You might also like
CVS Health Corporation is a leading health solutions company that operates across four main segments: Health Care Benefits, Health Services, Pharmacy & Consumer Wellness, and Corporate/Other . The company offers a wide range of health insurance products and services, pharmacy benefit management solutions, and retail pharmacy operations . CVS Health leverages its integrated model to enhance care delivery, improve health outcomes, and reduce health care costs .
- Pharmacy & Consumer Wellness - Operates retail pharmacy services, long-term care pharmacy services, specialty and mail order pharmacy offerings, and front store sales, which include health and wellness products and general merchandise .
- Health Care Benefits - Offers health insurance products and services, including medical, pharmacy, dental, and behavioral health plans, as well as Medicare Advantage and Medicaid management services .
- Health Services - Provides pharmacy benefit management solutions and health care services through medical clinics, virtual platforms, and home-based care, supported by acquisitions like Signify Health and Oak Street Health .
- Corporate/Other - Includes management and administrative expenses and products for which the company no longer solicits new customers .
What went well
- Strong performance in Pharmacy and Consumer Wellness segment: CVS achieved a record-high retail pharmacy script share of 27.3%, up 70+ basis points year-over-year . This growth is attributed to improved service levels, with Net Promoter Score (NPS) levels up hundreds of basis points year-over-year, driving strong prescription growth .
- Strategic initiatives driving margin expansion in 2025: CVS expects margin expansion due to deliberate benefit design changes, exiting underperforming products, and an anticipated $800 million tailwind from improved Star ratings for 2025, with two-thirds of Medicare Advantage members in 4.5-star plans . These actions are aimed at improving profitability and driving margin growth into 2026 .
- Successful rollout of Cost Vantage program: CVS's Cost Vantage program, aimed at addressing reimbursement pressure and transforming pharmaceutical pricing, has over 50% of clients enrolled, with expectations to have 100% of the commercial book signed by the end of the year . This initiative is expected to bring stability to pricing strategies and improve service to members and clients .
What went wrong
- CVS anticipates Medicare Advantage membership disenrollment of 5% to 10% in 2025, due to benefit reductions and exiting underperforming counties, potentially impacting revenue and profitability.
- Unfavorable medical cost trends in the Health Care Benefits segment are expected to reach the highest levels, with these trends projected to persist through Q4 2024.
- Medical Loss Ratios (MLR) are expected to increase significantly, potentially reaching 95.5% in Q4 2024, indicating rising costs and pressure on margins.
Q&A Summary
-
Medicare Advantage Margin Outlook
Q: What's the plan to improve MA margins over years?
A: Management aims to improve Medicare Advantage margins but notes that due to changes from the Inflation Reduction Act affecting the Part D program, their target margin range has shifted from 4%–5% down to 3%–5%. They've restructured benefits to drive margin improvement in 2025 and anticipate further gains into 2026, aided by better Star ratings, with two-thirds of members in 4.5-star plans. -
Exchange Business Losses and Actions
Q: What's happening with the exchange business and future plans?
A: The exchange business faced significant losses in 2024, being a $10 billion block with over 1.9 million members. Growth was too fast, especially among SEP members, and they suffered from unfavorable product mix. They've implemented double-digit rate increases and expect to shrink the book by 20%–25% next year to improve performance. -
Potential PDRs and Financial Impacts
Q: Are there PDRs needed for 2025, and what's the impact?
A: Management does not anticipate needing premium deficiency reserves (PDRs) for individual Medicare or exchange businesses in 2025. However, a PDR might be required for the group Medicare business due to multi-year contracts and less flexibility to improve year-over-year. -
Pharmacy Services Outlook
Q: How is the outlook for pharmacy services next year?
A: After a slow start in 2024, the Health Services segment gained momentum in Q2 and Q3. They're entering a strong selling season, with successes in biosimilar launches and high client satisfaction. Management expects continued strong performance but remains cautious given last year's slow start. -
Signify and Oak Street Performance
Q: Are Signify and Oak Street meeting expectations?
A: Signify had a great year with volumes up 37% year-over-year in Q3. Oak Street performed in line with guidance; while facing Medicare market pressures, they've maintained a risk adjustment headwind below 3%. There's potential for positive tailwinds next year as they grow Aetna membership in clinics. -
Cost Vantage Program Progress
Q: What's the status of the Cost Vantage program?
A: The Cost Vantage program, launched to address reimbursement pressures, now has over 50% of clients enrolled. They expect to have 100% of their commercial book signed by year-end. Management is excited about its potential to transform pharmaceutical pricing and reduce cross-subsidization. -
Medicare Advantage Bids and Disenrollment
Q: How are MA bids affecting membership and margins?
A: Early indicators suggest membership will decline by 5%–10%, mainly in individual and dual-eligible populations. They've made deliberate benefit design changes and exited underperforming areas, impacting nearly 0.5 million members, to improve profitability in 2025. An $800 million tailwind is expected from contracts now rated 4 stars or better.
Guidance Changes
Annual guidance for FY 2024:
- Medicare Advantage membership disenrollment: 5% to 10% (no prior guidance)
Annual guidance for 2025:
- Cost Savings Initiative: Over $500 million (no prior guidance)
No other metrics had updated numeric guidance for comparison.
-
Given that your Health Care Benefits segment may show operating losses in 2024 after generating over $5.5 billion in adjusted operating income in 2023 , what are the primary factors driving this significant decline, and what specific measures are you implementing to return this business to profitability?
-
You acknowledged miscalculations during the 2023 bid process for Medicare Advantage and individual exchange products, which significantly burdened Aetna's current results . How are you adjusting your bid and pricing strategies to prevent similar issues in future cycles, and what oversight mechanisms are being implemented to ensure accuracy?
-
With the anticipated Medicare Advantage membership disenrollment of 5% to 10% due to benefit design changes and reduced supplemental benefits , how do you plan to maintain market competitiveness and member satisfaction while aiming for margin improvement?
-
The individual exchange business is facing higher utilization and may result in negative margins approaching double digits . What are the underlying factors contributing to this underperformance, and what corrective actions are you taking to stabilize and improve this business line?
-
Given that Aetna has been more acutely impacted by industry pressures than others , what structural or operational deficiencies have you identified, and how will the recent leadership changes and operational enhancements address these issues effectively?
Q3 2024 Earnings Call
- Issued Period: Q3 2024
- Guided Period: FY 2024
- Guidance:
- CVS did not provide formal numeric guidance for FY 2024 but offered directional commentary:
- Health Services and Pharmacy and Consumer Wellness Segments: Confidence in performance and momentum.
- Health Care Benefits Segment: Challenges due to elevated utilization and higher acuity.
- Medicare Advantage: Expected membership disenrollment of 5% to 10%.
- Cost Savings Initiative: Expected to generate over $500 million in 2025.
- Leverage and Cash Flow: Aim to return leverage ratio to normalized levels with year-to-date cash flow from operations of approximately $7.2 billion.
- 2025 Outlook: Transition year with expected improvement in Health Care Benefits and Health Services segments .
- CVS did not provide formal numeric guidance for FY 2024 but offered directional commentary:
Q2 2024 Earnings Call
- Issued Period: Q2 2024
- Guided Period: FY 2024
- Guidance:
- Adjusted EPS: $6.40 to $6.65 per share.
- Health Care Benefits Segment:
- Adjusted operating income: $2.25 billion to $2.55 billion.
- Medical benefit ratio (MBR): 90.6% to 90.8%.
- Health Services Segment: Adjusted operating income of at least $7 billion.
- Pharmacy & Consumer Wellness Segment: Adjusted operating income of at least $5.6 billion.
- Cash Flow from Operations: At least $10.5 billion .
Q1 2024 Earnings Call
- Issued Period: Q1 2024
- Guided Period: FY 2024
- Guidance:
- Adjusted EPS: At least $7.
- Health Care Benefits Segment:
- Adjusted operating income: At least $3.6 billion.
- Medical benefit ratio: Approximately 89.8%.
- Health Services Segment: Adjusted operating income of at least $7 billion.
- Pharmacy & Consumer Wellness Segment: Adjusted operating income of at least $5.6 billion.
- Share Count: Approximately 1.265 billion shares.
- Adjusted Tax Rate: Approximately 25.6%.
- Cash Flow from Operations: At least $10.5 billion.
- Medicare Advantage Business: Revenue between $65 billion and $70 billion with significant losses.
- 2025 Preliminary Outlook: Low double-digit adjusted EPS growth .
Q4 2023 Earnings Call
- Issued Period: Q4 2023
- Guided Period: FY 2024
- Guidance:
- Adjusted EPS: At least $8.30.
- Cash Flow from Operations: At least $12 billion.
- Medical Benefit Ratio (MBR): Approximately 87.7%.
- Health Care Benefits Segment: Adjusted operating income of at least $5.4 billion.
- Pharmacy & Consumer Wellness Segment: Adjusted operating income of at least $5.6 billion.
- Health Services Segment: Adjusted operating income of at least $7.4 billion.
- Medicare Advantage Membership: At least 800,000 new members.
- Store Closures: On track to close 900 stores .
Competitors mentioned in the company's latest 10K filing.
- Prime Therapeutics and MedImpact - Competitors in the PBM services market .
- Express Scripts (Cigna Corporation) and OptumRx (UnitedHealth) - PBMs owned by large national health plans .
- Aledade, Centerwell - Competitors in primary care operations .
- Collaborative Health Systems, Evolent Health, Vytalize Health, Stellar Health - Competitors in ACO operations .
- Equality Health, Physicians of Southwest Washington - Geographically focused competitors in ACO operations .
- Matrix Medical Network - Competitor in IHE and related services operations .
- Walgreens, Rite Aid - Competitors in the retail pharmacy business .
- Walmart - Competitor as a discount retailer in the retail pharmacy business .
- Amazon - Competitor as an online retailer in the retail pharmacy business .
- PharMerica - Largest LTC pharmacy competitor nationally .
- COST, DG, DLTR, KR, SYY, TGT, WBA, WMT - Companies included in the S&P 500 Food & Staples Retailing Group Index .
Recent developments and announcements about CVS.
Legal & Compliance
- CVS Health Corporation: A leading health solutions company.
- Glenview Capital Management, LLC: An investment management firm.
- On November 17, 2024, CVS Health Corporation entered into a confidentiality agreement with Glenview Capital Management. This agreement involves the sharing of CVS's confidential information with Glenview and imposes confidentiality and related obligations on Glenview and its affiliates and representatives .
- The agreement also includes the appointment of four new members to the CVS Board of Directors: Leslie Norwalk, Larry Robbins, Guy Sansone, and Doug Shulman. These appointments followed discussions with Glenview Capital Management .
- The new directors will be nominated for election at CVS's 2025 annual meeting of stockholders, and CVS will use its best efforts to ensure their election .
- The agreement includes customary standstill restrictions and non-disparagement obligations, which remain in effect until the thirtieth day prior to the commencement of the stockholder director nomination window for CVS's 2026 annual meeting of stockholders .
- The confidentiality agreement will be filed on a Form 8-K with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission .
- The appointment of new board members could bring new perspectives and expertise, potentially leading to improved financial and operational performance .
- The agreement to increase the size of the board and appoint new members may also impact the company's governance structure and decision-making processes .
- The confidentiality and standstill provisions may limit certain actions by Glenview and its affiliates, potentially reducing the risk of hostile actions or public disputes .
- The non-disparagement obligations aim to maintain a cooperative relationship between CVS and Glenview, which could positively influence the company's public image and investor relations .
Legal Proceedings
Summary of the Legal Matter Involving CVS Health Corporation and Glenview Capital Management
Key Parties Involved:
Nature of the Proceedings:
Potential Financial or Operational Consequences for CVS:
Conclusion: The legal matter between CVS Health Corporation and Glenview Capital Management involves significant changes to the CVS Board of Directors and includes various confidentiality, standstill, and non-disparagement provisions. These changes and agreements are expected to have both financial and operational implications for CVS, potentially enhancing its governance and performance while maintaining a cooperative relationship with Glenview Capital Management.
Corporate Leadership
Board Change
CVS Health has announced the appointment of four new members to its Board of Directors: Leslie Norwalk, Larry Robbins, Guy Sansone, and Doug Shulman. This expansion follows discussions with Glenview Capital Management and increases the board size from 12 to 16 members. Norwalk will join the Health Services Committee, Sansone the Audit Committee, and Shulman the Management Planning and Development Committee .
Leadership Change
Leaving: No executives are reported to be leaving.
Stepping Up: J. David Joyner has been appointed as President and CEO, and Prem S. Shah has been appointed as Executive Vice President and Group President. Additionally, Leslie Norwalk, Larry Robbins, Guy Sansone, and Doug Shulman have been appointed to the Board of Directors .
Why: The appointments follow productive discussions with Glenview Capital Management to drive greater financial and operational performance and to enhance the company's strategic focus .
CEO Change
On October 17, 2024, Karen S. Lynch stepped down as President and CEO of CVS Health Corporation and resigned from the Board. J. David Joyner was appointed as the new President and CEO, effective the same day .
Financial Reporting
- Total Revenues: CVS reported a total revenue of $95.4 billion for the third quarter of 2024, marking a 6.3% increase compared to the same period in the previous year .
- GAAP and Adjusted EPS: The GAAP diluted earnings per share (EPS) was $0.07, a significant decrease from $1.75 in the prior year. The adjusted EPS was $1.09, down from $2.21 in the previous year. This decline was primarily due to a decrease in the Health Care Benefits segment's operating results, which included premium deficiency reserves of approximately $1.1 billion .
- Pharmacy & Consumer Wellness Segment: This segment saw a 12.3% increase in total revenues, driven by increased prescription volume and contributions from vaccinations. Adjusted operating income for this segment increased by 14.9% .
- Health Services Segment: Total revenues decreased by 5.9% due to the loss of a large client and continued pharmacy client price improvements. However, adjusted operating income increased by 17.4% due to improved purchasing economics .
- Health Care Benefits Segment: Total revenues increased by 25.5%, driven by growth in Medicare and Commercial product lines. However, the segment reported an adjusted operating loss of $924 million, primarily due to increased utilization and premium deficiency reserves .
- Restructuring Charges: CVS recorded restructuring charges of approximately $1.2 billion in the third quarter of 2024, as part of an enterprise-wide restructuring plan aimed at streamlining operations and reducing costs .
- Premium Deficiency Reserves: The company recorded premium deficiency reserves of approximately $1.1 billion, primarily in its Medicare and individual exchange product lines, which impacted the Health Care Benefits segment's performance .
Earnings Report
CVS Health Corporation Third Quarter 2024 Earnings Results
Financial Highlights:
Segment Performance:
CEO Commentary: David Joyner, CVS Health President and CEO, emphasized the company's commitment to delivering lower costs of care, a simpler experience, and better outcomes for health care consumers. He highlighted the strong performance in the Health Services and Pharmacy & Consumer Wellness segments, while acknowledging the challenges in the Health Care Benefits segment .
Significant Trends:
For more detailed financial data and reconciliations, refer to the full earnings release and accompanying financial statements .