William Franke
Chair of the Board at ULCC
Board
About William A. Franke
William A. Franke (age 87) is Chair of Frontier Group Holdings’ Board, serving since December 2013. He is managing member of Indigo Partners LLC (air transportation-focused private equity) and previously chaired America West Airlines (Chair 1992–2001; CEO 1993–2001). He holds a B.A. and LLB from Stanford University and honorary doctorates from Northern Arizona University and the University of Montana.
Past Roles
| Organization | Role | Tenure | Committees/Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| America West Airlines | Chair; CEO | Chair: 1992–2001; CEO: 1993–2001 | Led airline later absorbed into a predecessor of American Airlines |
| Spirit Airlines | Chair | 2006–2013 | Low-cost carrier leadership; board oversight |
| Tiger Aviation (Singapore) | Chair | 2004–2009 | Asia LCC expansion |
| Alpargatas S.A.I.C. | Director | 1996–2007 | Argentina-based footwear/textiles |
| Phelps Dodge (Freeport-McMoRan) | Director; Lead outside director | 1980–2007 | Mining; lead outside director for several years |
| ON Semiconductor; Valley National; Southwest Forest Industries; Circle K; Beringer Wine Estates | Director (prior) | Various | Broad industrial/consumer governance experience |
External Roles
| Organization | Role | Tenure | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wizz Air Holdings Plc | Chair | Since Feb 2005 | Europe-based airline |
| JetSMART Holdings Limited | Chair | Since Feb 2017 | South America-based airline |
| APiJET, LLC | Chair | Since Nov 2020 | Airline analytics software |
| Lynx Air Holdings Corporation | Chair (former) | Dec 2018–Dec 2023 | Canada-based airline |
| Volaris (Concesionaria Vuela Cía de Aviación) | Director (former), Honorary director | Director: Jul 2010–Apr 2023; Honorary since Apr 2023 | Mexico-based airline; ULCC codeshare partner |
Board Governance
- Current committee assignments: None; Chair of the Board; served on Nominating & Corporate Governance through March 29, 2024.
- Independence: Not independent due to affiliation with Indigo Partners, which provides management services to Frontier.
- Lead Independent Director: Robert J. Genise; independent directors hold regular executive sessions.
- Attendance: Board met 6 times in 2024; each director attended at least 75% of Board and applicable committee meetings.
- Classified board: Franke is a Class I director, term expiring at the 2025 annual meeting cycle; nominees proposed for 2028 for Class I at 2025 meeting.
Fixed Compensation
| Component (2024) | Amount/Details |
|---|---|
| Annual cash retainer | $120,000 |
| RSUs | Grant date May 25, 2024; 24,955 RSUs; grant-date fair value $140,000; vest on May 15, 2025 (or earlier of next annual meeting) |
| Travel benefits (UATP) | $13,750 annual travel bank as Chair; post-service flight benefits for life after ≥5 years of service |
Performance Compensation
| Equity Award | Shares | Grant-date Fair Value | Vesting | Performance Metrics |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 Director RSUs | 24,955 | $140,000 | Vest May 15, 2025 (time-based) | None disclosed (no performance conditions for director equity) |
No option awards or performance-based equity for directors were disclosed for 2024; directors held RSUs only.
Other Directorships & Interlocks
| Entity | Relationship to ULCC | Interlock/Transaction | Potential Conflict Vector |
|---|---|---|---|
| Indigo Partners LLC | Provides management services to ULCC under Professional Services Agreement ($375,000 quarterly; ~$2M in 2024) | Franke is managing member; ULCC pays fees and indemnifies Indigo Partners | Governance independence; related-party fees; influence over strategy |
| Volaris (Mexico) | Codeshare agreement with ULCC since 2018 | Franke honorary director; ULCC directors Andrew Broderick and Brian H. Franke serve on Volaris board (Brian is chair) | Business dealings with entity where ULCC directors have roles; oversight rigor for related-party transactions |
| Corporate Opportunity Waiver | Certificate of Incorporation renounces ULCC’s interest in business opportunities presented to Indigo/affiliates | Allows Indigo-affiliated directors to engage in competitive investments without duty to present opportunities to ULCC | Shareholder-unfriendly; heightens conflict risk |
Expertise & Qualifications
- Deep airline and low-cost carrier governance and operating experience across Americas and Europe; extensive private equity leadership in air transportation.
- Financial literacy and prior leadership roles across multiple public boards and industries.
- Education: B.A. and LLB, Stanford; honorary doctorates (Northern Arizona University; University of Montana).
Equity Ownership
| Holder | Shares Beneficially Owned | % of Outstanding | Breakdown/Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| William A. Franke | 99,477,799 | 44% | Includes: 67,303,343 direct; 31,975,180 via Indigo Denver; 116,827 via Indigo Partners LLC; 82,449 spouse; disclaims beneficial ownership except pecuniary interest in Indigo entities/spouse holdings |
| Shares Outstanding (as of Mar 14, 2025) | 227,658,883 | — | Basis for % ownership calculation |
- Hedging policy: Insider Trading Compliance Policy prohibits hedging transactions in company equity (e.g., swaps, collars).
- Pledging: No pledging disclosure specific to Franke found; not disclosed.
- Vested vs unvested/Options: No director option holdings disclosed; director equity is RSUs (time-based).
Say-on-Pay & Shareholder Feedback
| Item (2024 Annual Meeting) | For | Against | Abstain | Broker Non-Votes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Advisory vote on NEO compensation | 188,819,404 | 4,359,226 | 38,616 | 12,582,007 |
Governance Assessment
- Alignment and continuity: Very high “skin-in-the-game” with 44% beneficial ownership, supporting long-term alignment but also potential entrenchment and outsized influence.
- Independence and conflicts: Franke is not independent due to Indigo Partners affiliation; ULCC pays recurring fees to Indigo; corporate opportunity waiver permits Indigo/affiliates to pursue opportunities without duty to ULCC—these are material conflict risk indicators.
- Board structure: Separation of Chair and CEO roles; presence of Lead Independent Director and regular executive sessions are positive governance features.
- Attendance: Meets minimum expectations (≥75% attendance), but not disclosed as exemplary; no specific shortfalls reported.
- Related-party exposure: Codeshare with Volaris while Indigo-affiliated directors sit on Volaris’ board elevates oversight demands on Audit Committee for related-party transactions.
- Compensation mix (director): Predominantly cash retainer plus time-vested RSUs; absence of performance-conditioned equity for directors is typical, but perquisites include travel benefits and lifetime post-service benefits—monitor for optics and cost.
- Charter modernization: 2025 proposal reflects loss of “controlled company” status in 2024 and adds officer exculpation; governance guardrails rely more on independent director leadership and committee rigor given Indigo’s continuing influence.
RED FLAGS
- Corporate opportunities renunciation favoring Indigo/affiliates (risk of diverted opportunities).
- Ongoing management services payments (~$2M in 2024) to Indigo Partners (economic conflict).
- Family relationship on board (William A. Franke is father of director Brian H. Franke).
- Extensive interlocks with counterparties (Volaris codeshare; Indigo-linked boards).
- Non-independence of Chair; reliance on Lead Independent Director to balance influence.
Compensation Committee Analysis (Context)
- Compensation Committee members: Josh T. Connor, Ofelia Kumpf, Nancy L. Lipson, Alejandro D. Wolff; all independent; Willis Towers Watson engaged as independent compensation consultant.
Committee Assignments, Chair Roles, and Expertise (Summary)
- Chair of the Board (Franke); no current committee memberships; prior service on Nominating & Corporate Governance through March 29, 2024. Expertise centers on airline operations, private equity, and governance.
Director Compensation (Detail)
| Year | Fees Earned (Cash) | Stock Awards (RSUs, $) | RSU Shares | Vesting | Travel Bank |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | $120,000 | $140,000 | 24,955 | May 15, 2025 | $13,750 (Chair) |
Meeting Attendance & Engagement
| Metric (2024) | Value |
|---|---|
| Board meetings held | 6 |
| Director attendance | ≥75% each director; 10 directors attended 2024 annual meeting |
| Executive sessions | Regularly held by independent directors |