Gale Klappa
About Gale E. Klappa
Gale E. Klappa, age 74, is Non-Executive Chairman of WEC Energy Group (since May 2024) and has served on the Board since 2003. He previously served as CEO (2004–2016; 2017–2019) and Executive Chairman (2019–May 2024), bringing 45+ years in public utilities, including senior leadership roles at The Southern Company; he led WEC’s 2015 acquisition of Integrys Energy Group that expanded the footprint to four states . He is not an independent director (non-independent due to prior employment) .
Past Roles
| Organization | Role | Tenure | Committees/Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| WEC Energy Group | Non-Executive Chairman | May 2024–present | Leads Board oversight; separate from CEO structure |
| WEC Energy Group | Executive Chairman; CEO; President | Executive Chairman: Feb 2019–May 2024; CEO: 2004–May 2016 and Oct 2017–Feb 2019; President: 2003–Aug 2013 | Led 2015 Integrys acquisition nearly doubling customers and footprint |
| Wisconsin Electric Power Co. (subsidiary) | Chairman; CEO; President; Director | Various: 2003–2016; 2018–2019; 2003–2015 | Oversight of utility operations in core jurisdiction |
External Roles
| Organization | Role | Tenure | Committees/Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Associated Banc-Corp | Director | 2016–present | Not disclosed in proxy |
| Badger Meter, Inc. | Director | 2010–Apr 2023 (ended) | Not disclosed in proxy |
Board Governance
- Independence: Not independent due to prior WEC employment .
- Current Board role: Non-Executive Chairman (since May 2024); Executive Committee Chair .
- Attendance and engagement: In 2024, the Board met 7 times; all directors attended >75% of meetings; average attendance >98.7%; executive sessions held at every regular Board and most committee meetings .
- Board leadership balance: Separate CEO and Chair with Independent Lead Director (Tom Lane) and defined duties .
Fixed Compensation
| Component | 2024 Program/Amount | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Director Cash Retainer | $120,000 | For non-management directors |
| Annual Equity Retainer (Directors) | $160,000 in restricted stock (1-year vest) | For non-management directors |
| Additional Retainer – Non-Executive Chairman | $187,500 | Approved Jan 2024; prorated for 2024; no restricted stock for Chair role in 2024 |
| 2024 Salary (as NEO through 5/9/24) | $646,623 | Includes $197,679 pro rata Board fees; reflects Executive Chairman service through 5/9/24 |
| 2024 Non-Equity Incentive (STPP) | $1,269,794 | Prorated for transition; based on Company performance |
| 2024 Stock Awards (Grant-Date Fair Value) | $6,278,171 | Includes accelerated vesting of 30,539 RS shares at retirement; acceleration value $2,598,869 |
| 2024 Option Awards (Grant-Date Fair Value) | $702,302 | Annual grant 1/2/24; see details below |
| Change in Pension Value & NQDC Earnings | $1,294,870 | 2024 aggregate of pension value change and above-market EDCP/NQRSP earnings |
| All Other Compensation | $293,648 | Includes $24,893 for Directors’ Charitable Awards Program; other items per footnotes |
Pension/SERP/ILA details (benefit status and 2024 payments):
- Present value of accumulated benefits at 12/31/2024: WEC Plan $555,112; SERP $2,410,753; Individual Letter Agreement (ILA) $16,907,467; 2024 payments: WEC Plan $35,425; SERP $263,731; ILA $1,849,639. ILA service credit totaled 38.67 years; WEC may be obligated if a prior employer cannot pay its portion .
Performance Compensation
| Short-Term (STPP) | Details |
|---|---|
| Target as % of Salary | 140% (prorated to 5/9/24) |
| Actual Payout | 196% of base salary (prorated) |
| 2024 STPP Metrics & Weights | EPS (75% for corporate officers), Cash Flow (25%); for certain utility roles, additional state utility NI metric (not applicable to Klappa) |
| 2024 EPS Goal Grid | $4.80 (25%); $4.82 (50%); $4.85 (100%); $4.86 (135%); $4.88 (200%); payout linear in between |
| 2024 Cash Flow (Adjusted CFO) Goal Grid ($mm) | $2,325 (25%); $2,375 (50%); $2,425 (100%); $2,475 (135%); $2,550 (200%) |
| 2024 Results vs Goals | Adjusted EPS $4.88; Adjusted CFO $3,228mm → both at maximum payout; operational/social modifiers added +7.5% for other NEOs; overall STPP paid strong; Klappa award prorated |
| Long-Term Incentives (2024 awards) | Grant detail | Vesting/Terms |
|---|---|---|
| Performance Units (target #) | 12,724 units (2024 cycle) | 3-year performance; settled in cash; metrics: TSR vs custom utility peers (55%) and weighted-average authorized ROE (45%); P/E ratio modifier up to +25%, max overall 200% |
| Stock Options (#; exercise price; term) | 43,352 options; $85.045; 10 years | Granted 1/2/2024; standard vest 100% at 3 years; fully vested at his retirement per plan |
| Restricted Stock (#) | 30,539 sh (granted 1/2/2024) | One-year vest; vesting accelerated at retirement 5/9/2024; acceleration fair value $2,598,869 |
Compensation structure practices and controls:
- Clawback: NYSE/Rule 10D-1 compliant recoupment policy for restatements; additional recovery for “for cause” or restrictive covenant violations .
- Hedging/pledging: Prohibited for directors and employees; limited trading windows with pre-clearance .
- Change-in-control: Equity vests upon qualifying termination within 24 months post-CIC; performance units vest at target upon such termination; SERP lump sum if terminated within 18 months of CIC; no individual executive employment severance agreements .
- Say-on-pay: 94.3% approval in 2024; broad investor engagement with ~50% of outstanding stock .
Other Directorships & Interlocks
| Company | Role | Potential Interlock/Conflict Disclosure |
|---|---|---|
| Associated Banc-Corp | Director (since 2016) | No related-party transactions requiring disclosure since Jan 1, 2024 |
| Badger Meter, Inc. | Director (2010–Apr 2023) | Ended 2023; no related-party transactions requiring disclosure since Jan 1, 2024 |
| Compensation Committee Interlocks | None reported for WEC’s Compensation Committee in 2024 | “None” stated for interlocks/insider participation |
Expertise & Qualifications
- 45+ years in public utility industry; senior executive experience at WEC and The Southern Company .
- Led WEC’s strategic combination with Integrys (2015), expanding scale and geographic footprint .
- Governance and public company board experience (Associated Banc-Corp; past Badger Meter) .
Equity Ownership
| Holder | Shares Owned | Options Exercisable within 60 Days | Total Beneficial Ownership | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gale E. Klappa | 279,242 | 354,046 | 633,288 | None of directors/NEOs’ shares are pledged; no one owns >1% |
| Stock Ownership Guideline (Directors) | 5x annual cash retainer to be met within 5 years | — | — | Director guideline applies; policy prohibits pledging/hedging |
Board Governance
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Committee Assignments | Executive Committee (Chair) |
| Independence | Not independent due to prior employment |
| Attendance | All directors met >75% threshold; average >98.7% attendance in 2024 |
| Executive Sessions | Held at every regular Board and most committee meetings |
| Lead Independent Director | Thomas K. Lane; defined responsibilities; elected May 2023 |
Governance Assessment
-
Positives
- Substantial utility leadership depth; successful major M&A execution; long board tenure supports continuity .
- Strong board processes: separate Chair/CEO, independent Lead Director, regular executive sessions, robust evaluation and education .
- Director ownership guideline and prohibition on hedging/pledging support alignment; no shares pledged; no related-party transactions since Jan 1, 2024 .
- Compensation controls: clawback policy, defined CIC treatment, no executive employment severance agreements; high say-on-pay support (94.3%) .
-
Risk indicators and potential red flags
- Independence: As Non-Executive Chair, Klappa is not independent; Board mitigates with an Independent Lead Director but investors may scrutinize independence of the Chair .
- Discretion/award modifications: 2022 Performance Unit Plan peer TSR calculations were adjusted for certain peers (Duke, Xcel) to address plan design effects, increasing vesting to 112.9% with ROE adjustments; use of discretion in long-term plan calculations warrants monitoring .
- Accelerated vesting: Restricted stock for Klappa (30,539 shares) accelerated upon retirement in May 2024; while standard for retirement transitions, acceleration increases realized pay and should be monitored for precedent .
- Additional Chair retainer: Non-Executive Chair receives an incremental $187,500 retainer; typical in market but adds cash component to director pay; equity alignment for Chair role in 2024 was not granted due to mid-year transition .
No related-party transactions requiring disclosure were reported since January 1, 2024, and Compensation Committee interlocks were “none” for 2024 .
Fixed Compensation (detail table)
| Metric (USD) | 2024 Amount |
|---|---|
| Salary (Executive Chairman through 5/9/24; includes pro rata Board fees) | $646,623 |
| Non-Executive Chair Cash Retainer (annualized; prorated in 2024) | $187,500 |
| Director Cash Retainer (annualized) | $120,000 |
| Director Equity Retainer (annualized; not granted for Chair role in 2024) | $160,000 |
| All Other Compensation (includes $24,893 for Directors’ Charitable Awards Program) | $293,648 |
Performance Compensation (detail table)
| Element | Detail | 2024 |
|---|---|---|
| STPP Target | % of Salary | 140% (prorated to 5/9/24) |
| STPP Payout | % of Salary | 196% (prorated) |
| LTI – Performance Units | Target units | 12,724 units |
| LTI – Stock Options | #; Exercise Price; Term; Vesting | 43,352; $85.045; 10 yrs; 100% at 3 yrs (vested at retirement) |
| LTI – Restricted Stock | #; Vesting | 30,539; 1-yr vest; accelerated 5/9/24; acceleration value $2,598,869 |
2024 STPP Metric Weights and Thresholds (Company-wide)
| Metric | Weight | Threshold → Target → Max |
|---|---|---|
| Adjusted EPS | 75% | $4.80 (25%) → $4.85 (100%) → $4.88 (200%) |
| Adjusted Cash From Operations | 25% | $2,325mm (25%) → $2,425mm (100%) → $2,550mm (200%) |
| 2024 Outcome | — | Adjusted EPS $4.88; Adjusted CFO $3,228mm → Max on both |
2024 PUP (LTI) Metric Design
| Measure | Weight | Payout Curve/Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 3-year TSR vs peers | 55% | 25th percentile → 25%; 50th → 100%; 85th → 200%; linear interpolation |
| Authorized ROE (weighted avg.) | 45% | <9.27%→0%; 9.27%→25%; 9.42%→100%; ≥9.57%→200%; annual calc and averaged |
| P/E Ratio Modifier | Up to +25% | Additive based on quartile ranking; cannot exceed 200% total |
Note: For 2022 PUP payouts (vested in 2024), the Committee adjusted peer TSR calculations for Duke Energy and Xcel Energy due to plan design effects; combined with ROE adjustments, vesting was 112.9% .
Equity Ownership
| Ownership Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Beneficial shares | 279,242 shares |
| Options exercisable within 60 days | 354,046 options |
| Total beneficial ownership | 633,288 shares/options; less than 1% of outstanding |
| Pledged shares | None; company prohibits pledging |
Governance Assessment Summary
- Overall, Klappa brings deep sector expertise and continuity as Non-Executive Chair, but his non-independent status, equity acceleration, and the Committee’s prior adjustments in TSR calculations warrant continued monitoring for potential misalignment or precedent-setting discretion. Positive indicators include strong board processes, robust compensation governance (clawback, anti-hedging), no related-party transactions, and sustained shareholder support for pay programs .