PGY Q3 2024: $70M Credit Impairments Weigh on Diversified Loan Growth
- Diversified Funding Structure: The company has optimized its funding by balancing ABS (60%-70% of volume) with alternative sources like forward flows, pass-throughs, and privately managed funds (30%-40%), which lowers risk retention to 2%-3% and improves cost efficiency.
- Robust Growth in Emerging Asset Classes: Strong partnerships and pipeline developments in the point-of-sale segment, notably with major partners like Klarna, position the business to achieve growth comparable to its mature personal loan business.
- Improving Unit Economics and Credit Performance: Record FRLPC of 4.3% company-wide with 6.6% for personal loans, coupled with enhanced underwriting and operational leverage, supports a transition to profitable growth and GAAP net income in 2025.
- Credit Impairment Risk: Executives highlighted that the 2023 vintage has led to significant fair value impairments—with a $70 million charge this quarter—and uncertainty remains regarding the magnitude and timing of additional impairments, which could adversely affect margins if further credit deterioration occurs.
- Declining Conversion Rates: Despite robust application and volume growth, the company reported a conversion rate that has declined to less than 1%, suggesting potential challenges in efficiently translating application volume into profitable loan originations.
- Sensitivity in Funding Structures: The discussion emphasized that Pagaya’s ABS structures are highly sensitive to small changes in credit performance. Even modest shifts can trigger material impairments, which adds volatility to the company’s earnings outlook.
-
Funding Allocation
Q: How is volume allocated across funding sources?
A: Management explained that approximately 60–70% of volume comes from ABS, with the remaining 30–40% from alternatives like pass-throughs and forward flows—all supported by a net risk retention of 2–3%. -
Credit Impairment
Q: What drove Q3 credit impairments?
A: They attributed the impairments to structural sensitivity in the 2023 vintages of ABS, noting that better credit performance and adjustments in the funding structure should limit further losses, with most adjustments expected in Q4. -
Margin Outlook
Q: How will margins converge across products?
A: Executives noted that despite different product durations, margins (with personal loans at 6.6%) are expected to converge into a common range of 3.5–4.5% as newer products mature. -
Expense vs Investment
Q: How balance expenses and growth investments?
A: Management emphasized that their operating expenses remain flat while revenues grow in the high double digits, preserving strong operating leverage and margin expansion without significant additional costs. -
Fair Value Sensitivity
Q: How are fair value marks less sensitive now?
A: They highlighted that structural improvements have reduced risk retention exposure by about 40%, making the balance sheet significantly less sensitive to small credit shifts compared to 2023. -
Point-of-Sale Growth
Q: Will point-of-sale rival personal loans?
A: Executives confirmed that with expanding partnerships—such as with Klarna—and product enhancements, point-of-sale volumes are expected to eventually rival the more mature personal loan segment. -
Conversion Rate Trends
Q: Why is the conversion rate below 1%?
A: Management noted that the conversion rate, currently under 1%, is low due to cautious growth, but expects it to improve naturally as new relationships mature while maintaining profitable credit standards. -
Regulatory Outlook
Q: What is the new administration’s regulatory impact?
A: They anticipate a more constructive regulatory environment that supports consumer credit growth and further technology integration within banks, benefiting the overall business model. -
Approval Rate Changes
Q: Are lending partners raising approval rates?
A: Management observed modest improvements as market conditions become more constructive, though significant changes in approval rates have yet to materialize, keeping growth prudent. -
FRLPC & Risk Retention
Q: How do FRLPC and risk retention compare?
A: They explained that personal loans achieve a 6.6% FRLPC with risk retention of 2–3%, and similar enhanced unit economics are expected to extend to newer asset classes as they scale.
Research analysts covering Pagaya Technologies.