Sign in

    CME Group Inc (CME)

    Q1 2024 Earnings Summary

    Reported on Jan 10, 2025 (Before Market Open)
    Pre-Earnings Price$216.77Last close (Apr 23, 2024)
    Post-Earnings Price$215.63Open (Apr 24, 2024)
    Price Change
    $-1.14(-0.53%)

    What went well

    • Strong growth in energy products: CME Group's energy volumes increased by 16% in the first quarter year-over-year, driven by the fastest growth from buy-side and commercial customers. Non-U.S. energy volume grew by 38%, and energy options volume reached record levels, increasing by 60%. The overall revenue per contract in energy remained strong at $1.33. [[2]]
    • Spectacular rise in metals activity: Metals volumes surged by 76% in April, with the complex reaching its highest daily volume in history at 1.7 million contracts on April 12. The growth was driven by significant participation from both commercial participants and the buy-side across all client segments and regions. All six of CME's asset classes showed strong performance, indicating healthy diversification. [[4]]
    • Record activity in U.S. Treasury futures: The U.S. Treasury futures complex achieved a record average daily volume of 7.8 million contracts in the first quarter. Capital efficiency initiatives, such as the cross-margining program with DTCC, provided clearing members with margin savings of up to 75%-80%, enhancing CME's competitive advantage and attracting increased participation from market participants. [[11]]

    What went wrong

    • Increasing competition in key markets could threaten CME's market share. Analysts expressed concerns about market share trends in the energy markets, particularly in WTI crude oil futures, where ICE may be gaining share. While CME executives stated that they are maintaining or growing market share in competitive markets, the persistence of competition could impact CME's position.
    • Upcoming expenses may pressure margins due to project-based spending. CME maintained its full-year expense guidance despite lower-than-expected Q1 expenses, indicating that expenses are expected to increase in future quarters due to investments in projects like the Google migration and securities clearing. This anticipated ramp-up in spending could impact profit margins.
    • Limited growth in certain business areas amid competitive pressures. The BrokerTec cash rates business and the interest rate swaps business have experienced more limited growth, partly due to competition and changes in market dynamics, such as decreased volatility leading to internalization of flow by clients. This could hinder CME's ability to accelerate growth in these areas.

    Q&A Summary

    1. M&A Plans
      Q: What are your thoughts on potential M&A?
      A: Management stated they are open to M&A opportunities that benefit shareholders and clients but are not actively seeking deals at the moment. They emphasized their strong position to act if the right transaction arises but reiterated that their approach has not changed.

    2. Competition in Rates
      Q: How does FMX's upcoming launch affect CME's rates business?
      A: Management takes all competition seriously but feels confident due to their strong capital efficiencies, including $7–8 billion in daily margin savings through portfolio margining. They believe their offering is attractive, and competitors would need more than a "me-too strategy" to gain traction.

    3. Energy Market Share Trends
      Q: Are you concerned about losing market share in energy markets to ICE?
      A: Management does not see a loss in market share in Q1 and notes that in direct comparisons, CME maintained or grew market share in key benchmarks like WTI and Henry Hub. They highlighted growth in non-U.S. participation, with energy volume up 38% internationally and options volume up 60%.

    4. Launch of Credit Futures
      Q: What is the expected impact of launching credit futures in June?
      A: Management is optimistic about the June 17 launch of credit futures on Bloomberg indices. They see a significant addressable market, given the $90 billion average daily volume in related markets, and expect to offer up to 70% margin offsets against U.S. Treasury futures.

    5. Investment and Expense Timing
      Q: Why did you maintain expense guidance despite lower Q1 spending?
      A: Management expects project-based spending to ramp up over the year, including investments in the Google migration and securities clearing. They also anticipate higher technology costs as they move more into the cloud, aligning with their full-year guidance.

    6. Debt Refinancing and Leverage
      Q: Will you increase debt levels with upcoming refinancing?
      A: Management will evaluate their approach but hasn't made decisions yet. They acknowledge higher current rates compared to past issuances and emphasize their strong investment-grade rating. Leverage could increase for the right M&A opportunity, but they'd balance debt and equity carefully.

    7. Google Cloud Migration
      Q: How is the Google Cloud migration progressing and adding value?
      A: The migration is making good progress, with plans to move clearing, regulatory services, and business intelligence workloads this year . They are developing new data offerings and tools, like transaction cost analysis, and see opportunities for monetization over time .

    8. Market Data Growth Prospects
      Q: What's driving growth in market data revenue, and is it sustainable?
      A: Market data revenue grew to $175 million, up 6%, driven by professional subscriber revenue. While some derived data revenues are episodic, management sees repeatability and continues to work with Google to develop new data solutions.

    9. Treasury Clearing Application Impact
      Q: Does your treasury clearing application affect the DTCC agreement?
      A: Management believes their application does not complicate the relationship with DTCC. They remain committed to offering the best solutions for clients and will proceed based on what's in their best interest when the mandate begins in 2026.

    10. BrokerTec and Interest Rate Swaps Growth
      Q: What are the growth prospects for BrokerTec and interest rate swaps?
      A: BrokerTec experienced lower volumes due to reduced volatility, but U.S. repo activity was up 5% year-over-year to $300 billion daily. Interest rate swaps saw strong activity, especially in Latin American currencies. Management emphasizes the combined strength of their offerings.

    11. Regulatory Risks - Ether as Security
      Q: How would you respond if the SEC declares Ether a security?
      A: Management notes that the CFTC has declared Ether a commodity, under whose jurisdiction they listed Ether futures. They plan to continue offering Ether products unless informed otherwise.

    12. U.S. Treasury Complex Activity
      Q: Is treasury activity peaking, and what's driving it?
      A: Management believes it's premature to say treasury activity has peaked, citing differing opinions on Fed actions and expected issuance growth. They see continued growth opportunities, supported by capital efficiency programs offering 75–80% margin savings.

    13. Commodities and Metals Markets Activity
      Q: What's driving growth in commodities and metals volumes?
      A: Metals activity saw significant increases, with non-U.S. growth up 38% and options volume up 60%. Growth is attributed to heightened global participation and interest in both precious and base metals, reflecting physical market flows.

    14. Cash and Noncash Collateral Rates
      Q: Can you provide an update on collateral rates realized?
      A: Average U.S. cash balances were $76 billion, earning 36 basis points in Q1. Noncash balances averaged $159 billion, earning 10 basis points. April averages remain similar.

    15. CME's Network Size in Interest Rate Futures
      Q: How extensive is your network in rates futures liquidity provision?
      A: While not disclosing specific numbers, management asserts their network is strong and global, with record open interest of over 33 million contracts and more than 3,300 large traders. They emphasize the mix of participants and robust capital efficiencies.

    16. Basis Trading Trends
      Q: How is basis trading expected to progress this year?
      A: Basis trading continues as a significant activity, with clients managing risk using CME's tools. Management highlights the unique position of CME in facilitating these trades and expects continued, but variable, activity.

    17. Customer Base Health
      Q: How is the health of the customer base in commodities?
      A: Management observes strong customer health, with renewed participation from traders previously inactive in metals. All six asset classes are seeing increased activity, indicating robust client engagement.

    Related Publications