Q4 2024 Earnings Summary
- Steel Dynamics plans to maintain a very active share repurchase program along with increasing dividends, supported by expected increased cash flow and earnings as their growth investments begin to bear fruit in 2025. ,
- The company anticipates higher volumes and increased consumption across their platforms in 2025, driven by positive market factors such as public funding, potential reductions in imports, and a robust construction environment, which should benefit their steel and fabrication businesses.
- Margins in the steel fabrication segment have stabilized at higher levels due to a commercial pricing change, and the company expects these higher margins to continue going forward.
- The company's cash and short-term investments are at low levels, potentially indicating liquidity concerns, especially with a tranche of notes maturing in the second quarter requiring refinancing.
- The lack of imminent large-scale organic growth projects beyond current developments suggests limited future growth opportunities, which may impact the company's long-term revenue growth.
- Steel fabrication volumes in 2024 were lower than pre-COVID levels, indicating potential demand weakness in this segment, which could pressure margins and profitability if the expected improvement does not materialize.
| Metric | YoY Change | Reason |
|---|---|---|
Total Revenue | –8.5% (from $4,233M to $3,872M) | Total revenue declined due to significant decreases in Steel Operations (–9%), Metals Recycling Operations (–20%) and Steel Fabrication Operations (–24%), which more than offset gains from the surge in the Other segment (+60%) and the new Aluminum Operations introduction. |
Steel Operations | –9% (from $3,012.7M to $2,740.6M) | Steel Operations fell primarily from continued pressure on steel pricing and margin compression, reflecting lower realized selling prices and narrowed metal spreads compared to the prior period. |
Metals Recycling Operations | –20% (from $977.8M to $778.1M) | Metals Recycling revenue dropped sharply as softer scrap pricing and reduced domestic demand continued to impact the segment, following similar challenges seen in previous quarters. |
Steel Fabrication Operations | –24% (from $525.2M to $396.5M) | Steel Fabrication declined due to significantly lower average selling prices and reduced shipment volumes as the business normalized from record highs in previous periods, intensifying margin compression. |
Other Segment | +60% (from $179.4M to $287.8M) | The Other segment improved markedly by reducing corporate SG&A and profit-sharing expenses, a trend that built on previous period improvements and led to a 60% surge in revenue. |
Aluminum Operations | New segment: $312.6M in Q4 2024 | Aluminum Operations emerged as a new revenue stream in Q4 2024, reflecting construction and start-up activities with recorded revenues from new facilities, though operations are not yet fully ramped up. |
Non-U.S. Revenue | –16% (from $364.4M to $307.1M) | Non-U.S. revenue declined due to lower realized steel pricing and narrowed metal spreads that impacted export competitiveness, continuing the downward trend from previous quarters. |
Operating Income | –54% (from $518,536K to $237,502K) | Operating income plunged as metal spread contraction and lower realized pricing across segments significantly reduced profitability, compounded by higher SG&A expenses. |
Net Income | Nearly –50% (from $410,590K to $209,872K) | Net income nearly halved owing to contracted margins and lower revenues across key segments, mirroring the decline in operating income and reflecting increased cost pressures. |
Basic EPS | –50% (from 2.68 to 1.36) | Basic EPS dropped in line with the decline in net income, indicating that the cumulative effects of lower segment performance, margin compression, and increased operating challenges have materially impacted shareholder earnings. |
| Metric | Period | Previous Guidance | Current Guidance | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Losses | Q1 2025 | no prior guidance | $30–$35 million | no prior guidance |
Volumes (Steel business) | Q1 2025 | no prior guidance | Seasonally higher volumes | no prior guidance |
Capital expenditures | FY 2025 | $700–$800 million | $500+ million | lowered |
Aluminum rolling mill EBITDA positivity | FY 2025 | Second half of FY 2025 | Second half of FY 2025 | no change |
Aluminum rolling mill utilization | FY 2025 | 50% by end of 2025 | 50% by end of 2025 | no change |
Steel fabrication volumes | FY 2025 | “Anticipated stronger volumes” | “Volumes are expected to increase” | no change |
Steel fabrication margins | FY 2025 | no prior guidance | Margins expected to remain higher on a mid-cycle basis | no prior guidance |
| Metric | Period | Guidance | Actual | Performance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Capital Expenditures | Q4 2024 | $500 million to $550 million | $453 million | Missed |
| Topic | Previous Mentions | Current Period | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
Steel fabrication demand, volumes, and margins | Q3 2024: Strong demand with order backlog extending into Q1 2025 but slightly lower realized pricing. Q2 2024: Healthy backlog for Q4 2024, stable pricing. Q1 2024: Solid backlog into Q3 2024, lower volumes due to seasonality. | Achieved historically strong earnings despite a 4% pricing decline and seasonal volume dip. Margins remained around 37–40% EBITDA, backlog extends well into 2025. | Consistent topic, stable strong performance through 2024, optimism for 2025 |
Sinton plant ramp-up | Q3 2024: 72% utilization in September, aiming for 75% in Q4, expected EBITDA-positive soon. Q2 2024: Held back by outages but targeting 75% utilization in 2H 2024. Q1 2024: Around 70% utilization, resolving power constraints. | Reached 80% utilization by year-end, recently 90%. Addressing quality and yield issues, eyeing profitability by Q2 2025. | Ongoing improvements, nearing stronger performance, discussed each quarter |
Liquidity concerns and note maturities | Q3 2024: $3.1B liquidity, repaid $400M notes due Dec 2024. Q2 2024: $2.7B liquidity, issued $600M of notes. Q1 2024: Ended quarter with $3.1B, no new maturity details. | Maturing notes in Q2 2025 to be refinanced, strong liquidity of $2.2B. | Consistently strong liquidity, proactive refinancing approach |
Aluminum market expansion | Q3 2024: Similar capacity targets, high recycled input advantage. Q2 2024: 650k mt plan with 80–85% recycled content, addressing supply deficit. Q1 2024: 650k mt project featuring slab centers in Mexico & AZ, strong recycling advantages. | 650k mt aluminum facility on track; aiming for 50% capacity by end of 2025; projecting $650–$700M EBITDA. | Consistent updates, major future growth driver |
Trade tensions with Mexico | Q3 2024: Investigations tied to coated steel imports from Mexico and Canada, ensuring fair trade. Q2 2024: Some temporary issues, but stable demand from Mexico. Q1 2024: No direct business impact reported, strong Mexican shipments. | No mention in Q4 2024. | Not discussed this quarter, previously a recurring concern |
Share repurchase and dividend strategies | Q3 2024: $970M YTD repurchases, $486M remaining authorization, positive dividend outlook. Q2 2024: $607M repurchases, 8% dividend increase. Q1 2024: $298M repurchases, 8% dividend increase. | Repurchased $295M in Q4 2024 (total $1.2B for the year), solid dividend profile maintained. | Consistent shareholder returns, ongoing buybacks and dividend increases |
Competition from new steel capacity and anti-dumping investigations | Q3 2024: Trade case against coated imports, expecting favorable ITC findings. Q2 2024: Noted new EAF capacity; less direct mention of dumping, some discussion of import pressure. Q1 2024: No mention. | Addressed surge in coated imports; filed trade case, awaiting rulings to reduce unfair imports. | More explicit trade actions in Q4, escalating focus on unfair imports |
Lack of large-scale growth projects beyond 2025 | Q3 2024: No new 3Mt steel mill planned, focusing on value-added expansions and careful aluminum growth. Q2 2024: No similarly large projects beyond aluminum & Sinton. Q1 2024: No mention. | No imminent large-scale builds beyond current projects; evaluating M&A but nothing major planned. | Consistent message, no further mega-projects on the horizon |
Shift in steel fabrication sentiment | Q3 2024: Robust backlog, strong volumes expected for 2025. Q2 2024: Stable backlog and pricing heading into Q4 2024. Q1 2024: Seasonal softness in Q1 with improved bookings by Q2. | Noted a commercial pricing change post-COVID, supporting higher mid-cycle margins. 2024 volumes relatively soft, rebound expected in 2025. | Consistently positive, higher structural margins, near-term seasonality offset by strong outlook |
-
Capital Allocation Priorities
Q: Are there new projects or acquisitions planned for 2025?
A: Management is focused on executing existing growth projects like Sinton and the aluminum mill and does not anticipate any imminent large-scale organic growth or M&A in 2025. They are open to opportunities that make sense but are currently prioritizing execution over new initiatives. In the absence of new projects, they plan to continue active share repurchases and maintain a positive dividend profile, leveraging the expected material free cash flow inflection in 2025. -
Sinton Mill Profitability
Q: Why isn't Sinton more profitable at 80% utilization, and when will profitability improve?
A: Despite reaching 80% utilization in the fourth quarter, Sinton is still in start-up mode with extraordinary costs impacting profitability. These costs are related to reliability improvements, maintenance, and commissioning of downstream units. Management expects profitability to improve as they enhance machine reliability, increase yields and prime rates, and fully commission the finishing lines, anticipating profitability in the second quarter of 2025 and full maturity later in the year. -
Aluminum Mill Ramp-Up
Q: What are the production expectations for the aluminum mill in the next years?
A: The aluminum mill aims to end 2025 at 50% utilization and reach 75% total capability in 2026. The start-up is expected to be rapid due to proven technology and a batch process that allows for flexibility, and management regards it as a fabulous investment with significant returns anticipated. -
Fabrication Segment Margins
Q: Are the current stable high margins in fabrication the new normal?
A: Management believes the industry underwent a commercial change, recognizing the value of engineering and value-added services. They expect margins to remain higher compared to the pre-COVID mid-cycle levels, anticipating increased volumes in 2025 and beyond due to a robust construction environment and increased fixed asset investment. -
UBC Scrap Spreads and Scrap Intensity
Q: Is the tightness in UBC scrap spreads a structural trend, and what's the expected scrap intensity at ADI?
A: Management does not anticipate the current tightness to be the new norm, expecting markets to normalize over time. At Aluminum Dynamics Inc. (ADI), they plan to achieve 95% recycled content for can stock and 60–65% for automotive grades, leveraging OmniSource's advanced sorting and segregation capabilities to be best-in-class. -
Guidance on Steel and Fabrication Volumes
Q: What should we expect for steel and fabrication volumes into Q1?
A: While providing limited guidance, management expects seasonally higher volumes in the first quarter due to some disruptions in the fourth quarter. More importantly, they focus on increased consumption and volume in 2025, driven by public funding, a robust construction environment in the second half, and potential administrative support. -
Trade Case and Import Situation
Q: Why was the hot-dip galvanized trade case investigation delayed, and have imports increased ahead of potential tariffs?
A: The delay is a typical procedural event due to the substantial data collection required across 10 different countries. Management has observed an import bump but expects it to subside, anticipating favorable rulings that will remove unnecessary market noise caused by imports seeking to offload excess capacity into the U.S. market. -
Loss Guidance Moving Forward
Q: Will losses continue at $25 million per quarter or increase?
A: Losses are expected to incrementally increase in the first half of the year, with the first quarter projected at $30–35 million, due to ramp-up costs. As operations begin to offset expenses starting in June, losses are expected to decrease. -
Balance Sheet and Buybacks
Q: Is the current low cash position appropriate, and will buybacks remain steady?
A: Management feels very comfortable with their capital structure and plans to maintain a very active share repurchase program along with increasing dividends. They anticipate significant cash flow generation from recent investments starting in 2025, supporting continued buybacks despite the current cash position. -
Weather Impact on Operations
Q: Have there been any weather impacts on operations or demand this year?
A: Weather conditions have tightened scrap availability and affected shipping, but the impact has been minimal. The company works closely with utilities and communities to mitigate any emergencies, and continues to manage cold weather challenges effectively.
Research analysts covering STEEL DYNAMICS.