Sign in

    PNC Financial Services Group Inc (PNC)

    Q4 2023 Earnings Summary

    Reported on Jan 10, 2025
    Pre-Earnings Price$153.74Last close (Mar 4, 2024)
    Post-Earnings Price$150.38Last close (Mar 6, 2024)
    Price Change
    $-3.36(-2.19%)

    What went well

    • PNC expects continued growth in capital markets and advisory fees in 2024, with strong pipelines and quarterly revenues anticipated to be in the range of the first and fourth quarters of 2023.
    • The bank anticipates loan growth in 2024, expecting average loans to increase 1% and spot loans to rise 3% to 4%, primarily driven by commercial lending in the latter half of the year.
    • PNC is maintaining expense discipline, targeting stable expenses for 2024 even as it continues to invest in key growth initiatives, positioning itself to achieve its financial targets.

    What went wrong

    • Investors are concerned about PNC's potential acquisition strategy, fearing the company might engage in unwise deals that could negatively impact shareholder value.
    • Increased competition from private credit markets may affect PNC's loan growth and returns, as private credit offers higher yields that PNC might not compete with.
    • Uncertainty regarding net interest income due to assumptions on deposit betas and interest rates could negatively impact operating leverage if these assumptions are incorrect.

    Q&A Summary

    1. Net Interest Income Outlook
      Q: How will rate cuts affect your NII outlook?
      A: Our NII is relatively neutral to rate cuts because we've positioned our balance sheet to be interest rate neutral. We expect NII to decline in the first half of the year, trough around the time of the cuts, and then grow back to current levels. We anticipate record NII in 2025 due to the repricing of our fixed-rate assets. The main variable will be deposit pricing behavior as rates change.

    2. Loan Growth Outlook
      Q: What drives your loan growth outlook for 2024?
      A: We project average loan growth of 1% and spot growth of 3–4%, primarily in the commercial segment and mainly in the back half of the year. Consumer loan growth is expected to be modest throughout the year. The uptick in commercial loans is anticipated due to increased utilization and economic activity post a mild recession.

    3. Capital Markets Revenue Growth
      Q: What is your outlook for capital markets revenue in 2024?
      A: We expect capital markets revenue to increase by about 20% year-over-year. This growth is driven by a rebound in our Harris Williams M&A advisory business, supported by strong pipelines. We anticipate quarterly revenues to align with Q1 and Q4 of 2023 levels.

    4. Operating Leverage Guidance
      Q: Can you sustain your negative operating leverage guidance?
      A: We aim for approximately 100 basis points of negative operating leverage in 2024, which compares favorably to peers. We've worked hard to achieve stable expenses year-over-year. Our NII is fairly predictable, and we are confident in our guidance unless significant changes occur in deposit pricing or yield curve dynamics.

    5. Credit Quality and Reserves
      Q: Are you fully reserved for future charge-offs?
      A: Yes, we believe we're fully reserved for expected charge-offs under a mild recession scenario. Our reserves stand at 1.7%, which is appropriate. Charge-offs will occur but won't impact P&L since we've already provisioned for them. If the economy worsens beyond our expectations, we may need to increase reserves.

    6. Deposit Pricing and Betas
      Q: How do you expect deposit costs to change with rate cuts?
      A: We anticipate deposit costs to ease quickly on the commercial and high-end consumer side when rates are cut. However, core consumer deposit rates might continue to drift up even with rate reductions. We expect deposit betas to move down materially right out of the gate with the first rate cut.

    7. M&A Strategy and Scale
      Q: How important is scale, and what's your M&A outlook?
      A: Scale matters more than ever in today's banking industry. We're gaining market share organically but believe we're a natural player in industry consolidation. We're open to M&A opportunities that strengthen our position but won't pursue them at any cost. The regulatory environment affects M&A activity, and certain deals may get approved.

    8. Visa Share Monetization
      Q: What are your plans for your Visa shares?
      A: We hold 3.5 million Visa shares with an unrealized gain of $1.4 billion. Pending a shareholder vote, we might be allowed to monetize up to 50% of our holdings. Once approved, we'll proceed with our monetization plans accordingly.

    9. Swap Portfolio Management
      Q: How are you managing your swap portfolio?
      A: We terminated $3.6 billion in swaps and added new ones as part of regular activities. We're keeping our balance sheet neutral to interest rate movements. We don't see an urgency to deploy funds in the current rate environment and expect opportunities to persist.

    10. Private Credit Competition
      Q: How does private credit competition affect you?
      A: We don't compete directly with private credit lenders focusing on unsecured leveraged lending. Our lending is centered on traditional, secured loans to core clients. While private credit exists, it hasn't significantly impacted our growth. We serve private equity clients in various capacities, and they remain valuable clients.

    Related Publications