Q4 2023 Earnings Summary
- Progressive aims for unlimited growth without a ceiling, as long as they achieve at least $0.04 of underwriting profit. They leverage diversification across all lines of business and have a strategic plan based on the McKinsey 3 horizons model to capture more market share.
- The company is excited about expanding in Commercial Lines, including entering their 45th state with Florida , and integrating acquisitions like Protective, now rebranded as Progressive Fleet and Specialty.
- Progressive is investing in internal capabilities, increasing claims specialist headcount to handle property claims internally as they grow their property book, enhancing their talent and understanding to better serve customers.
- Increased competition expected in 2024: Progressive anticipates a highly competitive year as competitors re-enter the market, which could pressure its growth and profitability.
- Rate inadequacy in key states: Progressive is not yet rate adequate in important states like New York, New Jersey, and California, and is dependent on regulatory approval for rate increases to achieve profitability goals in these markets.
- Combined ratio above target due to inadequate rates: In 2023, Progressive's combined ratio was above its 96% target because it did not have the right rates and is still working on segmentation, which may continue to impact profitability.
-
Growth Strategy
Q: What's the outlook for growth, and how are you thinking about media spend?
A: Progressive plans to ramp up growth in 2024 by significantly increasing media spend to capitalize on market conditions. They feel confident in their rates and see an opportunity to gain market share as ambient shopping remains high due to competitors still raising rates. The company is also unraveling non-rate underwriting actions taken last year, which should further boost growth. -
Expense Ratio
Q: How will increased media spending impact the expense ratio?
A: While increasing media spend will put pressure on the expense ratio, Progressive emphasizes that they will spend efficiently and focus on reducing non-acquisition expenses over time. They are not targeting a specific expense ratio but are focused on acquiring customers efficiently without compromising incremental returns. -
Competitive Environment
Q: How does the current competitive landscape affect your ability to gain market share?
A: Progressive believes the current environment presents an opportunity to gain market share, especially in the preferred and bundled "Robinsons" market. Competitors are still raising rates, leading to increased shopping, and Progressive feels well-positioned with their rates to attract and retain customers. They are seeing competitors re-enter the market but are confident in their ability to compete effectively. -
Loss Trends
Q: What's your outlook on severity and frequency trends in 2024?
A: The company expects severity trends to moderate, with auto parts inflation nearing 0% and auto services in the mid-single digits. They anticipate frequency to revert to normal declining trends of around 2%, excluding recent anomalies. Progressive will monitor trends closely but feels optimistic about a more benign claims environment. -
Rate Increases
Q: What's the status of rate adequacy in key states?
A: Progressive feels confident in their overall rate adequacy but acknowledges that they are still working to obtain necessary rate increases in certain states like California, New York, and New Jersey. They are in ongoing discussions with regulators and aim to achieve rates that allow them to make at least a 4% underwriting profit. -
Retention and PIF Growth
Q: How are retention levels and policies in force trending?
A: Retention levels are improving and approaching historical highs, which, along with new business, is driving policy in force growth. The company expects retention improvements to continue as rates stabilize and anticipates strong PIF growth over the year. -
Florida Legislative Reforms
Q: Will recent Florida tort reforms affect your strategy in the state?
A: Progressive views the recent Florida legislative reforms positively and expects them to reduce litigation pressures. However, they do not plan to change their de-risking strategy in the state's property market, as they continue to focus on reducing exposure to volatile risks like coastal properties and rentals. -
Reinsurance Program
Q: Are you considering changes to your reinsurance program upon renewal?
A: While final decisions haven't been made, Progressive anticipates maintaining a similar structure in their catastrophe reinsurance program during the June renewal. They have reduced their probable maximum losses due to de-risking the property portfolio, which may decrease the amount of coverage needed. -
Commercial Lines and TNC Business
Q: What's the outlook for the TNC business after recent volatility?
A: Progressive has taken significant rate increases in their Transportation Network Company (TNC) business and feels much better about its profitability. They have strengthened reserves, particularly in states like New Jersey and California, and continue to gain experience that helps them manage the business effectively. -
Claims Environment in Florida
Q: What drove the favorable development in January, particularly in Florida?
A: The favorable development was primarily due to settlements and legislative changes in Florida, including impacts from House Bill reforms affecting glass and other claims. The company is cautiously optimistic about the benefits of the tort reforms but wants to see more data over time.
Research analysts covering PROGRESSIVE CORP/OH/.