Robert Mellor
About Robert E. Mellor
Independent director of Coeur Mining, Inc. since 1998; age 81. Background includes service as Chairman and CEO of Building Materials Holding Corp., and current role as Independent Chairman of Monro, Inc. He holds a B.A. in Economics (Westminster College, Missouri) and a J.D. from Southern Methodist University School of Law; core credentials span leadership, risk management, operations, capital markets, M&A, and strategic planning .
Past Roles
| Organization | Role | Tenure | Committees/Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Building Materials Holding Corporation | Chairman, CEO & President; Director | CEO/President 1997–Jan 2010; Director 1991–Jan 2010 | Led a cyclical, capital-intensive business; experience in risk management, operations, M&A and strategy |
| CalAtlantic Group, Inc. | Director | Oct 2015–Feb 2018 (CalAtlantic acquired by Lennar) | Oversight at large homebuilder through merger |
| The Ryland Group, Inc. | Director | 1999–Oct 2015 (merged to form CalAtlantic) | Long-term public board experience in cyclical housing industry |
| Stock Building Supply Holdings, Inc. | Director | Mar 2010–Dec 2015 (merged) | Distribution and manufacturing board oversight |
External Roles
| Organization | Role | Tenure | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monro, Inc. | Independent Chairman; Director; Interim CEO | Director since Aug 2010; Chairman since Jun 2017; Interim CEO Aug 2020–Apr 2021 | Current public company chair; operational leadership during CEO transition |
Board Governance
- Independence: The Board determined Mellor is independent under NYSE standards and Coeur guidelines .
- Committees and Chair roles:
- Nominating & Corporate Governance (NCG): Chair; 5 meetings in 2024 .
- Compensation & Leadership Development (CLD): Member; 6 meetings in 2024 .
- Executive Committee: Member; 0 meetings in 2024 .
- Board attendance: Board met eight times in 2024; each incumbent director attended at least 95% of aggregate Board and committee meetings; seven incumbent directors attended the 2024 Annual Meeting .
- Leadership changes: In May 2024, CEO Mitchell Krebs became Board Chair; J. Kenneth Thompson became Lead Independent Director. Mellor had served as independent Chairman earlier in 2024 and presided over executive sessions while in that role .
- Stockholder engagement: Independent directors (including committee chairs) available for engagement; program summarized in proxy .
Fixed Compensation
-
Director fee framework (2024):
- Annual cash retainer: $90,000
- Annual common stock/deferred stock unit retainer: $100,000
- Lead Independent Director retainer: $25,000 (effective May 2024)
- Committee chair retainers: Audit $25,000; CLD $25,000; EHSCR $25,000; Finance & Technical $20,000; NCG $15,000
- No meeting fees; CEO receives no director compensation
-
Mellor’s 2024 director compensation: | Component | Amount (USD) | |---|---| | Fees earned or paid in cash | $160,875 | | Stock awards (grant date fair value) | $87,029 | | Total | $247,904 |
Note: Mellor received a pro-rated Chairman retainer until May 2024 when he ceased serving as Chairman .
- Director stock awards are fully vested upon grant; no outstanding director options as prior options expired .
Performance Compensation
- No director performance-based incentives disclosed; equity grants are time-based and fully vested on grant. No option repricing; no single-trigger cash severance; no tax gross-ups on perquisites/change-in-control .
Other Directorships & Interlocks
| Company | Role | Public/Private | Potential Interlock/Conflict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monro, Inc. | Chairman; Director; Interim CEO (past) | Public | No related person transactions disclosed at Coeur; industry adjacency minimal (auto services vs. mining) |
- Related person transactions: None since the beginning of 2024 involving directors or executive officers; transactions ≥$120,000 require NCG Committee review under policy .
- Independence review: Board evaluates relationships annually; 2024 independence determinations explicitly considered certain directors’ external boards with whom Coeur did business (not including Mellor) and maintained independence .
Expertise & Qualifications
- Leadership in cyclical industries, risk management, operations, capital markets, M&A, strategic planning; extensive public company board experience .
- Education: B.A., Economics (Westminster College); J.D. (SMU) .
- Recognitions: NACD Directorship 100 (2020) .
Equity Ownership
| Holder | Shares Beneficially Owned | % of Outstanding | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Robert E. Mellor | 290,476 | <1% of 638,384,526 shares | Based on March 5, 2025 data; directors may defer stock into DSUs; Mellor’s stock award in 2024 was $87,029 in value; director awards fully vested; no options outstanding |
- Ownership alignment:
- Stock ownership guidelines: Non-employee directors must hold 5x base annual director cash retainer; five-year phase-in; each director is either in compliance or within the phase-in period .
- Hedging/pledging prohibited; directors may not hold Coeur securities in margin accounts or pledge as collateral .
- Clawback policy applies to incentive compensation for misconduct and restatements (executive officers; board oversight via CLD/Board) .
Governance Assessment
-
Strengths:
- Long-tenured, independent director with deep public board leadership; chairs NCG and serves on CLD and Executive Committee—positions central to board effectiveness, succession, and pay risk oversight .
- High board/committee activity in 2024; strong attendance standard; robust stockholder outreach with independent director participation .
- Director pay structure balanced (cash + equity); ownership guidelines and anti-hedging/pledging policies reinforce alignment; no related-party transactions flagged .
- CLD Committee uses independent compensation consultants (Semler Brossy, Meridian); independence affirmed; mitigates consultant conflicts .
-
Watch items / potential risks:
- Very long tenure (since 1998) and age (81) may raise entrenchment/perception risks; Board explicitly considered tenure and maintained independence determinations given Mellor’s experience across cycles and management teams .
- Time commitments: External chair role at Monro; Coeur overboarding policy limits to four public boards (Mellor within limits); no evidence of overcommitment or attendance shortfalls .
- Leadership transition: Shift from an independent chair structure to CEO-chair model in May 2024—balanced with designation of a Lead Independent Director; Mellor’s prior chair retainer ended with change; continued oversight via NCG chair role .
-
Investor confidence signals:
- Transparent governance practices (majority voting, proxy access, annual director elections, clawback, no poison pill); strong say-on-pay support (>96%) indicating shareholder alignment on compensation governance .