Sign in
RC

RLI CORP (RLI)·Q2 2025 Earnings Summary

Executive Summary

  • Q2 2025 was solid operationally: combined ratio 84.5 and underwriting income of $62.2M, with net investment income up 16% to $39.4M .
  • EPS beat: Operating EPS was $0.84 vs Wall Street consensus $0.78*, and consolidated revenue was $499.8M vs $443.4M consensus*; net EPS was $1.34, aided by $43.5M unrealized equity gains and $15.0M realized gains . Values retrieved from S&P Global.
  • Mixed segment picture: Property remained highly profitable (62.1 combined ratio) despite industry softening; Casualty posted growth but with a higher loss ratio; Surety grew premiums but saw higher acquisition costs due to reinsurance and tech investments .
  • Management emphasized underwriting discipline and selectively pulling back where risk/reward is unattractive; book value per share rose 16% YTD to $18.89, inclusive of dividends .

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

What Went Well

  • Strong underwriting profitability: combined ratio 84.5 and underwriting income $62.2M; favorable prior-year reserve development added $24.4M to underwriting income .
  • Property segment strength: 62.1 combined ratio and $49.5M underwriting income despite a 10% GWP decline; favorable prior-year development (~$10M) and manageable storm losses supported results .
  • Investment tailwinds: Net investment income +16% to $39.4M; total portfolio return 2.9% in Q2; operating cash flow $174.7M supported continued portfolio activity .
  • Quote: “We posted an 85 combined ratio, underscoring our underwriting discipline in a highly competitive market.” – Craig Kliethermes, CEO .

What Went Wrong

  • Top-line pressure in Property: gross premiums written down ~10% amid rate decreases in wind and competitive pressure from MGAs and admitted carriers; earthquake demand in CA also softening .
  • Expense ratio uptick in Property and Surety due to reinsurance purchasing changes and investments in technology and people, pressuring segment expense ratios .
  • Casualty loss environment: continued double-digit loss cost inflation in transportation and elevated severity in auto; management remains cautious with wheels-based exposures and is walking away where rate adequacy is insufficient .

Financial Results

Consolidated Financials vs Prior Periods

MetricQ4 2024Q1 2025Q2 2025
Consolidated Revenue ($USD Millions)$439.1 $407.7 $499.8
Net Investment Income ($USD Millions)$38.8 $36.7 $39.4
Net EPS ($USD)$0.44 $0.68 $1.34
Operating EPS ($USD)$0.41 $0.92 $0.84
Underwriting Income ($USD Millions)$22.2 $70.5 $62.2
Combined Ratio (%)94.4 82.3 84.5

Results vs Wall Street Consensus (S&P Global)

MetricQ4 2024Q1 2025Q2 2025
EPS Consensus Mean ($USD)0.5206*0.8488*0.7829*
EPS Actual ($USD)0.41 0.92 0.84
Revenue Consensus Mean ($USD Millions)435.0*442.0*443.4*
Revenue Actual ($USD Millions)439.1 407.7 499.8

Values retrieved from S&P Global.

Segment Breakdown (Q2 2025 vs Q2 2024)

SegmentUnderwriting Income ($USD Millions) Q2 2024Underwriting Income ($USD Millions) Q2 2025Combined Ratio (%) Q2 2024Combined Ratio (%) Q2 2025
Casualty$10.3 $8.3 95.1 96.5
Property$53.2 $49.5 60.3 62.1
Surety$6.5 $4.4 81.8 87.9
Total$70.0 $62.2 81.5 84.5

KPIs

KPIQ4 2024Q1 2025Q2 2025
Net Premiums Earned ($USD Millions)$397.2 $398.3 $401.9
Net Cash Flow from Operations ($USD Thousands)$128,080 $103,514 $174,719
Book Value Per Share ($USD)$16.59 $17.48 $18.89
Weighted Avg Diluted Shares (000s)92,725 92,528 92,518

Guidance Changes

MetricPeriodPrevious GuidanceCurrent GuidanceChange
Regular Dividend per ShareQ2 2025$0.15 (Q1 2025) $0.16 (paid June 20, 2025) Raised
Reinsurance Program (Surety, Property)Effective Apr 1, 2025N/A (no prior explicit guidance)Purchased more limits in surety; filled co-participations in CAT treaty; increased net expense ratio impact Updated program (qualitative)
Quantitative Revenue/Margin GuidanceFY/Q3None providedNone providedMaintained (no formal guidance)

Earnings Call Themes & Trends

TopicQ4 2024 (Q-2)Q1 2025 (Q-1)Q2 2025 (Current)Trend
Property market/pricingHurricane Milton losses reduced underwriting income by $42.4M; Property full-year CR 68.5% Property CR 57.1; favorable PYD $17.6M Softening E&S property, wind rates -13%; property still at 62.1 CR; exposure down 10% into hurricane season Conditions softening; profitability remains strong but cautious growth
Casualty/wheels-based exposuresEmphasis on underwriting discipline after reserve actions in late 2024 Casualty CR 99.1; PYD $5.1M; rate management ongoing Double-digit loss cost inflation; 14% rate across auto; willingness to walk away on inadequate rates Persistent severity; continued rate and selection focus
Surety investments/expenseYear-end noted investments and steady profitability Surety CR 68.5; PYD $8.3M; strong growth Reinsurance limit increase; tech and people investments raised expense ratio; growth led by commercial surety Growth with higher expenses; portfolio mix shifting away from energy
Investment income/portfolioQ4 2024 net investment income +19%; total return -1.1% for quarter NII +12%; total return 1.3% NII +16%; total return 2.9%; operating cash flow $175M Strengthening returns and income
Construction marketN/A (press release focus)N/AConstruction activity healthy; submissions up double digits; public/private segments supported Stable-to-healthy demand across regions

Management Commentary

  • “We posted an 85 combined ratio, underscoring our underwriting discipline in a highly competitive market... Investment income increased as we put operating cash flow to work in a favorable interest rate environment.” – Craig Kliethermes, CEO .
  • “Operating earnings of $0.84 per share [were] supported by solid underwriting performance and a 16% increase in investment income... Property continued its strong performance, posting a 62 combined ratio.” – Todd Bryant, CFO .
  • “As conditions soften, our underwriters are emphasizing selection and discipline... Entering the hurricane season, our exposure is down 10% from year end.” – Jen Klobnak, COO .
  • “Our underwriters are assuming double-digit loss cost inflation [in transportation]... willing to walk away from the business if they’re not getting the increase they need.” – Craig Kliethermes, CEO .

Q&A Highlights

  • Acquisition costs and expense ratios: Pressure in property and surety from commissions, reinsurance structure, and investments; surety added reinsurance limits April 1, lifting expenses modestly .
  • Pricing and competitive dynamics: ~20 new entrants in E&S property over two years; casualty rates nuanced by coverage tailoring; D&O rates at -2% trending back to flat; work comp pressured .
  • Transportation/casualty severity: Double-digit loss cost inflation; 12–14% rate increases targeted; MGA competition persists; selective underwriting and loss control focus .
  • Tort reform impact: Early signs of benefit in Florida; cautious optimism; potential for broader reforms and litigation finance disclosure to reduce costs over time .
  • Construction end markets: Healthy conditions across regions and segments; submissions up double digits, supporting opportunity pipeline .

Estimates Context

  • Q2 2025: Operating EPS $0.84 vs consensus $0.78* (beat), revenue $499.8M vs consensus $443.4M* (beat) . Values retrieved from S&P Global.
  • Sequential/YoY: Q1 2025 operating EPS $0.92 vs $0.85* (beat); Q4 2024 operating EPS $0.41 vs $0.52* (miss). Revenue: Q1 2025 $407.7M vs $442.0M* (miss); Q4 2024 $439.1M vs $435.0M* (beat) . Values retrieved from S&P Global.
  • Implication: Strong Q2 beat driven by underwriting profitability and investment gains; estimate models may need to reflect continued segment selectivity, expense ratio mix shifts (reinsurance/tech), and the softening property pricing backdrop .

Key Takeaways for Investors

  • Q2 delivered a quality beat on EPS and revenue with an 84.5 combined ratio; underwriting income ($62.2M) and investment income (+16%) underpin durability in earnings .
  • Property profitability remains exceptional despite market softening; expect selective growth and exposure management to sustain margins near cycle peaks .
  • Casualty remains a watch item: legal system abuse and auto severity drive double-digit loss trends; RLI is enforcing rate and selection discipline (expect continued rate actions) .
  • Expense ratios can drift higher due to reinsurance program changes and ongoing investments; monitor surety and property expense trends vs margin retention .
  • Book value compounding is strong (BVPS $18.89, +16% YTD); capital deployment remains shareholder-friendly (regular dividend increased to $0.16) .
  • Near-term trading: Positive setup from Q2 beat and clear discipline narrative; watch hurricane season exposure (down 10% vs YE) and cat activity as key swing factors .
  • Medium-term thesis: Specialty underwriting culture and cycle-aware growth should drive sustained ROE; estimate models should incorporate softer property pricing, cautious casualty trends, and steadily rising investment income yields .