excited about what, you know, this brings forward to us.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Nigel, just to add to that, it's a manufacturing date transition. As Joe said, we don't expect significant inventory build, because the R-410A is more expensive next year. The delta between a 2024 price and a 2025 price might be just like a normal price difference year-over-year. I just don't think that's gonna make a meaningful difference to our dealers' economic calculations.
Nigel Coe (Managing Director and Senior Research Analyst)
I'm just wondering, do our contractors as excited as you are about, you know, using this flammable refrigerants? It seems like there is definitely some contractors out there that might be pushing the R-410A next year to customers, just to, just on that basis alone.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
There might be, and we have 10,000 dealers plus more in U.S., and we can't control. I think overall, I think the flammability concerns are a little overblown. I mean, if you take a candle and blow the refrigerant on it, the candle extinguishes versus catch on fire. This is not as flammable as, like, some people might fear. We have done lots of internal testing, and the safety mechanisms are solid. I think from that perspective, I believe majority of the contractors will come along with us to say, "Hey, this is a safe product. This is a good product, and we'll follow the rules and make the transition seamless.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Okay, appreciate that, Alok. Just a quick one, just to clarify the distribution network expansion, is that primarily Lennox store expansions, or are you looking at, or do you think it's maybe more on the independent channels?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
It's both. I think the way we look at it is, we are under-penetrated in both. On our stores, our recent focus is more around increasing output through the current stores and putting more products through that, but we are still geographically under-penetrated in North America. On independent distributors, of course, we have a very low share. Both of those, I think we have significant expansion opportunities. Once we get through our self-help, once we get through our, you know, growth acceleration and put the right amount of feet on the street and the processes behind it, we are super excited about the expansion phase.
Nigel Coe (Managing Director and Senior Research Analyst)
Great. Thanks a lot.
Operator (participant)
Thank you. We'll take our next question from Stephen Tusa with JPMorgan. Please go ahead.
Stephen Tusa (Managing Director and Senior Equity Analyst)
Hi, good morning.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Morning, Steve.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Morning.
Stephen Tusa (Managing Director and Senior Equity Analyst)
Just on, on the commercial side, I know there's, like, differences in comps and things like that, but Carrier reported, you know, very, very strong, volume. You guys, I think, were up, like, 3%. You mentioned you still have yet to reenter emergency replacement, but where do you think the difference is between, you know, your growth rate and theirs, and anything vertical specific to talk about?
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Hey, Steve. This is Michael. Yeah, we saw total volumes up 4%, but if you look at the rooftop production out of our Stuttgart factory, that was up significantly more. We're, we're pleased to see that, that side of it. We had some, obviously, offsets in different products, but definitely some growth more than the 4% coming out of our Stuttgart factory. A lot of that growth that we saw on the rooftops was on the national accounts, and it was really broad-based across retail, and, and restaurants and distribution. Really saw that broad-based growth. From an emergency replacement, although it's small, we did see a little bit of growth in the quarter, but still very small. It's a good start to that journey as we, as we move back into that space.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
I think I would start also say that, hey, congratulations to the Carrier team. I haven't digested the earnings, but great growth for them, and we are excited that the industry growth trend continues, and the industry overall is in good shape. I think that bodes well for us and for them. We still remain production constrained, where, like, you know, we are producing less than we can sell. Excited about continued output increase in Stuttgart and our new factory in Mexico.
Stephen Tusa (Managing Director and Senior Equity Analyst)
Just on this, since you're kind of delving into the technology here, you know, you talked about it not being that big of a change. I think in December, you know, you said you now have, I mean, you just chose your refrigerant, I guess, is what you're saying. What's the source of confidence that your technology is so much better than the other guys? Also, why do you think you're entitled to share gains? In the last couple of years, it's been very, you know, choppy, obviously, with what's happened. A little bit of a different approach on initiatives relative to what the former CEO did over a 10-year period, a little bit different of a market.
Like, what where do you think your product is so differentiated versus the other guys?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Sure. couple of things, right? First of all, for the past five years, as I said, Lennox was in a very difficult spot because our supply chain was more constrained versus others, because we are more reliant on China than others. The tornado severely crimped our manufacturing ability, especially for the premium products. I think the transition on leadership and CEO, that obviously, while it doesn't have a direct impact, had lots of indirect impacts. but that's not important right now. I mean, what's more important is your question of why are we confident? I think our direct-to-dealer network is something that we have under leveraged but have done a great job building up. I think that's the investment that still needs to continue delivering results for a while.
Technology-wise, I mean, even in the current SEER transition, there was a lot of noise about compatibility of indoor units versus the outdoor units. A lot of new home builders, they put indoor units first, and then they put outdoor units. During the SEER transition, they had to go rip out indoor units if the indoor units were the older SEER compatible and outdoor units were newer SEER. Ours didn't have to make that difference, because our indoor units were compatible both with the new SEER and the old SEER. The connection to the dealer we have, that helps us make those kind of choices and decisions. At the end, I can tell you that our compressor is better than our competitive compressor, because you buy it from the same place usually.
What we can tell you is our product design, our actual package, and the choices we make for our dealers, that's what helps us gain share. The results would be probably more convincing than any of my answers. Let's wait a year or two, and then we'll answer this question with numbers.
Stephen Tusa (Managing Director and Senior Equity Analyst)
All right. Well, talk to you in.
Operator (participant)
All right, we'll take our next question from Jeffrey Sprague with Vertical Research Partners. Please go ahead.
Jeffrey Sprague (Founder and Managing Partner)
Hey, thank you. Good morning, everyone. Hey, look, you, you probably accused us of overanalyzing stuff, but that's, you know, that is what we do. I appreciate Joe's comments and reiterating kind of the investment for the transition. You know, it sounds like you clearly know what you need to do. I think Mike kind of left Gautam's question somewhat unanswered in terms of, you know, what, what's your best guess on, you know, the increase in, in cost or selling price to customers in 2025 on the transition?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
I think. Well, fair enough, I'll try and give more detail. I mean, part of it is we don't know exact numbers. I can give you ranges. There's two things to think about. The price increase from current prices, like 2023 to 2025, and then price increase from potential 2024 price to 2025. The reason we are hesitant to answer that question is not that we are trying to be evasive, but we don't know the 2024 pricing, which could get significantly impacted by R-410A production curtailment that's going on. I don't think it's going to be 20%. I just give you some ranges. I don't think it's 0% either. It's likely to be between 0% and 10%, putting everything together, and that's just going to help us all preserve our margins and pass on the cost through.
Going back to the overanalyzing, it was actually one of the Satellite Research Report, which says, the HVAC industry has become like analyzing storms in a teacup. I'm not confusing. I actually enjoy reading all of this, and I think I've learned a lot in my one year. I think what we have learned is that Lennox is going to win because of our direct-to-dealer network, because we need to leverage that better, because we are really focused on one thing and only one thing, and because, you know, we are able to design our products. Just recently, we got the, like, design awards, and we won more awards than others. I think that's what I've learned more, is that everything else matters, but we all do it about the same. What differentiates Lennox is what was in the last page of my presentation.
Jeffrey Sprague (Founder and Managing Partner)
Yeah. That 0-10 is from 23-25, though, just to put that finer point on it. Or is it?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
If you're not gonna hold me to it, yes.
Jeffrey Sprague (Founder and Managing Partner)
Yeah. Then, just a separate question. I know, you know Joe likes to kind of wink and nod, yeah, we're conservative, I mean, realistically, guys, like, you're gonna be at your 2026 guide this year, right? You're gonna be at the midpoint of it, roughly. You know, clearly, you're signaling you think there's upside to that, also, are you, in fact, signaling that maybe there's heavier investment to drive growth, therefore, we shouldn't, you know, kind of extrapolate too aggressively on margins from here? Maybe just give us a little bit more context on how you're thinking about that.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Sure. I think the reason I talked about the third phase of the transformation, which is beyond 26, is, yeah, there's a high chance that we will get to the 26 target sooner. I won't commit to this year or next year, because, I mean, our actions remain the same. I think that's one. On the conservatism side, listen, there are so many things that could go wrong, and historically, it has gone wrong for us in the past. We just want to make sure that if we are wrong, we are gonna be wrong on the conservative side versus being wrong on the aggressive side. On the investment questions, no, I think, I mean, our current investment rate is kind of what we expect going forward.
I mean, CapEx will go down going forward for sure, as the second factory is the heavy lift this year, and a lot of those refrigerant change investment is happening this year, and some will happen next year. no. some of this is also we are mapping ourself on the incentives on much lower incentive payouts last year. Like, you know, last year, our incentives were below target. This year, at least current match shows it'll be above target, so that's why the corporate cost delta, you see. net-net, you know, we are optimistic, and we hope to get to the 2026 targets sooner, but we know we'll get there to 2026 by sure.
Jeffrey Sprague (Founder and Managing Partner)
Okay, thank you.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Thanks.
Operator (participant)
Thank you. We'll take our next question from Noah Kaye with Oppenheimer. Please go ahead.
Noah Kaye (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
Hey, good morning. Alok, Joe, Michael, thanks for taking the questions.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Good morning, Noah.
Noah Kaye (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
Great. Maybe just to better understand the revised price mix, EBIT outlook of $250 million benefits. You've already done $182 million, right, year to date. Maybe if you can help us understand the dynamics for the rest of the year. It seems like maybe a little bit less benefit in commercial because the carryover is easing, but I mean, resi is clipping along at, you know, kind of this $40 million per quarter run rate. You just implemented PIs. Just help us understand that revised guide.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Hey, Noah, it's Michael. Yeah, one of the big drivers is, as you mentioned, the carryover benefit on commercials. That's an outsized difference between first half and second half. With that said, we do have a little bit of conservativeness. As Alok said, some of that would be in the price mix category, but really what we're focused on is the pricing excellence in residential. This new price increase that we've just announced, that'll start to happen in the second half, and again, margins look good in the commercial backlog. Everything looks positive for the second half of price mix still, but guide may be a little conservative.
Noah Kaye (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
Yeah, just to double-click on that, I mean, how do we think about the incremental benefit of that price increase on resi side?
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Yeah. In the last quarter, we raised our price mix guide from 150 to 175. That $25 million reflected that additional residential price increase. We already had that in the-
Noah Kaye (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
Right
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
In the previous $175 guide.
Noah Kaye (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
Okay.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
That's progressing well.
Noah Kaye (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
You know, on the Saltillo expansion, you know, just can you give us an update on how the timetable there looks? Just sort of remind us or, or dimension for us how much that increases commercials, you know, revenue capacity.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Sure. Yeah, just before this, 15 minutes before the call, I was with the commercial team, congratulating them on an excellent quarter, and I saw latest video feed and pictures of the Saltillo factory construction. The ground is all prepared. We have roof going up in portions of the business. We are hiring talent. Some are being redeployed from our residential factory in Saltillo. Clearly, we are, like, you know, well on the way of ordering equipment, given some of the extended lead time. All indications are green and solid that we will be starting production end of next year. Nameplate capacity-wise, you know, over years, it could more than double our capacity, at the same time, like, you know, we're not gonna put all the equipment immediately, right?
We're gonna get enough land and roof space to put more, but we're gonna put equipment on a judicious basis. The last thing we want is the industry to have overcapacity on this as well, so we've got to watch out. As Joe mentioned earlier, this will be focused around standard products, shipped by the truckload, getting into the emergency replacement, where our revenue is below what it used to be and our share is just dismally low. We have a huge opportunity to use our distribution network to increase that number. We are very excited and all systems go there.
Noah Kaye (Managing Director and Senior Analyst)
Great. Thanks so much for the color, guys. Take care.
Operator (participant)
We'll go next to Joseph Ritchie with Goldman Sachs. Please go ahead.
Joseph Ritchie (VP and Senior Equity Analyst)
Hey, thanks. Good morning, guys.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Good morning, Joe.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Good morning, Joe.
Joseph Ritchie (VP and Senior Equity Analyst)
Just maybe just along the lines of Jeff's question earlier, and just trying to think about these commercial margins. I know that it was only just a few months ago that you gave us that 19%-21% long-term target, first half of the year, you guys are already there, and actually slightly above it. I'm just curious, like, how do you kind of think about the trajectory of the margins then from here after that business, maybe even beyond 2023?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
You know, I think our next Investor Day is gonna be 2024, and we'd love to update you on long-term targets. You know, there's a lot going well, but I keep in mind that a lot could go wrong as well. You know, I think one quarter doesn't make a trend. I mean, it's a great sign of our progress. I think the team has done an excellent job, but we need to leave some room for, you know, things could slide different ways. Net, net, listen, we are not doubting anything you're saying. I think just we need to be cautious and not get ahead of ourselves in where we are in the journey.
Joseph Ritchie (VP and Senior Equity Analyst)
No, that's, that's, that's fair. Look, it's a, it's a good position to be in, to be able to already, you know, be ready to update those targets. Congrats on the progress there. I guess maybe my quick follow-on question, the piece of your business, the quarter of your business that goes through independent distribution, I think you guys said this is down 20%. How much were volumes down versus the pricing that came through in that business?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Volume on that one is a little messy because remember, we sell a lot of coils in that business. I think that kind of often skews the volume number for us in a negative way. In general, I would say they were slightly better than what you would look at on the AHRI data. I mean, you guys all look at the AHRI data. I think we did better than what you saw in the AHRI data, but slightly better.
Joseph Ritchie (VP and Senior Equity Analyst)
Okay, great. Thank you, guys.
Operator (participant)
We will take our next question from Joe O'Dea with Wells Fargo. Please go ahead.
Joe O'Dea (Managing Director)
Hi, good morning.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Hi, Joe.
Joe O'Dea (Managing Director)
I wanted to just start on how the commercial manufacturing, you've sort of noted that there are still further manufacturing improvements to make in the back half of the year. Any details around that, that you could outline for us, any major sort of goalposts there? What's the timeline for when you expect factory output to hit targeted levels?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Sure. You know, very good question on that. Listen, when we started the year, we hardly had any production in January because we were taking some drastic improvement actions. We rationalized 65% of our SKUs. We, like, you know, looked at different lines and reconfigured the line to make the products that give us the best way to serve our customers. Starting from almost 0 in January until the end of the first half, we have reached progressively higher numbers and are starting to hit daily rates that are kind of consistent with what the factory used to do in the past. Think of first half as kind of, you know, a linear progression from 0 to getting to the rate. Second half, I think that, like, you know, we've got to obviously maintain rate and continue driving the improvements going forward.
The team's doing well there. I mean, our labor challenges are behind us. We are no longer struggling to attract labor. I would say supplier challenges are kind of 75%-80% behind us. We still feel like we are playing Whac-A-Mole sometime. But we have done a good job with getting dual source supplier or working with our suppliers to better communicate and build the appropriate buffer and transportation. Things are going well. It could go better, is the way I look at it.
Joe O'Dea (Managing Director)
Got it. That's helpful. You know, just circling back to the, the 25.3% commercial margin, I mean, how, how does that compare to kinda internal expectations for the quarter? You know, when we think about seasonality going forward, I mean, any sort of variances to be mindful of versus typical seasonality in the back half?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Yeah, I could tell you my answer, but I'll hand it over to Michael to answer the rest. Yeah, listen, my expectations are always higher than the team delivers, but put that aside, like, I think Michael can give you a better answer on that.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
The speed of the recovery was a little faster than expected, and a lot of this on the price mix benefit, so we're pleased to see that side of it. It was a little better than what we had expected, mostly just because of the price mix speed of recovery that we saw.
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
Then on the, you know, on the seasonality that you, you know, that you inquired about, there's always a natural choppiness in, in the commercial business because a lot of it's project nature. It doesn't really have, you know, the perfect seasonality that we sometimes see in our residential demand patterns. I'll just leave that out there. You know, sometimes the second quarter can be a little bit more of a, you know, a leading quarter for us than the third quarter, but it all depends on projects.
Joe O'Dea (Managing Director)
Nothing non-repeat, really, in the quarter to be mindful of in terms of sort of.
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
No
Joe O'Dea (Managing Director)
for the back half?
Joseph Reitmeier (CFO)
Yeah.
Joe O'Dea (Managing Director)
Thank you.
Operator (participant)
We'll take our next question from Julian Mitchell with Barclays. Please go ahead.
Julian Mitchell (Managing Director)
Thanks very much. Thanks for, squeezing it in. Just for anyone overly sensitive, definitely the teacup comments were not meant to denigrate, diligent work. In terms of, you know, I suppose sort of diving in.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
I kind of-
Julian Mitchell (Managing Director)
Oh, yeah.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Julian, I sort of enjoyed that comment, and I use that often, so I thought it was a great way to look at bigger picture while continuing to analyze the storm in a teacup, so.
Julian Mitchell (Managing Director)
Oh, yes. We'll see how the, the resi cliff plays out, I suppose. In the very, very short term, are we sort of trying to move away from 2025, but are we trying to think about resi HVAC volumes in your guide, you're assuming sort of down low double digit third quarter and then down sort of low singles in fourth quarter? Is that the way to think about it, year on year?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
On the indirect side, maybe, but no, not on the overall basis. Our volumes are not down, that much. I know if you look at the current bridge, and we showed 12% on the resi side, Julian?
Julian Mitchell (Managing Director)
Yeah.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
You gotta keep in mind, that's probably the worst that you would see during the year. As we go toward Q3, we think the number just gets better from there on.
Julian Mitchell (Managing Director)
Okay, even with the destocking in Q3, it's still a narrower year-on-year decline then?
Alok Maskara (CEO)
Exactly. I think some destocking started happening in Q3, very little, and we do think destocking is decelerating, as we mentioned in the comment.
Julian Mitchell (Managing Director)
Got it.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
I would look at that number being much lower in Q3 and then Q4.
Julian Mitchell (Managing Director)
That's perfect. Thank you. Then I just wanted to put a finer point on the, the core sales guide of sort of up 3%, you know, total company for the year. Did you clarify the, the price mix tailwind within that? I, I see the price mix EBIT guided benefit, just wondered if you clarified any revenue benefit from price mix in that sales guide.
Alok Maskara (CEO)
We did not. I think a lot of that is there are so many different types of mix in there. I mean, we look at channel mix, we look at products like equipment versus parts versus coil. We look at, obviously, mix based on the SEER. We did say that about half of the mix benefit in residential was because of SEER, and the other half was all the other factors in there. Still a lot of uncertainty out there, but we are pleased with where we are in July.
Julian Mitchell (Managing Director)
That's helpful. One last quick one. Commercial backlog, how do you see that moving from here? I understand that lead times should normalize. Does that put much pressure on the backlog, or the end market is sort of strong enough, it should stay stable?
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Hey, Julian, this is Michael. Yeah, we saw our lead times improve 50%. Obviously, our backlog didn't decline that much. The order rates continue to remain strong. Everything we see on plan replacement for national accounts still remains strong. Really no indication yet of a backlog decline, except for just because of lead times are shortening.
Julian Mitchell (Managing Director)
That's great. Thank you.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Yep.
Operator (participant)
Thank you for joining us today. Since there are no further questions, this will conclude Lennox Second Quarter Conference Call. You may disconnect your line at this time, have a wonderful day.
Michael Quenzer (VP Finance)
Thank you.
