Q4 2024 Summary
Published Jan 31, 2025, 4:49 PM UTC- Strong Data Center Demand Driving Growth: Johnson Controls is experiencing significant growth in data center demand, with data center orders more than doubling the sales delivered. Key customers are placing multiyear orders in the hundreds of millions of dollars for cooling solutions, contributing to a record backlog of $13.1 billion.
- Higher Service Attach Rates Enhancing Margins: The service attach rate in the data center vertical is very strong and better than the rest of the portfolio. Customers are increasingly relying on Johnson Controls' capabilities, leading to higher recurring revenue and margin improvement.
- Momentum in Key Verticals Beyond Data Centers: Johnson Controls is seeing strong growth in other key verticals such as health care, hospitals, manufacturing, and new energy sectors like battery manufacturing, which are contributing positively to applied sales and supporting overall growth.
- Upcoming increase in effective tax rate from 12% in fiscal 2025 to potentially 16%-17% in fiscal 2026 due to global tax reforms, leading to higher tax expenses and reduced net income.
- Structural headwinds to free cash flow conversion, including substantial restructuring costs, increased capital expenditures, and pressures from a higher effective tax rate, which may limit the company's ability to generate and convert free cash flow.
- Stranded costs related to the divestiture of the residential and light commercial business, along with significant investments in cybersecurity and IT infrastructure, may result in elevated corporate expenses and impact profitability.
| Metric | Period | Guidance | Actual | Performance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Sales Growth | Q4 2024 | ~7% yoy | -57.58% yoy (from 6,906To 2,928) | Missed |
Segment EBITA Margin | Q4 2024 | ~19% | ~1% (28 ÷ 2,928) | Missed |
Adjusted EPS | Q4 2024 | $1.23 – $1.26 | $0.94 | Missed |
Adjusted EPS | FY 2024 | $3.66 – $3.69 | $2.53 (sum of 0.55+ (-0.41)+ 1.44+ 0.95) | Missed |
| Topic | Previous Mentions | Current Period | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
Data center growth | Consistently cited as growing faster than the rest of the portfolio in Q3, Q2, Q1 (e.g., “10% of sales” and expectations of double-digit growth). | Remains a strong growth driver with double-digit sequential growth, strong service attach rate, and continued capacity expansion. | Consistent, central to future growth. |
China business | Was previously weak in Q3 (–19%), Q2 (–23%), and Q1 (–21%). Gradual improvement signaled in Q3, but still cautious. | Sales in Asia Pacific (includes China) declined 5%, but showed sequential improvement, with orders rebounding 6%. | Sentiment improving from negative to cautious optimism. |
Restructuring plan and cost savings | In Q3, management noted cost-offset actions and further details to be shared; Q1 highlighted simplification and cost structure optimization. No direct mention in Q2 [–]. | Announced a $400 million multiyear restructuring plan, targeting $500 million in annual savings; half the cost in FY2025 free cash flow. | Elevated focus in current period, execution phase. |
Divestitures and portfolio simplification | Q3: Announced sale of Residential and Light Commercial HVAC to Bosch and ADT business to Truelink; ~20% of current sales. Q2/Q1: Discussed exploring divestitures to simplify portfolio. | Proceeding with the residential and light commercial sale to Bosch, closing expected in FY2025; aiming to become a pure-play commercial buildings provider. | Consistent discussion; final details now emerging. |
PFAS settlement costs | Q3: Referenced $750 million settlement with significant insurance coverage, expecting minimal net financial impact. Q2: Settlement split into tranches with partial insurance recovery. | No discussion in Q4 2024. | No longer mentioned in current period. |
CEO succession | Q3: Succession plan initiated, search firm engaged, Oliver to remain Board Chair after transition. Not discussed in Q2; Q1 addressed a CFO transition, not CEO. | The Board is actively considering candidates; update expected in the first half of 2025. | Continuing discussion, but no final successor yet. |
Softer commercial real estate market | No direct mention in Q3 or Q2; Q1 briefly noted commercial headwinds but less specific. | Cited as softer, but office space is being repurposed, creating new opportunities. | Newly introduced emphasis in current period. |
Increased effective tax rate | Not mentioned in Q3 or Q2; Q1 flagged longer-term headwind, possibly high teens. | Expect 12% in FY2025 (up from 11%), plus a 400–500 bps jump in FY2026 to ~16–17%. | More specifics provided, remains a concern. |
Service business momentum | Q3: 9% service growth, major contributor ; Q2: 13% yoy growth ; Q1: mid-single-digit growth. | Double-digit growth in Service; key performance driver across global regions. | Consistently strong across periods. |
Residential HVAC weakness | Q3: Global residential HVAC grew mid-single digits overall. Q2: Low single-digit global decline. Q1: High single-digit decline in North America. | No explicit Q4 mention; overshadowed by the divestiture discussion. | Topic overshadowed by ongoing portfolio actions. |
Record backlog | Q3: $12.9B, +10% yoy ; Q2: $12.6B, +10% yoy ; Q1: $12.1B, +7% yoy. | Reached $13.1B, up 7% yoy; strong visibility into FY2025. | Ongoing improvement each quarter. |
Product quality charges | Q3: No mention; Q2: $33 million charge related to a fire detection firmware issue ; Q1: No mention. | No mention in Q4 2024. | No longer mentioned recently. |
OpenBlue platform | Q3: Integral to data-driven service growth ; Q2: Not mentioned; Q1: Highlighted as a key differentiator for digital building solutions. | No mention in Q4 2024. | Continued importance but not referenced in the latest call. |
Sustainable and smart buildings | Q3: Positioned as the “smart building trifecta” ; Q2: Strategic priority ; Q1: Aligned with OpenBlue vision. | Emphasized focus on energy efficiency, clean electrification, and digital solutions; transforming into a pure-play commercial solutions provider. | Consistent emphasis, remains central to strategy. |
Cyber incident | Q3: Referenced prior Q1 impact ; Q2: Discussed operational disruption recovery ; Q1: Detailed Q1 disruptions. | No direct mention; noted cybersecurity investments. | No longer a focal point, resolved earlier in the year. |
-
Global Products Margins Sustainability
Q: Are high Global Products margins sustainable into FY2025?
A: Management affirms that the elevated margins in Global Products are sustainable, resulting from structural operational efficiencies achieved over the past year. They expect margins to be around 20% in the first half of FY2025 and significantly higher in the second half, with continuous performance at this level or better. Importantly, there were no one-off items contributing to these margins. -
Restructuring Costs and Savings Impact
Q: How will restructuring costs and savings affect FY2025 results?
A: The company plans to incur $400 million in restructuring costs ahead of realizing $500 million in savings. Approximately half of these costs are included in the FY2025 free cash flow guidance, representing a structural headwind for the year. The timing of costs and benefits is linked to the divestiture of the residential and light commercial business, making precise predictions challenging. -
Tax Rate Outlook
Q: What is driving changes in the effective tax rate?
A: The effective tax rate is increasing from about 11% in FY2024 to 12% in FY2025 due to strategic planning around the residential business divestiture, allowing better tax rate management. However, global tax reforms are expected to pressure the rate upward by 400 to 500 basis points in FY2026 and beyond. -
Data Center Growth and Margins
Q: What is the outlook for data center business and its impact on margins?
A: Data centers constitute about 10% of revenue and are experiencing solid double-digit growth. The service attach rate in this vertical is strong and improving, enhancing margins. Data center projects command slightly higher margins due to differentiated solutions and integrated engineering efforts with customers. -
North America Building Solutions Margins
Q: How will margins in North America Building Solutions evolve with changing mix?
A: The mix headwinds from large Systems projects, which have slightly lower margins than the Service business, are expected to diminish. As service revenues from these projects increase, margins should improve throughout FY2025. -
Free Cash Flow Conversion Guidance
Q: What supports the 85% free cash flow conversion guidance, and how will it improve?
A: The 85% conversion rate reflects headwinds from restructuring costs, increased CapEx investments in data center capacity, and the gap between effective and cash tax rates. Improvements are expected from better trade working capital management. Over time, the company aims to exceed the 85% conversion rate. -
First Quarter Growth Expectations
Q: Why is Q1 organic growth guided at mid-single digits despite strong orders?
A: Due to the timing of large orders and strong Q4 performance in data centers and decarbonization projects, Q1 growth is expected at mid-single digits. North America may perform slightly above this, while EMEA/LA, APAC, and Global Products will be in line or slightly lower. -
CEO Succession Plan
Q: What is the status of the CEO succession process?
A: The Board is actively considering an impressive list of internal and external candidates to succeed the CEO. An update is expected in the first half of calendar year 2025. -
Applied Sales in Other Verticals
Q: What trends are observed in applied sales beyond data centers?
A: Strong growth is seen in health care, hospitals, manufacturing, and new energy sectors like battery manufacturing. Opportunities also arise from repurposing commercial real estate spaces post-pandemic. -
Corporate Expenses and Share Buybacks
Q: How are corporate expenses and share repurchases expected to change?
A: Corporate expenses remain flat year-over-year at around $430 million, with investments in cybersecurity and IT offsetting cost reductions. Share buybacks will continue as usual, returning 100% of free cash flow to shareholders, without assuming deployment of proceeds from the residential business sale in the FY2025 guidance. -
Indirect Revenue Mix and Market Exposure
Q: What is the composition of indirect revenue and its market exposure?
A: The company utilizes indirect channels to address mid- to low-end market segments where direct value selling is less feasible. This approach complements their direct efforts, ensuring full market share entitlement across all segments. -
Backlog Expectations and Order Growth
Q: Will backlog levels decrease or remain consistent through FY2025?
A: Backlog is expected to continue growing, supported by a robust pipeline of opportunities, particularly in data centers. This underpins confidence in achieving mid-single-digit revenue growth, drawing revenue from this strong backlog. -
Clarification on Global Products Revenues and Margins
Q: What are the underlying revenues and margins for Global Products?
A: The Global Products segment has revenues slightly less than $5 billion, with margins in the high 20% range on a pro forma basis. Management expects to leverage volume further to enhance margins. -
Service Attachment Rate in Data Centers
Q: How does the service attachment rate in data centers compare to traditional buildings?
A: The service attachment rate in data centers is strong and slightly better than in the overall portfolio. This improvement is due to increased complexity and customers recognizing the value of comprehensive service offerings, leading to better margins. -
Pricing Power in Data Centers
Q: How does pricing power in data centers compare to traditional segments?
A: Pricing power in data centers is slightly higher owing to the complexity and engineered solutions required. By embedding their engineering teams with customers to address higher-value challenges, the company can command better pricing and margins than in traditional applied equipment. -
Details on Free Cash Flow
Q: Does the free cash flow guidance include tax payments on divestitures, and what changes are expected?
A: The free cash flow conversion guidance does not include tax payments on divestitures. The restructuring benefits are not expected to be material to the FY2025 guidance. The cost-out program focuses on simplifying operations and improving customer experience, with ongoing updates as changes are implemented.