Q1 2024 Earnings Summary
- Strong Cash Flows and Share Buybacks: Shell has delivered over $13 billion of cash flow from operations in the first quarter, enabling consistent share buybacks of at least $3 billion for 10 consecutive quarters, totaling over $40 billion since the Permian deal. This demonstrates Shell's ability to generate significant cash flows and return value to shareholders despite market volatility.
- Strategic Focus on High-Value Assets and Portfolio Optimization: Shell is actively high-grading its portfolio by divesting underperforming assets and focusing on areas where it has a competitive edge, such as deepwater operations and LNG. This includes operational improvements at Shell Polymers Monaca, now running all three trains at robust capacity and implementing strategies to maximize cash generation.
- Resilient Strategy Amid Energy Transition with Growth in LNG: Shell is committed to growing its LNG business by 20% to 30% through to 2030, capitalizing on global demand. The company maintains stable liquid production around 1.4 million barrels per day, focusing on high-margin barrels, ensuring resilience regardless of the pace of the energy transition.
- Volatility in Cash Flows and Earnings Raises Investor Concerns: Shell has displayed significant inconsistency in cash flows, with a 60% variability from last quarter to this quarter, which is higher than peers like Exxon. This unpredictability may raise questions about the company's ability to generate stable cash flows, potentially affecting investor confidence.
- Underperformance in Chemicals and Decarbonization Sectors May Indicate Misallocation of Capital: Despite a significant investment of over $25 billion in the chemicals business, Shell's returns remain modest, potentially due to a challenging margin environment and the inability to earn cost of capital returns on substantial portions of the invested capital. Similarly, the sectors and decarbonization business, which used to deliver $600–$700 million net income per annum, only achieved $20 million in the first quarter, suggesting it may have become an area of experimentation rather than a significant earnings contributor.
- Cost Inflation Could Pressure Capital Spending and Project Delivery: Shell is facing cost inflation in key areas such as LNG and deepwater projects, with inflation rates around 5% and certain categories up to 6%–10%. This inflationary pressure might challenge Shell's efforts to control capital costs and could pose risks to delivering projects on budget and on time, potentially impacting future cash flows and returns.
-
Share Buybacks and Valuation
Q: Will you increase buybacks despite valuation disconnect?
A: Shell has strengthened its balance sheet by $3 billion this quarter due to strong operational performance and lower CapEx. Despite lower cash flows in past quarters, they've consistently conducted $3.5 billion in share buybacks per quarter, totaling ten consecutive quarters with at least $3 billion in buybacks. Management focuses on growing free cash flow per share and sees buybacks as a way to bridge the valuation gap. -
U.S. Relisting Consideration
Q: Are you considering relisting in the U.S.?
A: While acknowledging the growing debate about U.S. relisting, Shell believes that a simple relisting won't address fundamental valuation issues. The company's priority is to focus on performance, discipline, and simplification to grow free cash flow. Relisting is not a live discussion at the moment, but management continues to review all opportunities. -
CapEx Discipline and Inflation
Q: How are you managing CapEx amid inflation?
A: Shell is exercising rigorous capital allocation discipline, aiming to mitigate inflationary pressures. Portfolio-level inflation is around 5%, with some categories at 6–10%. The company remains committed to its CapEx guidance of $22–25 billion and is focusing on cost control and project phasing. -
LNG Trading Outlook
Q: What is the outlook for LNG trading profits?
A: Shell expects LNG demand growth, particularly from Southeast Asia at current price levels. Small changes in supply can have outsized impacts on price due to tight markets. The company leverages its large LNG portfolio and trading capabilities to capture value from market volatility. LNG trading contributes to the mid-to-upper end of the 2–4% gross uplift from Trading and Optimization. -
Upstream Performance Sustainability
Q: Is improved upstream performance sustainable?
A: The improved upstream performance is a result of a multi-year journey enhancing reliability and operational focus across assets. Shell is institutionalizing rigorous operational processes and aligning objectives to maintain consistent performance. -
Portfolio Divestments and High-Grading
Q: What are your plans for divestments?
A: Shell continues to divest non-core and underperforming assets to focus on areas with differentiated capabilities. Recent divestments include the planned sale of Bukom Jurong in Singapore and exit from the power market in China. More divestments are expected as the company high-grades its portfolio. -
Energy Transition Strategy
Q: How do you respond to shareholder resolutions on climate?
A: Shell is committed to a thoughtful and profitable energy transition strategy. Management believes that the "Follow This" resolution is not aligned with the company's approach and could be detrimental to shareholders, customers, and climate goals. The Board unanimously recommends voting against the resolution and supports management's strategy. -
Chemicals Business Challenges
Q: How are you addressing challenges in Chemicals?
A: Shell is making progress by high-grading the Chemicals portfolio, selling underperforming assets, and addressing cost structures. Margins remain challenged, but the company is focusing on maximizing value and stabilizing facilities like Shell Polymers Monaca. -
Oil Production and Consolidation Plans
Q: Will you pursue oil acquisitions amid transition?
A: Shell plans to maintain stable liquids production around 1.4 million barrels per day. The company is open to consolidation opportunities but believes current share price undervalues the company, making buybacks more attractive than acquisitions. Shell focuses on high-return projects and exploring basins where it has a competitive edge. -
Cash Flow Variability
Q: How do you manage cash flow variability?
A: Shell recognizes quarterly cash flow can be volatile but emphasizes consistent shareholder returns through buybacks and dividends. The company has delivered over $40 billion in share buybacks since the Permian deal, demonstrating confidence in underlying cash flows. -
Namibia Exploration Update
Q: What's new with Namibia exploration?
A: Shell continues its de-risking program in Namibia, drilling exploration and appraisal wells while studying results. The company is not in a rush and aims to ensure sufficient de-risking before significant capital investment. -
Exit from China Power Market
Q: Why are you exiting China's power market?
A: Shell is focusing on markets where it has differentiated capabilities. The company lacked the competitive edge in China's power market but continues its EV charging business there due to strong brand and high utilization rates. -
Operational Cost Savings
Q: How are you achieving cost savings?
A: Shell is simplifying processes, reducing standards by 70%, and empowering assets to make fit-for-purpose decisions. The company is seeing good progress in structural cost reductions while navigating inflationary pressures. -
Monaca Plant Performance
Q: How is the Monaca plant improving?
A: Shell Polymers Monaca is now operating all three trains, focusing on reliable operations and maximizing polyethylene throughput. The team adjusted strategies to optimize production and generate cash despite market conditions. -
Capital Expenditures Timing
Q: Why was CapEx low this quarter?
A: Lower CapEx in Q1 is due to timing and phasing of payments. Shell maintains its full-year CapEx guidance and continues disciplined capital spending.
Research analysts covering Shell.