Paul J. Dolan
About Paul J. Dolan
Paul J. Dolan (age 67) is a Class B director of MSGE, serving since April 20, 2023. He is Chairman and CEO of the Cleveland Guardians (MLB) since 2010, previously President (2004–2010) and VP & General Counsel (2000–2004); he also serves on MLB’s Ownership and Diversity & Inclusion Committees and the Executive Council. He is part of the Dolan family group that controls MSGE’s Class B shares and is not classified as independent under NYSE rules; MSGE is a controlled company with independent directors limited to Class A seats .
Past Roles
| Organization | Role | Tenure | Committees/Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cleveland Guardians (MLB) | Chairman & CEO | 2010–present | MLB Ownership Committee; Diversity & Inclusion Committee; Executive Council |
| Cleveland Guardians (MLB) | President | 2004–2010 | Senior franchise leadership |
| Cleveland Guardians (MLB) | VP & General Counsel | 2000–2004 | Legal oversight |
| The J.M. Smucker Company | Director; Chair, Executive Compensation Committee | Director 2006–2023; Chair 2017–Aug 2022 | Led comp oversight; committee member before/after chair role |
| Fast Ball Sports Productions | Chairman & CEO | 2006–2012 | Sports media management |
| MSG Networks | Director | 2015–2021 | Board oversight |
| Cablevision | Director | 2015–2016 | Board oversight |
External Roles
| Organization | Role | Tenure | Committees/Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sphere Entertainment (SPHR) | Director | 2020–present | Overlapping board with MSGE/MSG Sports |
| Madison Square Garden Sports (MSGS) | Director | 2019–present | Overlapping board with MSGE/SPHR |
| Dix & Eaton (private) | Director | 2014–present | Communications/PR oversight |
Board Governance
- Committee memberships: None; Dolan does not sit on Audit or Compensation Committees .
- Independence: Not independent; MSGE is a controlled company and only Class A directors Bandier, Coleman, Salerno are independent .
- Attendance: Board met 5 times in FY2025; each director attended at least 75% of Board and committee meetings; all directors attended the 2024 annual meeting .
- Lead Independent Director: None designated due to voting structure; executive sessions of independent directors held regularly .
Fixed Compensation (Director)
| Name | FY2025 Fees Earned or Paid in Cash ($) | FY2025 Stock Awards ($) | Total ($) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paul J. Dolan | 75,000 | 152,790 | 227,790 |
Director program structure:
- Annual cash retainer: $75,000; Committee member fee: $15,000; Committee chair fee: $25,000 (not applicable to Paul due to no committee roles) .
- Annual equity retainer: $160,000 in RSUs; RSUs fully vested at grant but subject to holding until 90 days post-separation .
- Event tickets: Up to two tickets per event for up to eight events per year at Company venues; additional access viewed as perquisites at venues, though perquisites below $10,000 not included in table .
Performance Compensation (Director)
- No performance-based director compensation disclosed for Dolan (director pay comprised of cash retainer and fully vested RSUs with holding requirement) .
Other Directorships & Interlocks
- Dolan concurrently serves on boards of SPHR and MSGS alongside several MSGE directors, creating extensive interlocks across the Dolan-controlled companies .
- MSGE’s Articles and policies acknowledge overlapping directors/officers and permit Independent Committee review/approval of related-party transactions and intercompany arrangements .
Expertise & Qualifications
- Deep sports franchise leadership; extensive board compensation oversight at Smucker; long-standing ties to media/sports ecosystem via Dolan family enterprises .
Equity Ownership (Alignment)
| Security | Beneficial Ownership | Percent of Class | Combined Voting Power of All Classes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Class A Common Stock | 129,885 shares | * | — |
| Class B Common Stock | 1,437,495 shares | 20.9% | — |
| Combined voting power (A+B) | — | — | 13.3% |
| Director RSUs held (as of 6/30/2025) | 12,989 units | — | — |
Notes:
- Hedging/pledging: Company policy prohibits short sales, hedging transactions, margin accounts, and pledging of Company securities for directors/employees and certain family members .
- Section 16(a): No delinquent ownership reports in FY2025 .
- Director RSUs: Subject to holding requirement until 90 days post-separation; settled in stock or, at Compensation Committee’s election, cash .
Governance Assessment
- Committee assignments: None, limiting direct influence on Audit/Comp governance frameworks .
- Independence and control: As part of the Dolan Family Group that owns all Class B shares, Dolan is non-independent; Class B holders elect 75% of the Board and can approve auditor ratification and say-on-pay regardless of other votes, concentrating control and impacting investor confidence in minority protections .
- Voting bloc dynamics: The Dolan Family Committee votes Class B shares as a block (with exceptions for Excluded Trusts); James L. Dolan holds two votes and can block Company change-in-control actions, underscoring entrenchment risk for minority holders .
- Related-party exposure: Extensive intercompany aircraft, services, and cost-sharing arrangements among MSGE, SPHR, MSGS, and AMC Networks; Independent Committees oversee and approve related-party transactions, but breadth of ties elevates conflict risk perception .
RED FLAGS
- Controlled company with concentrated family voting control; non-independent Dolan family directors (including Paul) dominate board composition .
- Cross-company interlocks and transactions (aircraft, services, shared executives) could introduce conflicts despite Independent Committee oversight .
- Dolan Family Committee’s ability to block change-in-control transactions reduces takeover optionality and may cap governance-driven catalysts .
Potential positives
- Regular executive sessions and independent Audit/Compensation Committees provide some checks; Board-wide attendance is adequate (≥75%) .
- Director equity with holding requirement fosters ongoing alignment via RSUs held until 90 days post-separation .