Q4 2024 Earnings Summary
- Norfolk Southern has a robust pipeline of industrial development projects expected to add approximately 150,000 incremental carloads. The volumes from these projects will manifest throughout 2025, representing full production for these facilities and contributing to growth not just this year but in the years to come.
- The company plans to resume share repurchases in 2025 due to improved profitability and a rebuilt balance sheet. This resumption is critical to their value creation framework and indicates strong financial health and commitment to shareholder returns.
- Norfolk Southern is focusing on operational efficiencies, targeting significant improvements in fuel and mechanical infrastructure. By unlocking productivity value, they aim to drive further cost reductions and margin improvements, closing the service and productivity gap with peers.
- Continued pressure on coal prices and declining coal demand pose a downside risk to NSC's coal revenues. The company noted that coal prices have been under pressure now for a couple of quarters, with a "downside risk for the market" due to reduced seaborne demand and high utility stockpiles impacted by low natural gas prices. ,
- Headwinds from fuel prices and coal pricing, along with coal volume declines, may limit revenue growth and operating ratio improvements. NSC expects these headwinds to offset gains, leading to a guidance of only 3% revenue growth. , ,
- Constraints on the pace of operating ratio improvement due to inflation, fuel price increases, and depreciation may hinder NSC's ability to close the margin gap with peers swiftly. The company faces nearly 200 basis points of pressure on the OR from inflation, fuel price, and depreciation headwinds. ,
| Metric | YoY Change | Reason |
|---|---|---|
Total Revenue | -2% | The slight decrease to $3,024 million reflects lower fuel surcharge revenues compared to last year and a marginal decline in overall volumes, especially in certain merchandise categories. Additionally, weaker intermodal storage revenues impacted the top line. |
Coal Segment | -9% | This segment declined to $39 million due to continued softness in utility coal demand and lower seaborne export pricing. Ongoing competition from natural gas and elevated coal stockpiles at utilities also weighed on results, consistent with previous quarters. |
Operating Income (EBIT) | +40% | EBIT rose to $1,131 million, driven by productivity improvements, lower operating expenses, and favorable settlements in certain cost categories. Compared to prior quarters, the company also benefited from moderating fuel costs and better asset utilization. |
EBIT Margin | up 11 percentage points | The margin improved to 37%, from 26% a year ago, due to cost optimization initiatives, improved train velocity, and reduced overhead expenses. These efficiency gains built upon previous efforts to streamline operations over the last few periods. |
Net Income | +39% | Rising to $733 million, net income benefitted from higher operating profits, continued expense discipline, and no major one-time charges, unlike earlier periods with incident-related costs. Additionally, steady volume in key segments stabilized the revenue base. |
Diluted EPS | +39% | Increasing to $3.23, EPS growth mirrored the net income improvements, supplemented by ongoing share repurchases that reduced the share count. Compared to the prior year, the company’s stronger operating performance supported higher per-share earnings. |
| Metric | Period | Previous Guidance | Current Guidance | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Operating Ratio | Q4 2024 | 64% to 65% | no current guidance | no current guidance |
Volume Growth | Q4 2024 | Continued growth | no current guidance | no current guidance |
Revenue Growth | FY 2024 | 1% | no current guidance | no current guidance |
Revenue Growth | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | 3% | no prior guidance |
Operating Ratio | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Improvement of 150 basis points | no prior guidance |
Cost Takeout | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Exceed $150 million cost reduction target | no prior guidance |
Capital Expenditures (CapEx) | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | $2.2 billion | no prior guidance |
Free Cash Flow & Repurchases | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Strong free cash flow, resume share repurchases | no prior guidance |
Volume Growth | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Modest volume growth | no prior guidance |
Coal Revenue Per Unit (RPU) | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Continued pressure from lower seaborne coal prices | no prior guidance |
Intermodal Markets | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Volume growth expected | no prior guidance |
| Metric | Period | Guidance | Actual | Performance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Revenue Growth | Q4 2024 | Up roughly 1% | YoY from 3,073To 3,024, a decrease of approximately 1.6% | Missed |
| Topic | Previous Mentions | Current Period | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
Operating Ratio & Cost Efficiency | Consistently highlighted in Q1–Q3 with improvements in OR, productivity gains, and cost-efficiency targets. Examples include a 570 bps adjusted OR improvement in Q3 and reaffirmed guidance for the second half of the year. | Achieved 64.9% adjusted OR with a 160 bps improvement vs. 2023 and nearly $300 million in cost savings. Targets another 150 bps improvement in 2025. | Recurring topic, continued emphasis on disciplined cost management and OR improvement. Sentiment remains strongly positive. |
East Palestine Liabilities | Mentioned in Q1 with a $600 million class action settlement and $592 million operating income impact, then no explicit mentions in Q2 or Q3. | No specific legal liability discussion in Q4 beyond mentioning nearly $2.2B incurred and $650 million in accelerated insurance recoveries in 2024. | No longer emphasized after Q1, only brief financial references in Q4. |
Intermodal | Emphasized in Q1–Q3 with consistent volume growth, new reservation system, and rationalization of lanes for better service. Q3 noted an 9% increase in volume but a 5% RPU decline; Q2–Q3 saw continuing focus on operational improvements. | 5% YoY volume increase and RPU (less fuel) up 2% despite low truck pricing. Still a key growth driver in 2025. | Recurring topic, consistently positive sentiment on growth, with slight pricing pressure. |
Coal | Emerged as a concern in Q3 with declining export prices and higher utility stockpiles. Q2 noted slight pricing lifts eroding, and Q1 flagged high inventories and low natural gas prices affecting demand. | Downward pressure on seaborne prices; 9% revenue decline with a 1% volume decrease. Softness expected to continue into 2025. | Recurring topic, sentiment has turned more negative due to persistent price/demand headwinds. |
Industrial Development Pipeline | Not mentioned in Q1–Q3 in the documents provided. | Introduced a robust pipeline with 8 new locations + 4 expansions in Q4; strong 2025 pipeline for long-term volume gains. | New topic in Q4, could have large future impact on volumes and growth. |
Share Repurchases | In Q3, executives indicated they expect to repurchase shares modestly in 2025 from cash proceeds and line sales. No mention in Q1–Q2. | Plans to resume share repurchases in 2025 after balance sheet restoration. Part of their value creation strategy. | New emphasis for 2025, likely a significant capital return event. |
Margin Improvement Sentiment | Q3 noted 570 bps improvement in adjusted OR but flagged possible Q4 headwinds (seasonality, hurricane costs, fuel). No specific mention of sentiment shift in Q1–Q2. | No explicit statement of sentiment shift in Q4; management still projects additional OR improvements and cost gains. | Consistent optimism, no major sentiment shift documented. |
-
Productivity Initiatives and OR Improvement
Q: How will you exceed productivity targets and improve OR?
A: Management is confident in exceeding the $150 million productivity target for 2025 by identifying opportunities across all expense categories. They foresee a 150 basis point OR improvement through self-help initiatives, aiming for an OR around 60% once economic recovery boosts volumes. Key areas include efficiency gains in manpower, reductions in overtime (an 18.5% reduction in Q4 2024 vs. 2023), asset utilization improvements, fuel efficiency, and reductions in purchased services and rents. -
Revenue Growth Outlook
Q: Is the 3% revenue growth driven by volume or yield?
A: The 3% revenue growth guidance for 2025 is a combination of volume growth and solid core pricing, particularly in merchandise. Management expects volume growth in most markets except coal and anticipates executing their price plan despite headwinds from fuel and coal prices. They project a few percentage points of volume growth with good core pricing and less intermodal pricing headwind compared to prior years. -
Labor Productivity Opportunity
Q: What is the incremental labor productivity opportunity in 2025?
A: Management sees continued benefits and runway in labor productivity across all operating ranks. In Q4 2024, they achieved an 18.5% reduction in overtime compared to Q4 2023 and a full-year reduction of almost 15%. They are focusing on discipline within terminals, developing supervisors, and engaging with craft employees to drive solid productivity initiatives. -
Capital Allocation and Share Buybacks
Q: What are your plans for share repurchases in 2025?
A: Management plans to resume share repurchases at a measured pace in 2025, following a path to deleverage the balance sheet throughout the year. They have rebuilt the balance sheet through improved profitability, insurance recoveries, and line sales. Their capital distribution philosophy remains to invest in the business first, pay dividends, and then repurchase shares. -
Service Improvement and Pricing
Q: Will better service lead to market share gains or yield improvement?
A: Management aims to expand wallet share with customers by improving service reliability, leading to both market share gains and pricing opportunities. They are focused on increasing their share with existing customers and attracting new business due to the value of their improved service. They expect to continue recognizing value through price, particularly in merchandise markets. -
Operational Plan Changes
Q: What changes are you making to the operating plan?
A: The company is implementing the next iteration of continuous improvement in their operating plan, tightening standards in terminals, optimizing train weights, and customizing services to grow the business. They are leveraging speed increases, extending train lengths, and right-sizing the fleet to enhance productivity, reduce fuel consumption, and improve operational discipline.
Research analysts covering NORFOLK SOUTHERN.