Sign in

    Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. (AJG)

    Q4 2023 Summary

    Published Jan 10, 2025, 5:10 PM UTC
    Initial Price$227.00October 1, 2023
    Final Price$224.88December 31, 2023
    Price Change$-2.12
    % Change-0.93%

    What went well

    • AJG is actively expanding through strategic acquisitions, including the recent purchase of a $60 million revenue disability business in Australia, enhancing their risk management capabilities and contributing to growth.
    • Strong performance and expectations in reinsurance and specialty segments, with AJG projecting these businesses to be at the upper end of the 7% to 9% organic growth range in 2024, benefiting from increased demand and pricing, and limited competition able to match their capabilities. ,
    • Superior book of business driving increased contingent revenues, with contingent revenues up 30% in the quarter, indicating that AJG's book of business is superior to the competition.

    What went wrong

    • Arthur J. Gallagher’s growth in Canada has decelerated from double-digit organic growth to around 5%, potentially indicating market saturation or increased competition.
    • The company's benefits business is expected to grow at the lower end of the 7% to 9% range, suggesting slower growth in that segment compared to others.
    • Reinsurance rate increases may not be as strong as the previous year, which could limit organic growth in that segment.

    Q&A Summary

    1. Organic Growth Guidance
      Q: What assumptions underlie the 7%-9% organic growth guidance?
      A: The 7%-9% organic growth guidance for 2024 assumes current pricing and exposure levels remain consistent throughout the year. Not all business units are expected to be within this range; benefits may be at the lower end, while reinsurance and specialty could be at the higher end. Growth is expected to come roughly equally from new business, rate increases, and exposure growth. Benefits might grow closer to 7%, while reinsurance and specialty could be at 9% or above (see , , ).

    2. Reinsurance Market Outlook
      Q: How is the reinsurance market evolving, and what is the expected impact?
      A: After navigating a challenging market last year, the company sees continued strength in reinsurance. Pricing remains firm with increased demand. Approximately 45% of reinsurance business is booked on January 1st, and the favorable market conditions are expected to support growth opportunities in 2024 (see ).

    3. M&A Strategy and Impact
      Q: Has the acquisition landscape changed, and how are recent acquisitions performing?
      A: The company continues successful acquisitions, including larger bank-owned brokers. Recent acquisitions like Buck are showing strong organic growth. These acquisitions bring valuable talent and expertise, energizing teams—a phenomenon termed the "Gallagher effect"—and creating immediate growth opportunities (see , ).

    4. Interest Rate Sensitivity
      Q: How sensitive is interest income to potential Fed rate cuts?
      A: For every 25 basis point rate cut by the Fed, interest income could decrease by $5 million per year. Approximately 45% of interest income is from the U.S., with the remainder from international operations, so global central bank policies also impact interest income (see , ).

    5. Casualty Market Outlook
      Q: What is the outlook for casualty pricing and reserves?
      A: Inflation may impact casualty reserves set during periods of low inflation. Carriers are concerned about reserve adequacy, which may lead to price increases over several years as they adjust to inflationary pressures and address potential reserve shortfalls (see ).

    6. Contingent Commissions
      Q: How did contingent revenues perform, and what is the outlook?
      A: Contingent revenues increased by 30% in the quarter, slightly exceeding expectations due to strong underwriting results. For 2024, contingent revenues are expected to grow within the overall 7%-9% organic growth guidance (see , ).

    7. Risk Management Growth
      Q: Where is the most growth in claims management coming from?
      A: Growth is driven by large risk management accounts and outsourced claims from insurance companies, both large and regional. Outsourcing claims to the company leads to superior outcomes and can improve insurers' ROE by up to 2 points, contributing to strong performance in the Risk Management segment (see , ).

    8. Operating Margins
      Q: Did incentive comp timing affect Brokerage margins, and what's the impact?
      A: There was slight favorable timing in incentive compensation expenses, but it was anticipated and had minimal impact on margins—less than one percentage point—and was included in prior margin expansion guidance (see ).

    9. Use of AI and Centers of Excellence
      Q: Any changes in plans for Centers of Excellence and AI deployment?
      A: The company plans to double the number of employees in Centers of Excellence over the next 5-7 years as the business grows. Standardized processes enable effective deployment of AI, enhancing job quality and efficiency for employees (see ).

    10. Earn-out on Willis Re Deal
      Q: Have you reserved to the maximum on the Willis Re earn-out?
      A: Yes, the maximum has effectively been reserved, with about $50 million of accretion to go through the financial statements next year (see , ).

    11. Canadian Market Growth
      Q: Is there a slowdown in Canadian market growth?
      A: The Canadian operations have seen organic growth slow from double digits to around 5%, which is still strong given past performance. This aligns with market shifts, and similar growth levels are expected in 2024 (see , ).

    12. Amortization in Risk Management
      Q: Why is there an increase in amortization of intangibles in Risk Management?
      A: The increase is due to the recent acquisition of a plan manager in Australia, adding $60 million in revenue to the disability business, leading to higher amortization expenses (see ).

    Related Publications