RNR Q4 2024: $750M Wildfire Loss Hits Renewals, Capital Remains Strong
- Strong Underwriting Discipline: Management demonstrated confidence in their underwriting and reserve‐management approach. Despite volatile short‐term loss trends in casualty specialty, executives highlighted that disciplined account selection and proactive reserve adjustments have resulted in healthy loss ratios and profitability, supporting a sustained bull case for the business [Index 12][Index 17].
- Favorable Renewal Environment: The team expects a rebound in pricing as loss‐impacted renewals—particularly in property catastrophe and casualty—adjust with market dynamics. Although early renewals showed some softness, improved client engagement and capacity, especially in the second quarter, should drive better pricing and margins going forward [Index 14][Index 20].
- Robust Capital Position and Reinsurance Structure: Executives noted their strong capital base and well‐capitalized reinsurance vehicles (e.g., DaVinci, Tokyo Millennium) that enable them to absorb large events like the California wildfires while maintaining flexibility. This resilient balance sheet provides confidence in seizing new opportunities even during market volatility [Index 22][Index 25].
- High Underwriting Volatility: Several analysts questioned the elevated casualty specialty combined ratio (over 100% in Q4) and the conservative loss picks, raising concerns that adverse trends or volatility in the general liability line could pressure margins going forward.
- Uncertainty from Catastrophe Losses: The discussion of the California wildfires highlighted a $50 billion market loss estimate with a potential $750 million pretax negative impact, with limited access to data and high uncertainty, suggesting that actual losses could be worse than anticipated.
- Reserve Development Risk: Analysts questioned the adjustments in reserve development for recent accident years, indicating that significant movements in casualty and specialty reserves might result in unexpected future charges, thereby negatively impacting profitability.
-
Wildfire Impact
Q: How will wildfire affect renewals?
A: Management explained that the recent California wildfire, with an insured market loss estimated at $50 billion leading to a pretax impact of about 1.5% (roughly $750 million), will mostly affect loss‐impacted renewals in the second quarter while the 1/1 renewals remain less affected, maintaining a strong outlook. -
Casualty Specialty
Q: Does high Q4 ratio change outlook?
A: They noted that despite a Q4 casualty specialty combined ratio over 100%, the underlying loss ratios of 65–69% and disciplined adjustments using a 10–12% trend keep the forward guidance solid and aligned with expectations. -
Reserve Development
Q: How are recent accident year reserves adjusted?
A: Management clarified that reserve adjustments have been applied especially for accident years from 2019 onward, balancing reserve releases with necessary fortification to manage market volatility while preserving overall portfolio stability. -
Non-California Impact
Q: Will non-CA programs like Florida be affected?
A: Kevin O'Donnell mentioned that while California loss specifics drive some renewal pressures, non-California programs (for example, in Florida impacted by Hurricane Milton) are expected to see rate increases, keeping overall exposure manageable. -
GL Reserve History
Q: How far back do GL reserve changes go?
A: He noted that reserve strengthening primarily covers the period from 2019 to 2022, addressing softer market years while older periods remain largely unaffected, ensuring robust general liability coverage. -
Capital Vehicles
Q: Are extra funds needed for capital vehicles?
A: Management confirmed that vehicles such as DaVinci, Upsilon, and Medici are well-capitalized and structured with ample flexibility, so no additional funding is expected despite the current events. -
Tokyo Millennium
Q: What is the Tokyo Millennium update?
A: They stated that the Tokyo Millennium contract is largely developed with only minimal further development needed, and they remain comfortable with its capacity and stability in the relationship.
Research analysts covering RENAISSANCERE HOLDINGS.