John A. Seifrick
About John A. Seifrick
Independent Class III director at Mannatech (MTEX), appointed April 15, 2022; current term expires in 2026. Age 64 as of the 2024 proxy. CPA-trained operator and entrepreneur with over 40 years across audit, finance, operations, banking, and consumer products. Education: B.S. Business Administration, summa cum laude, with Distinction in Accounting (Ohio State, 1982) and MBA focused on entrepreneurial management and real estate (Harvard Business School, 1986) .
Past Roles
| Organization | Role | Tenure | Committees/Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arthur Andersen & Co. (Houston) | Texas CPA; Audit Senior, Finance & Real Estate Division | Began 1984 | Audit training and financial reporting foundation |
| Kitchens of the Oceans (FL) | Corporate Controller | 1986–1990 | Corporate controllership, accounting leadership |
| The Amend Group (Dallas) | EVP & COO | 1990–2002 | Executive operations leadership |
| Paul Duesing Partners (Dallas) | Partner & Advisor | 2002–2004; 2006–2011 | Advisory and partnership roles |
| Professional Bank, N.A. (Dallas) | Lead Organizing Founder & Chairman | 2002–2010 | Board leadership (Chair) |
| Senior Living Properties (Bedford, TX) | Board Member; consultant for nationwide debt facilities | Not disclosed | Governance and financing oversight |
External Roles
| Organization | Role | Tenure | Committees/Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| CAST Wines (Geyserville, CA) | Co‑Founder; President/General Manager | Founded 2012 – present | Entrepreneurial leadership |
| Pioneer Bank SSB (Austin, TX) | Co‑Founder; Vice Chairman; Director’s Loan Committee; ALCO; prior Chair of Compensation Committee; sold 2022 | 2007–2022 | Risk, ALCO, compensation oversight |
| YMCA of East Dallas; Wine Road of Sonoma County; Winegrowers of Dry Creek Valley | Non‑profit board roles | Not disclosed | Community governance roles |
Board Governance
- Independence: Board determined Seifrick is independent under Nasdaq/SEC rules .
- Board class/term: Class III; term expires 2026 .
- Committee leadership and memberships (current): Chair, Compensation & Stock Option Plan Committee; Member, Audit; Member, Nominating/Governance & Compliance; Member, Science & Marketing .
- Attendance: In 2023, all directors attended all regular and special Board meetings; all committee members attended their meetings during their service . In 2022 (post‑appointment Apr 15), he attended all Board and committee meetings during his service .
- Audit Committee: Current members are Jobe (Chair, financial expert), Rameson, and Seifrick .
- Board/committee activity levels in 2023: Audit (4 regular, 6 special); Compensation (4 regular, 3 special); Nominating/Governance & Compliance (4 regular); Science & Marketing (4 regular) .
- Role transitions: Effective June 1, 2023, Seifrick became Chair of Compensation; previously chaired Science & Marketing .
Fixed Compensation
Director fee structure (2023 policy):
| Fee Type | Amount |
|---|---|
| Annual Board retainer (independent directors) | $80,000 |
| Special meeting fee (Board or committee) | $500 per meeting |
| Audit Committee Chair | $20,000 |
| Compensation & Stock Option Plan Committee Chair | $18,000 |
| Nominating/Governance & Compliance Committee Chair | $18,000 (increased effective June 1, 2023) |
| Science & Marketing Committee Chair | $10,000 (increased effective June 1, 2023) |
| Chairman of the Board (non‑employee) | $300,000 |
Director compensation received by Seifrick:
| Metric | FY 2022 | FY 2023 |
|---|---|---|
| Fees earned or paid in cash | $69,125 | $91,333 |
| Stock awards (grant-date fair value) | $0 | $23,321 |
| Option awards (grant-date fair value) | $0 | $21,105 |
| All other compensation (travel reimbursements, etc.) | $691 | $1,089 |
| Total | $69,816 | $136,848 |
Notes:
- As part of the director equity component in 2023, most directors received $40,000 fully vested stock grants on Jan 3, 2023; Seifrick received a smaller stock grant (1,338 shares; see footnote) reflecting his circumstances .
- Re‑elected non‑employee directors receive 5,000 stock options vesting 1/3 on grant, 1/3 on first anniversary, 1/3 on second anniversary; 10‑year term; strike equals grant‑date close .
Performance Compensation
Recent equity awards and terms (director equity): | Grant/Transaction Date | Type | Quantity | Price/Strike | Vesting Terms | Source | |---|---:|---:|---|---| | 2025-01-02 | Common stock award | 2,686 | $14.89 | Not specified in proxy; Form 4 award | https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1056358/000105635825000002/0001056358-25-000002-index.htm | | 2024-01-02 | Common stock award | 4,932 | $8.11 | Not specified in proxy; Form 4 award | https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1056358/000105635824000009/0001056358-24-000009-index.htm | | 2023-06-07 | Stock options | 5,000 | $12.58 | 1/3 grant date; 1/3 at 1 year; 1/3 at 2 years; 10‑yr term | | | 2023-01-03 | Common stock award | 1,338 | $17.43 | Fully vested upon grant (per program) | | | 2022-05-10 | Right to purchase common stock (options) | 1,807 | $0 (Form 4 presentation) | Not detailed in proxy; see Form 4 | https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1056358/000105635822000043/0001056358-22-000043-index.htm |
Options outstanding at 12/31/2023 (aggregate): 6,807 for Seifrick .
Other Directorships & Interlocks
- Current public company directorships: None disclosed for Seifrick .
- Prior boards: Vice Chairman, Pioneer Bank SSB (co‑founder); Chairman, Professional Bank N.A. (lead organizing founder) .
- Compensation Committee interlocks: None; no officer/employee service; no cross‑company interlocks disclosed .
Expertise & Qualifications
- Financial/audit literacy; CPA background; senior operations leadership .
- Industry/entrepreneurial credentials via CAST Wines and banking board leadership (ALCO, loan, compensation committee experience) .
- Education: Ohio State University B.S. (1982); Harvard MBA (1986) .
Equity Ownership
Beneficial ownership (Rule 13d‑3 definition; as of stated dates):
| Metric | As of Apr 20, 2023 | As of Apr 19, 2024 |
|---|---|---|
| Shares owned (Outstanding) | 1,338 | 6,270 |
| Shares underlying options (exercisable within 60 days) | 1,807 | 3,473 |
| Total beneficial (shares + near‑term options) | 3,145 (0.2% of class) | 9,743 (0.5% of class) |
Director stock ownership guidelines:
- Encouraged (not required) to own shares equal to 3× the annual Board retainer; no formal mandatory policy and no individual compliance status disclosed .
Recent insider filings (Form 3/4) for transparency:
Governance Assessment
-
Strengths for investor confidence
- Independent director with deep finance/audit experience; serves on Audit and chairs Compensation—key for oversight of reporting and pay practices .
- Strong attendance; Board and committees reported full attendance during 2023; Seifrick attended all meetings during his service periods in 2022–2023 .
- Transparent director pay program with defined cash/equity mix; 2023 director comp disclosed in detail; equity awards and option vesting schedules specified .
-
Potential risk areas and red flags to monitor
- Related‑party environment at the company level (not tied to Seifrick personally): significant associate commission payments to director Kevin Robbins and family; charitable board overlap (M5M Foundation) with current executives and director family members. Compensation oversight must be vigilant given CEO Landen Fredrick is son of Chairman J. Stanley Fredrick .
- Concentration of influence: Chairman is largest shareholder; monitor compensation decisions and succession oversight for potential perceived entrenchment risks; the committee discloses independence and lack of interlocks, which mitigates some concern .
-
Signals from shareholder votes
- 2024 Say‑on‑Pay passed with strong support (For: 840,162; Against: 26,601; Abstain: 1,721; Broker non‑votes: 301,153), indicating broad approval of compensation practices overseen by the Compensation Committee chaired by Seifrick .
-
Related‑party/pledging/hedging
- The 2024 proxy discloses related‑party transactions involving other insiders but does not report any transactions involving Seifrick; no pledging or hedging by Seifrick is disclosed in the Security Ownership or related‑party sections reviewed .
Appendix: Committee Matrix (current as of April 23, 2024)
| Committee | Role |
|---|---|
| Compensation & Stock Option Plan | Chair |
| Audit | Member |
| Nominating/Governance & Compliance | Member |
| Science & Marketing | Member |
Director Compensation Program Notes (context)
| Element | 2023 Practice |
|---|---|
| Equity grant to directors | $40,000 in common stock (fully vested upon grant); granted Jan 3, 2023, priced at close; Seifrick received 1,338 shares (grant‑date FV $23,321) . |
| Options upon re‑election | 5,000 options; 10‑yr term; time‑based vesting 33%/33%/33% starting on grant date; strike at date‑of‑grant close (e.g., $12.58 on Jun 7, 2023 for Seifrick) . |
All citations: and SEC filing URLs embedded above.