Q4 2024 Earnings Summary
- M&T Bank expects net interest margin to continue increasing throughout 2025, driven by their locked-in swap portfolio gains and positive asset repricing, which could enhance profitability.
- The bank has successfully reduced its commercial real estate (CRE) exposure while maintaining core customer relationships, and is now rebuilding its CRE pipeline, positioning itself for future growth in this sector.
- M&T is expanding its fee income opportunities by growing its capital markets and investment banking services, enhancing its CRE platform through partnerships (e.g., with Blackstone), and expanding internationally, which could boost revenue.
- Potential stress in the loan portfolio, particularly in office CRE loans, if interest rates remain high. Daryl Bible acknowledged that "if rates stay where they are, there will be some stress in the system. We still are concerned with office". This suggests that without further rate cuts, the bank may face increased credit stress, especially in the commercial real estate (CRE) sector.
- Higher-than-desired stress capital buffer indicating regulatory capital constraints. Daryl Bible stated that "Our stress capital buffer is still too high from how we look at it, and we need to bring it down some more". A higher stress capital buffer could limit the bank's ability to return capital to shareholders or require retention of earnings to meet regulatory requirements.
- Soft loan demand in middle market businesses may limit loan growth prospects. Daryl Bible noted that "If you look at our middle market businesses... it tends to be a little bit more soft. I think waiting for more certainty to come out from the administration and how things play out". Weak loan demand in this segment could constrain the bank's ability to grow its loan portfolio.
| Metric | YoY Change | Reason |
|---|---|---|
Total Revenue | +3.7% (from $2,300.33m in Q4 2023 to $2,385m in Q4 2024) | Total Revenue increased driven by improved net interest and noninterest income across key segments such as Retail and Commercial Banking, reflecting the consistent operational performance seen in prior periods. |
Net Income | +41% (from $482.4m in Q4 2023 to $681m in Q4 2024) | Net Income surged as enhanced operating performance and efficiency boosted earnings—supporting a marked improvement compared to the previous year's figure. |
Basic EPS | +41% (from $2.76 in Q4 2023 to $3.88 in Q4 2024) | Basic EPS grew significantly due to higher net income combined with effective share repurchase measures that lowered the weighted-average shares outstanding, consistent with the increase in earnings. |
Diluted EPS | +40%+ (from $2.74 in Q4 2023 to $3.86 in Q4 2024) | Diluted EPS improved as the strong net income growth, coupled with stable share counts and effective cost management, translated into higher earnings per share on a diluted basis relative to the previous period. |
Revenue – "All Other" Segment | Shift from a loss of $1,872.79m to a positive $6m | "All Other" segment performance turned around dramatically, likely due to improved internal allocation methodologies and reduction of one-off losses present in Q4 2023, resulting in a move from a large loss to a marginal positive figure. |
Net Change in Cash | Decline to –$241m | Net cash decreased in Q4 2024 due to significant investing outflows and higher financing expenditures offsetting operational cash flows, contrasting with previous periods where cash flows were more robust. |
Debt Repayments | From $43.28m in Q4 2023 to –$1,687m in Q4 2024 | Debt Repayments surged sharply as the company undertook substantial refinancing and repayment activities in Q4 2024, a stark contrast to the minimal repayments noted in Q4 2023. |
Dividend Payments | From $232.23m in Q4 2023 to –$1,811m in Q4 2024 | Dividend Payments increased markedly driven by higher cash dividends on common and changes to preferred stock distributions, reflecting the robust earnings performance and a more aggressive capital return approach relative to the prior period. |
| Metric | Period | Previous Guidance | Current Guidance | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Net Interest Income | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | $7.1B to $7.2B | no prior guidance |
Average Loan and Lease Balances | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | $137B to $139B | no prior guidance |
Average Deposit Balances | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | $164B to $166B | no prior guidance |
Noninterest Income | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | $2.5B to $2.6B | no prior guidance |
Noninterest Expense | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | $5.4B to $5.5B | no prior guidance |
Net Charge-offs | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Near 40 bps | no prior guidance |
Tax Rate | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | 24.5% | no prior guidance |
CET1 Ratio | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | 11% | no prior guidance |
| Topic | Previous Mentions | Current Period | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
Commercial real estate (CRE) exposure and credit risk | Actively reducing CRE in Q1–Q2, shifted to stabilizing and starting to grow in Q3. | Reached target CRE levels and now rebuilding a $1.5B pipeline, with improved credit metrics and reduced criticized balances. | Moving from reduction to rebuilding in late 2024 |
Net interest margin (NIM) and net interest income (NII) | NIM rose from 3.59% in Q2 to 3.62% in Q3, with continued attention to deposit costs and asset repricing. | NIM at 3.58%; $1.74B in net interest income, relatively stable quarter-over-quarter. Management optimistic about further expansion in 2025. | Stable with positive outlook |
Criticized loans | Gradual declines each quarter: 12.9→12.1→10.9 (Q1→Q2→Q3). | Further $1B reduction in criticized commercial loans and $236M drop in nonaccrual loans, highlighting improved credit quality. | Consistent improvement |
Deposit cost management details | More focal in Q1–Q3, where each quarter highlighted modest declines or slowing increases in deposit costs. | Mentioned briefly: interest-bearing deposit costs fell 24 bps to 2.64%, but less prominent in discussion. | Less emphasis in Q4 |
Share repurchases | Q1–Q2: Plans to resume ($200M/quarter). Q3: Restarted buybacks; pace continued. | Repurchased $200M in Q4; plan to maintain CET1 at 11%, with buybacks contingent on loan growth. | Ongoing with a steady $200M pace |
Expanding fee income opportunities (capital markets…) | No prior Q1–Q3 references specifically on capital markets and investment banking expansion. | Actively growing fee income via capital markets, investment banking, and talent investments. Cited relationships (e.g., Blackstone) for off-balance sheet fee revenue. | New topic in Q4 |
Soft loan demand in middle market businesses | Not specifically mentioned in detail Q1–Q3. | Softer demand observed in middle market segment, potentially waiting for more economic clarity. | New observation for Q4 |
CRE exposure shift: reduction → rebuilding pipeline | Initially reducing in Q1–Q2, then discussing stabilization in Q3. | Confirmed $1.5B pipeline building in Q4 after meeting reduction targets. | Notable shift starting in Q3–Q4 |
Increasing optimism in NIM expansion | Q2–Q3: Consistent upward trajectory with expanding margin on the back of higher yields and lower deposit costs. | Highlighted positive drivers (deposit betas, hedges, asset repricing) for higher NIM in 2025. | Continued optimism for rising NIM |
Stress capital buffer & capital constraints | Q1–Q3: Cautious capital returns awaiting stress test outcomes; SCB improved slightly in Q2–Q3. | Aiming to reduce SCB further, calling it still too high; CET1 at 11.67% with plans for 11% in 2025. | Ongoing focus with steady improvement in SCB |
Potential stress in office CRE | Cited office as the main stress point in Q1–Q3 but improving with lower LTV and continued borrower cooperation. | Acknowledged risk if rates stay high, but noted reduced office exposure and continuing watchfulness. | Still a concern, though exposure is less |
Fee income expansion plans as new revenue driver | Q1–Q3: Growth in trust, mortgage, and treasury management fees, with ICS highlighted as a core opportunity. | Expanding capital markets, investment banking, ICS, mortgage, and trust services for $2.5–$2.6B fee income outlook. | Strategic focus with ongoing enhancements |
-
Capital Return and CET1 Ratio
Q: Can you explain your capital and share buyback plans?
A: We feel comfortable operating at an 11% CET1 ratio and plan to bring our ratios down throughout the year. Share repurchases will be driven by our RWA growth and loan growth. If loan growth is less, we'll do more share repurchases; if more loan growth, we'll do less repurchases. -
Credit Outlook and Allowance Levels
Q: Do you expect continued reserve releases in 2025?
A: As commercial CRE credits improve and criticized balances decrease, we might see reductions in allowances. However, we're shifting our loan portfolio mix towards consumer assets, which require higher allowances. Overall, we may not release a lot of allowance due to this mix change. -
Net Interest Margin Outlook
Q: How will NIM trend if the Fed doesn't move rates?
A: We expect our net interest margin to increase throughout 2025. Our received swap portfolio is locked in and will increase over 50 basis points from Q4 '24 to Q4 '25. Fixed-rate assets will reprice higher, and we anticipate deposit costs to improve, assuming two Fed cuts. The NIM trajectory depends on the shape of the yield curve. -
Expense Outlook and Investments
Q: Will current investments lead to lower expenses ahead?
A: We have six major investments, including three big ones like new data centers and a general ledger system, which happen once every several decades. Once these are completed, those expenses will fall off. However, ongoing investments in areas like data analytics and digital will continue. -
M&A Plans and Expansion Strategy
Q: How are you approaching expansion into new markets?
A: We're focused on growing organically in New England and Long Island, similar to our expansion in Baltimore 20 years ago. Inorganic growth could speed up the process. As we execute our priorities, we believe opportunities for M&A may arise, and markets will pull us into new areas. -
Deposit Trends and Competition
Q: Has DDA migration stabilized and will deposits grow?
A: Deposit disintermediation has run its course, and we expect core deposit growth of 2-3% in 2025. Despite competitive markets, our model helps us attract deposits, and we saw a $3 billion increase in deposits this quarter, all customer-oriented growth. -
Stress Testing and Capital Requirements
Q: Are you addressing your stress capital buffer this year?
A: We've opted into the stress test again. With reductions in CRE and criticized balances, we believe we'll perform better than in 2024 and aim to reduce our stress capital buffer this year. -
Borrower Sentiment and Loan Demand
Q: What's the current loan demand from borrowers?
A: Borrower sentiment is a mixed bag. Specialty businesses are robust, but middle-market demand is softer as clients wait for more certainty from the administration. We expect loan demand to improve in 2025 and 2026 as the economy grows. -
Regulatory Outlook with New Administration
Q: Thoughts on upcoming regulatory changes?
A: We're optimistic that the new administration will focus on safety and soundness risks, tailoring, and increased transparency. We're aligned with these priorities and believe focusing on fundamentals will continue to serve us well. -
Fee Income Growth and Product Offerings
Q: Do you need a broader product set to boost fee income?
A: We're expanding in areas like capital markets and investment banking to serve our customers better. We see growth in our CRE platform, subservicing sector, and ICS business, including expansion into Europe. Fee income is positive with good momentum.