Olin - Q4 2023
January 26, 2024
Transcript
Operator (participant)
Good morning, and welcome to Olin Corporation's fourth quarter 2023 earnings conference call. All participants will be in listen-only mode. Should you need assistance, please signal a conference specialist by pressing the star key followed by zero. Following today's brief opening comments, there will be an opportunity to ask questions. To ask a question, you may press star, then one on your touchtone phone. To withdraw your question, please press star, then two. Please note, this event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Steve Keenan, Olin's Director of Investor Relations. Please go ahead.
Steve Keenan (Director of Investor Relations)
Thank you, Andrea. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us today. Before we begin, let me remind you that this discussion, along with the associated slides and the question and answer session that follows, will include statements regarding estimates or expectations of future performance. Please note that these are forward-looking statements and that actual results could differ materially from those projected. Some of the factors that could cause actual results to differ from our projections are described without limitations in the Risk Factors section of our most recent Form 10-K and in yesterday's fourth quarter earnings press release. A copy of today's transcript and slides will be available on our website in the Investors section under Past Events. Our earnings press release and other financial data and information are available under Press Releases. With me this morning are Scott Sutton, Olin's CEO, and Todd Slater, Olin's CFO.
I'll now turn the call over to Scott Sutton to make some brief remarks, after which we'll be happy to take your questions.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Thanks, Steve, and good morning to all. In the fourth quarter, the Olin team delivered the four items that were promised, which were $210 million of Adjusted EBITDA, overcoming a -$100 million EBITDA impact from our purposeful Value Accelerator Initiative, stopping the decline of ECU values as a result of our Value Accelerator Initiative, completing the remaining purchase of 10% of our outstanding equity in 2023, and setting the company up for a 2024 that is better than 2023. We start that set up by making the first quarter of the new year better than the fourth quarter of the past year.
We are also very pleased that outside of the minor purchase price for the White Flyer acquisition, Olin's net debt at the end of 2023 was essentially the same as the net debt at the beginning of 2023. Since this could well be my last Olin earnings call, you know, I wanted to remind everyone that Olin has a very unique value creation equation of lifting people to a higher level of fulfillment, delivering value on a contemporary basis through a novel idea pipeline, and practicing absolute leadership in commerce. This unique value equation opens a long runway to a very positive future, and our leadership team will take Olin there. The earnings and cash flow power of Olin is huge. So Andrea, that concludes my opening remarks, and now we can proceed to questions.
Operator (participant)
We will now begin the question and answer session. To ask a question, you may press star, then one on your touchtone phone. If you are using a speakerphone, please pick up your handset before pressing the key. To withdraw your question, please press star, then two. At this time, we will pause momentarily to assemble the roster. Our first question comes from Arun Viswanathan of RBC Capital Markets. Please go ahead.
Arun Viswanathan (Senior Equity Analyst)
Great. Thanks for taking my question. Good morning. So I guess I just wanted to ask first on the guidance. So it looks like you're, you're expecting some growth in 2024. How do you see that proceeding? Looks like your Q1 guidance is a little bit below where we were expecting. So, you know, I know that you're implementing the Value Accelerator Initiative, so maybe you can just kind of walk us through some of the growth you expect as you move through the quarters of 2024.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Yeah. Good morning, Arun. You know, happy to do that. I mean, we're, we're really forecasting some profit growth, right? And, you know, if you just walk through the three businesses, and I'll just start with Winchester. I mean, we are right in the middle of doubling our military business, and that is on track, both domestically and internationally. In the commercial side of, of that business, you know, demand stays rather high, and on top of that, we have the White Flyer acquisition for a full year. And on top of that, there's gonna be a shortage of propellant across the industry this year, and Winchester is well positioned to take advantage of that. So we feel really good about the profit growth in Winchester. Look, in, in Epoxy, it's, you know, much more a self-help story. We're not necessarily anticipating demand growth....
But clearly, the restructuring work that we did is applicable for a whole year. Our focus on systems is working. We don't have to clean up inventory as much as we did in 2023, and we're gonna work on the illegal flow of products coming from Asia as well. So then, Arun, you really get to the, the biggest business, CAPV, which, you know, I'll just remind you, has super fundamentals as you look out in the future. But it's all about turning around the value of the ECU, and that's the initiative we're running now. We have a slide number four that gives some indications that we're having some success. I would say even on top of that, there's less volume entering global trade flows today. Some customers are restarting assets that have been down.
So even in that business, we expect Q1 to be larger than Q4, and we expect Q2 to be better than Q1 as well.
Arun Viswanathan (Senior Equity Analyst)
Thanks. And then if I could just ask, is there any update on the search for a new CEO? Thanks a lot.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Yeah, sure. Look, Arun, I mean, I really don't have an update on that, and I'm really sorry for that because, look, our shareholders and our Olin women and men who have really built this value for those shareholders, they deserve a lot better than that from me. But I'm out of the process. That process is 100% run by our independent board members only. You know, what I can say is, to the best of my knowledge, I'm not aware of any offer being extended out there yet to any candidate. Yep.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Hassan Ahmed of Alembic Global. Please go ahead.
Hassan Ahmed (Senior Equity Analyst)
Morning, Scott. You know, question, just wanted to sort of go back to the Value Accelerator Initiative. I mean, you know, you were very specific in talking about limiting your market participation till February 2024. You know, what gives you the confidence with regards to that sort of a timeline that you'll start sort of potentially seeing a positive inflection thereon after, particularly keeping in mind, you know, the macro, you know, housing the way it is and the like?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Yeah, sure. Hey, Hassan. Look, we think that's about the right time to make sure that this gets substantially turned around. I mean, already, and again, I'm kind of referring back to slide number four, right? We've seen the indicators of success. Certainly in our business, we are having caustic price increases, you know, effective, you know, January first and even a bit before that. Already, you know, EDC export pricing has lifted significantly. But in—for some of the public trade indices, that's still just projection, though it's their projection, not our projection now. But we do need to make sure that materializes.
So look, I mean, this is a real gain of momentum and third derivatives and second derivatives, and we're just gonna make sure that, you know, we deliver a bit more oomph behind that momentum, and that's why we're extending it a bit into the first quarter.
Hassan Ahmed (Senior Equity Analyst)
Got it. And just wanted to get a bit more sort of quantitatively specific about, you know, the 2024 guidance that that you gave. I mean, you know, you're, you're, you're sort of alluding to, you know, north of $1.3 billion in EBITDA in 2024. And, you know, if I were to just use sort of Q4 as a starting point, you did $210 million in EBITDA in Q4, so I annualize that, and you're at $840 million, right? And to get to north of $1.3 billion, you need an incremental, you know, call it $460 million in EBITDA, right? So, so I'm just trying to understand where that increment really comes from.
I mean, I know that in the slides that you guys presented, you referred to the sort of, you know, the value sort of enhancement initiative being $100 million a quarter worth of a penalty. So is it primarily you guys sort of stopping to partake in that initiative post-February and most of that EBITDA coming from there, or are you sort of looking for some margin help from the market as well?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Yeah, I mean, sure. I mean, hopefully, you'll give us a little bit on Winchester and the fact that you probably won't report, you know, repeat Epoxy being a zero. So then, you know, I get your question for sure. You know, I would also think a little bit about some of the math even behind this. You know, we took our operating rates down to roughly 50% from around 60% in the fourth quarter, and that was a $100 million penalty. So, you know, you might could imagine that as those rates very slowly creep up to match, you know, customers coming back online, that that's sort of an equation for where you might be. A $100 million penalty for one quarter to change the rates from 50%-60%...
If everyone's paying attention, they'll understand the math behind our operating leverage exactly. It doesn't take very much there to add, you know, $100 million or a couple $100 million or even $1 billion as things get better, maybe in 2025.
Hassan Ahmed (Senior Equity Analyst)
Very helpful, Scott. Thank you so much.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Aleksey Yefremov of KeyBanc Capital Markets. Please go ahead.
Aleksey Yefremov (Managing Director and Equity Research Analyst)
Thanks. Good morning, everyone. Scott, you talk about January first caustic soda price increases. Can you discuss them? Were those mostly monthly customers or quarterly contracts or maybe spot? And, what is your outlook for caustic next few months?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah, yeah. Hey, Aleksey. Yeah, I mean, look, I would say it's some of all of that. In fact, even though we put January first, some of that success happened, you know, early, earlier than that. And while it's across, you know, a number of customers, I mean, please understand that we still have a lot of work to do there. And caustic is a business that is still heavily tied to a trade index, and that trade index, you know, in the fourth quarter relative to the third quarter, showed a decline. So our pricing in the first quarter is going to change by the difference between those prior two quarters.
So we still have to get by that hurdle, and that- that's why in the last quarterly earnings call, we said, "You're really going to see this start to materialize in a bigger way in our second quarter results.
Aleksey Yefremov (Managing Director and Equity Research Analyst)
Thanks, Scott. And on the chlorine side, I mean, there's a consultant's view of declines for the year. What is your outlook and level of confidence in the outlook for the next few quarters as well?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Yeah. Well, I mean, the chlorine and chlorine derivative sides are, you know, still the weaker side of the ECU. But, you know, what I will say is that Olin's average chlorine pricing in the first quarter relative to the fourth quarter absolutely goes up. You know, some of that is because, you know, we've been able to renegotiate pricing in some contracts that expired at the end of the year. Some of that is because, you know, we ran this Value Accelerator Initiative, and the only way to pull out of the market was actually to pull out of some of our higher priced business because it was more spot in nature. But at least on our base business that continues without a contract change, that pricing doesn't go down either. Nothing is getting worse in terms of chlorine pricing.
Aleksey Yefremov (Managing Director and Equity Research Analyst)
Okay, thanks a lot.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Sure.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Steve Byrne of Bank of America. Please go ahead.
Steve Byrne (Managing Director U.S. Chemicals and Equity Research Analyst)
Yes, thank you. Scott, I was curious about this prolonged trough in PVC demand. Is that representing a bit of a challenge for you to negotiate maybe a partnering opportunity downstream, post the end of the Dow agreement in another year?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Hey, hey, Steve. I mean, look, I do think it's extended it some, right? But of course, with the change in our relationship with Dow at Freeport in 2025, we get a lot of excess capability coming back in our hands, and, you know, we'll have to decide what to do there, and everyone already knows that that's quite accretive for us, for sure, no matter what we do. So that comes available. I would say in addition to that, you know, we have a tremendous amount of VCM that's going through a pipeline to one customer, and all of that ends in 2030 as well. So we're getting close to being able to match up with a different PVC operator.
So instead of spending $6 billion on a completely integrated world-scale facility, you know, someone has the ability to spend 20% of that to get in business in a world-scale PVC plant. So I think the timing is okay. We wish it was a bit faster, but you're right. I mean, the situation in the world right now has just slowed down some of those activities.
Steve Byrne (Managing Director U.S. Chemicals and Equity Research Analyst)
Then just given this uncertainty about the new CEO, Scott, are you opposed to staying there in that seat or staying longer, depending on this transition?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
No, I'm not.
Steve Byrne (Managing Director U.S. Chemicals and Equity Research Analyst)
Okay, thank you.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Joshua Spector of UBS. Please go ahead.
Chris Perrella (Director Equity Research)
Hi, everyone. It's Chris Perrella on for Josh. Good morning, Scott and Todd. Question on the follow-up. I saw that the share repurchases slowed in the fourth quarter. What's the outlook for share repurchases for 2024?
Todd Slater (CFO)
Yeah. Chris, this is Todd. Thanks for the question. We committed to repurchase approximately 10% of our outstanding shares in 2023, and that was consistent with what we achieved. We were a relatively steady buyer through the year. We bought a little less in the fourth quarter, but, you know, consistent with the guidance that we had provided. You know, as you look at our Levered Free Cash Flow for 2024, you should expect us to primarily deploy that cash toward share repurchases. Our strong investment-grade balance sheet and cash flow enable Olin to continue to deploy our cash toward repurchasing our shares.
Chris Perrella (Director Equity Research)
All right, and then a follow-up. As you take the break off the Value Accelerator Initiative and you raise operating rates starting in March, with, you know, as the current plan, you know, I thought there'd be a larger step up in EBITDA earnings for Chlor-Alkali business. I'm just curious, you know, given the puts and takes there, it seems like it's not up much, and, you know, that $100 million penalty should be coming back a bit faster. Can you just kind of walk through how that penalty lifts?
Todd Slater (CFO)
Yeah, I mean, Chris, look, it's a really good observation. I mean, I would just keep two things in mind. I mean, you know, number one, we're continuing to run that initiative for, you know, up to 2/3 of the first quarter. But also on top of that, it goes back to that caustic pricing phenomena that I talked about, whereby, you know, the first quarter pricing that we print, you know, is determined by the difference between the fourth quarter and the third quarter, and that's already known to be a drop. So we have to overcome that as well.
Chris Perrella (Director Equity Research)
All right, so it's just a lag in the contract pricing-
Todd Slater (CFO)
Exactly.
Chris Perrella (Director Equity Research)
Playing through. Okay.
Todd Slater (CFO)
Exactly. Yeah.
Chris Perrella (Director Equity Research)
I know. I appreciate that.
Todd Slater (CFO)
You said it better than me.
Chris Perrella (Director Equity Research)
Thank you very much.
Todd Slater (CFO)
Bye.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Frank Mitsch of Fermium Research. Please go ahead.
Frank Mitsch (President)
Hey, good, good morning. Interesting on the Parlay chart, you know, reaching a high of 25% in the fourth quarter. Obviously, part of that is the initiative to ramp back your own operating rates. Where does that stand now here in January, and what are your expectations for that metric through the quarter?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Yeah. Hey, hey, Frank. Yeah, I mean, you're right. I mean, it's very interesting that for 25% of our volumes were out there selling, we were buying those from third parties. And it might just tell you about the strength of Olin, that we can do that, we can go run our assets at 50% utilization, we can take care of all those items and still have positive Levered Free Cash Flow even in the fourth quarter. So I mean, thanks for the observation on that or the hints of the observation.
Frank Mitsch (President)
Mm-hmm.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
I mean, I would say that, look, we're, we're still doing a lot of that because we're still running that initiative. I do think, you know, through the year, as we very slowly and incrementally may lift rates a little bit, you might see that percentage decline back some. We're unlikely to, to be at a 25% purchase of all of our volumes from other parties over a long period of time. It'll probably settle at something lower than that.
Frank Mitsch (President)
Okay, great. Great. And then as you, you know, as you assess the underlying market demands by region, you know, you had indicated the last time, you know, that things were right, you know, were rather slow and so forth. How is it standing here in January, and what are your expectations? What is actually embedded, you know, in terms of underlying demand as you think about 2024 being better than 2023 overall?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Yeah. Well, I mean, look, in Winchester, there's a demand increase in military just to, you know, sort of put that one to bed. We haven't planned on any demand increase in Epoxy, right? That's a self-help type of work. Even Chlor-Alkali, very limited demand recovery, but I will just say that sentiment is a little bit better here at the start of the year. Customers are restarting. Two of our larger customers that have large offtakes have been down for many weeks, and in fact, they're restarting. There's some light confidence, I'd say, in home builders, where at least maybe that doesn't go the wrong way. So there's just not a lot of strength in demand built in our outlook, Frank.
Frank Mitsch (President)
Okay, very helpful. Thanks so much, Scott. And if this is the last time we speak as you being part of Olin, I'm looking forward to your next adventure. Thanks so much.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Thanks, Frank.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Kevin McCarthy of Vertical Research Partners. Please go ahead.
Kevin McCarthy (Partner)
Yes, thank you, and good morning. Scott, I'd welcome your updated thoughts on the shape of the epoxy cycle. If I look at slide eight, it appears as though your prices eroded in 4Q versus 3Q. How do you think that will trend in, in the first quarter? And then I'm also interested to hear your thoughts on epoxies in Europe. You know, we're reading about disruptions in trade routes relative to the Red Sea, and purchasing managers seem to want to kind of get ahead of those longer lead times and increased tensions and friction and so forth. How do you see the next quarter or two shaping up for epoxy?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah, sure. Hey, Kevin. Good question. Yeah, look, I mean, we, we've announced price increase, and we're getting price increase. And in fact, if you really looked at what's happened over the last few months, it's been more of a bathtub bottom. It really hasn't declined further. In fact, even the trade publications now are saying that this is a bottom. Believe me, we absolutely say that this is a bottom. And, you know, the disruptions for trade routes, that is starting to have an impact, particularly in Europe. So there's a lot of momentum for the start of lifting prices again through Epoxy. It's gonna be slow, though. I think what you'll end up seeing us do is sort of take that bathtub and prop it up a little bit.
You know, I wouldn't expect something really, really fast there, but we're gonna change the slope of that curve.
Kevin McCarthy (Partner)
Okay, that's helpful. And then, curious on EDC, we've seen those prices percolate higher, notwithstanding, you know, weakness in downstream PVC resin. How much headroom is there before you kind of run into that PVC ceiling, so to speak?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Well, look, I mean, particularly the export PVC pricing is not good, and, you know, you've seen EDC lift, but there, there's still a substantial gap left, even when PVC is this low. And that's one of the focuses we've had and one of, you know, the initiatives we've had, is to try to close that gap, and we were never really successful at closing that gap. So there's still room there to move it some more relative to PVC.
Kevin McCarthy (Partner)
Great. Well, that, that's helpful. And if it is the last call, Scott, congrats on all that you've been able to do with the company in less than three years, and look forward to keeping in touch.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah, no, thanks a lot. It's really not me, though. It's this team and this employee group. So thanks.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from David Begleiter of Deutsche Bank. Please go ahead.
David Begleiter (Director)
Thank you. Good morning. Scott, just on the Blue Water Alliance, can you update us on how it performed last year, and what's the expected EBITDA contribution in 2024?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Hey, good morning. Yeah, I mean, look, I, I probably won't, you know, give a forecast of the EBITDA contribution, but I mean, clearly, that does appear indirectly in our, in our financials, and it wasn't a positive contributor in 2023, which was actually the, the expectation, right? It's sort of the first year. There's a lot of purposes for Blue Water. We don't intend for it to be a wild, direct contributor of profit. But the value to ton one and the value in the overall product levels of Olin, you know, is there. I mean, part of our Parlay work that we're doing now, and, you know, we just had that discussion being 25% of our business, is associated with Blue Water.
So, you know, it'll likely improve this year, but it's not gonna be a major direct contributor relative to the size of the rest of our business.
David Begleiter (Director)
Very good. Just again, on Epoxy, what's the path back to mid-cycle earnings, given the amount of oversupply in the marketplace today?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Well, you know, I guess it depends on what you call, you know, mid-cycle in that business, but I'll just say it's a multiyear path, and maybe leave it at that.
David Begleiter (Director)
Thank you very much.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah, sure.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Mike Leithead of Barclays. Please go ahead.
Mike Leithead (Director Equity Research)
Great. Thank you. Good morning. First question on Winchester. You've obviously talked a lot this call, Scott, about the earnings improvement likely this year. Could you first remind us just how big military is relative to your overall kind of sales mix in this business? And second, it is an election year. Does that normally change commercial order patterns, or do you see that impacting at all commercial sales volumes?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Yeah. Hey, good morning. And you know, the military side of that business now has become about as big, you know, in rough terms, as the commercial side of that business. In fact, in the third quarter of 2023, it was actually bigger than the commercial business for the first time in history. So I think a good way to think of it is, it's sort of half and half from a sales perspective. It's not quite as profitable as the commercial business, but that's roughly the sizing of it. Yeah. What was the second part of the question?
Mike Leithead (Director Equity Research)
The presidential election.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Oh, yeah. Yeah, thank you. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, that kind of uncertainty, you know, along with other things that are out there in the marketplace, and I mentioned this challenge on propellant supply to the whole industry, those two things coming together, you know, are likely to cause, you know, a run on ammunition.
Mike Leithead (Director Equity Research)
Got it. Okay. And then second question, I wanted to parse apart one of the comments or bullets you have in the slide deck, slide four, where I think you said customer requests for merchant chlorine has increased. Should we interpret that customers are coming to you asking for more product, but not at a price or an economics you're willing to sell at? Or can you maybe expand upon that a bit?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah, I think the way to interpret that is that when we, you know, pulled back from the market some, just because we're running our initiative, we're not gonna participate in a poor quality market. After we did that, that caused some customers, some not even the same customers that we may have pulled back from, to come ask for more volume. Again, it's just an indication that we can have an impact by taking that kind of action. And it's an indication that we have the opportunity to turn back on some of these assets, though, at a very, very, you know, incremental amount only and do some additional business.
Mike Leithead (Director Equity Research)
Great. Thank you.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yep.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Mike Sison of Wells Fargo. Please go ahead.
Mike Sisson (Client Service Associate)
Hey, guys. Scott, it's been great working with you over the last several years. I guess just to clarify, if you're—you would need to get your operating rates in CAPV between 60%-70%, at some point, maybe the second quarter and beyond, to get to your guidance of $1.3 billion or better. I mean, is demand there to do that? I guess, is the follow-up question, or do you need demand to get better to do that?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Well, I don't know that we need to get back to the levels that you spoke of. I mean, remember, you know, Winchester and Epoxy are gonna do better, and we expect CAPV to do incrementally better as well. I think adding anything back to our rates, maybe below the numbers that you spoke of, gets us there. When you take that in combination with, you know, the fact that, look, we don't have another $100 million penalty from not being able to run our VCM unit for a whole quarter, for example. So when you put those two things together, I don't think we need to get there. By 2025, I think we need to be in the 60s.
Mike Sisson (Client Service Associate)
Got it. And then what— And just curious, what would prevent you from moving your operating itself? I mean, I know the consultants have... You know, they have ECU margins kinda down sequentially. They might not necessarily be right, but, you know, what are you looking— What would prompt you not to be able to raise your operating rates heading into 2Q?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Well, if we weren't having success moving product values, then we would keep running this initiative. But we're having success changing the direction of our product pricing.
Mike Sisson (Client Service Associate)
Got it. Thank you.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yep.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Jeff Zekauskas of JPMorgan. Please go ahead.
Jeff Zekauskas (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst)
Thanks very much. Earlier in the call, you spoke of a large contract that can end in 2030. Did that customer indicate that they didn't wish to renew?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Well, well, hey, Jeff. How you, how you doing?
Jeff Zekauskas (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst)
Hi.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
I mean, what, what I would say is that's the natural expiration of that contract, and we're currently in a dispute with a very significant value lift opportunity. So we'll just have to see where that goes by 2030.
Jeff Zekauskas (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst)
Okay. And then, secondly, can you just compare general demand conditions in the caustic chain to the chlorine chain? And in your curtailment of production, are you making a larger difference to the chlorine side or to the caustic side, and why?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah, yeah. Well, I mean, right, right now, Jeff, the chlorine and chlorine derivative side is weaker for us. So we generally set our participation according to that weaker side, and so we're having an impact. But more than likely, the bigger part of the impact will be on the stronger side, because you end up really shorting that demand profile more. Okay?
Jeff Zekauskas (Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst)
Okay, I understand that. Thank you very much.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Okay, thank you.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Vincent Anderson of Stifel. Please go ahead.
Vincent Anderson (Research Director)
Thanks. Good morning. So, you know, maybe you have a different view, but it looks like China is probably still planning a fair amount of capacity up and down the Epoxy value chain over the next few years. So to me, at least, it would appear that trade protections might be necessary even if we did see some amount of demand recovery. So I guess to turn that into a question, you know, are you still considering trade cases in Epoxy? And how important is sort of your renewed focus on fleshing out your derivative portfolio as a balance to the operating leverage on the base resin assets?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah, yeah. Yeah, sure. I mean, no, we're absolutely doing more than considering. I mean, look, effectively, this is illegal product trade flows coming into both Europe and the U.S., and, you know, this has to be stopped. And for some of the reasons that you said, it's likely to continue. So, you know, we're absolutely gonna pursue that. I think in terms of getting rates up, we've, you know, reduced our on-the-ground capacity quite a bit, and we're using our systems portfolio to get some operating leverage back across our base resin. I think that was the second part of your question.
Vincent Anderson (Research Director)
Yeah, it was. It was.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Okay.
Vincent Anderson (Research Director)
Very helpful. Thank you.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Sure.
Vincent Anderson (Research Director)
If I could ask one other one, maybe too early on this, but, you know, we're reading about the Chinese ramping up capacity of sodium-ion battery production. I'm curious if you've seen any meaningful change in their sodium markets, whether, you know, that's coming from the caustic side or, or maybe they're using soda ash, but just anything you can shed a light on because it's still a bit of a black box on our end.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Yeah, and I, I probably can't help that much on that specific of an item, right? But what I, what I can say is, you know, the, the ramp up of battery production and battery recycling is probably the largest growth item we have across our, you Chlor-Alkali portfolio. There's a demand for more caustic in many of those applications. There's also an additional demand for hydrochloric acid in those as well. So it's probably the premier growth item over the next 10 years in this business.
Vincent Anderson (Research Director)
All right. Well, thanks. Thanks, Scott. I appreciate it.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Sure.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Matthew Blair of TPH. Please go ahead.
Matthew Blair (Managing Director)
Hey, good morning, Scott. So slide eight shows caustic holding as a strong side of the ECU again this quarter. I think in the past, you said you like it when that gap is pretty wide. So could you talk about what you're seeing in the market now, and is that gap widening out, or is it narrowing?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Look, give, give me a little clarification. I missed the gap between what two things?
Matthew Blair (Managing Director)
Oh, the gap between chlorine and caustic in the ECU, and which is the strong side and which is the weak side.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Oh! Yeah, sorry. Sorry. Yeah, I appreciate that. And, I mean, you know, first of all, you know, Olin does do better when, you know, there's a difference in the supply-demand profile on the chlorine side of the ECU versus the caustic side of the ECU. Because just because we can act on one versus the other. The only challenge that we really have is when both are bad and they're equal. You know, that's the hardest profile for Olin to act on. So we don't have a problem with one being weak and one being stronger. That's the way we're set up now. Caustic is stronger, chlorine is weak, but overlaying that is just general weakness, and that's why our earnings are down.
Matthew Blair (Managing Director)
Got it. And then, I thought it was interesting, you mentioned that in general, Winchester is a bright spot and talked about military being a big opportunity. I think the slides mentioned that military demand was actually down a little bit in the fourth quarter, quarter-over-quarter, even, you know, given this period of global instability. What are you seeing in Q1? Is that starting to rebound?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. And I understand your comment. That was just a sequential issue, and it's really only order pattern, you know, related and delivery related. A lot of those deliveries into the military application are very large, and they're very discrete. So that's only an order pattern issue. You know, again, I would just compare year-on-year-on-year, and, you know, there's substantial lifts year-on-year-on-year.
Matthew Blair (Managing Director)
That's really helpful. Thank you.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Sure.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Vincent Andrews of Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead.
Vincent Andrews (Managing Director)
Thank you. Good morning. On the cash taxes, my recollection is that those, that increase was also supposed to be the case last year, and I think you managed to defer into this year. So is, is this year, that, that increase, I think it's $80 million, is that definitive for 2024, or is there some chance to further defer those?
Todd Slater (CFO)
Yeah. Thanks for the question, Vincent, and I wish I could sound very optimistic and say there's a chance to defer. I don't believe that will be the case, and we would expect that that $80 million will be paid out, you know, roughly during the middle of this year.
Vincent Andrews (Managing Director)
Okay. And then also on that same slide nine, in the primary uses for cash flow, the third one being the alliance and JV opportunities, you know, is there sort of a rough amount you could suggest that could go towards those this year or a max amount?
Todd Slater (CFO)
They would be... Vincent, thank you for the question on that. At this point, they would be very small. We do have, you know, a hydrogen joint venture that we do have a little bit more that will be paid during this year. So that is a small number relative....
Vincent Andrews (Managing Director)
Thank you very much.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yep.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from John Roberts of Mizuho. Please go ahead.
John Roberts (Managing Director)
Thank you, and best wishes as well, Scott. I think acetone prices spiked during the quarter. Is that just the normal co-product dynamics with the weak BPA market for epoxies, or is there something else going on there?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah, I mean, principally that's it. You're right. I mean, you know, phenol acetone, co-production, a little bit like chlorine, caustic, and, you know, we, we've sort of transferred some of our model that we run in the ECU world into our phenol acetone production and marketing scheme. And so, you know, you, you've seen us, you know, take advantage of that and get some value out of acetone.
John Roberts (Managing Director)
And then at Lake City, do you think there are any political risks to being able to use the excess capacity for commercial production? The New York Times had a pretty high-profile article during the quarter.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
No, I don't think there's any risk there at all. I mean, what I will say is that, look, I mean, there's always this sort of backdoor play to try to go after the Second Amendment, you know, of the Constitution in the U.S., and, you know, that's what that is. And those kind of things are not likely to be very successful. You know, I just go back to the fact that probably in this country, there's 26,000 gun laws on the books. Still, you know, sport shooting is the largest participant sport in the country, just below exercise, okay? And coming after ammunition, there's probably an unsuccessful road that some might follow there.
John Roberts (Managing Director)
Thank you.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Got it.
Operator (participant)
The next question comes from Roger Spitz of Bank of America. Please go ahead.
Roger Spitz (Managing Director)
Thank you very much. I'm assuming you've idled some of your electrolyzers or perhaps full trains to get to the 50% operating rates. Will there be material restart costs as you move your operating rates up? I guess membranes can be finicky, or you're mainly idling just your asbestos diaphragm electrolyzers.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yeah. Yeah, thanks for the question. No, there's no incremental cost. We can move those up and down rather quickly. And in fact, just a smaller point for you that's pretty interesting is the diaphragm systems relative to the membrane systems are very easy to go up and down. That's an advantage of asbestos diaphragms or-
Roger Spitz (Managing Director)
Thank you.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Other kinds of diaphragms relative to membrane systems. Very easy to turn on and off.
Roger Spitz (Managing Director)
Got it. And then secondly, historically, ammunition sales, commercial ammunition sales have been higher when the Democrats have the administration versus Republicans. You know, do you have any view of how much EBITDA is in Winchester attributed to the fact that we currently have a Democratic administration?
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Well, I would say not really. I would say it's more attributed to the fact that there's, you know, at least 15 million new participants doing sport shooting in this country. And every month, I forget how many, maybe someone will tell me how many months in a row that the NICS background checks have been above 1 million guns a month, but it's like 40 or 50, maybe even more. I just can't remember the number, and that trend continues, and that's driven a lot more participation in the sport.
Roger Spitz (Managing Director)
Very much.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Yep.
Operator (participant)
As there are no further questions, this concludes our question and answer session. I would like to turn the conference back over to Scott Sutton for closing comments.
Scott Sutton (CEO)
Well, I would just say, you know, thanks very much to everybody for attending today. Thank you.
Operator (participant)
Thank you for attending today's presentation. You may now disconnect.